Far Green Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1859
Report of Thomas Wynne (page 76)
No. 37 in Tabular List. — At Far Green, Hanley.
Is by far the most disastrous event of the year, and most to be regretted, as it was
caused by, I may almost say, momentary inattention.
On Saturday, the 5th November, about half-past two p.m., 16 men and boys were
coming up the pit in a cage from their work, the engineman being at his post; the
door was fastened, but the window, which is nearly on a level with the pit bank, was
open. It was raining at the time, and an overlooker named Tellett called Williams, a
timekeeper, to come into the window and give in his time. They had just sat down,
and one of them said to Gallon, the engineman, "Are we in your way?" when Gallon
leaned forward and said, "What did you say?" twice. During this time his attention
was drawn from the indicators and from the top of the pit, and the cage went over the
pulley. Some of the poor fellows were precipitated down the pit and some fell on the
pit bank. The engine being stopped at once, no material damage was done to the rope
or to the machinery. No blame whatever attaches to the management, for extra precaution
was taken of having two indicators, in case one should be out of repair. I have
always considered this a safe pit to descend, and this accident has not altered my
opinion, as you will see by my evidence at the inquest.
Mr. Wynne was examined. He said — In consequence of information which I received, I examined
the works at the Deep Pit on Monday morning. I examined the winding-engine, and measured the
distances. The engine was worked in my presence. The rope was let down and drawn up several
times. It was stopped and started again, whenever I wished it, by Peter Griffiths, engine-tenter. I
could not perceive the slightest difficulty in stopping it at any point that might be wished. The engine
is in every respect a proper one for what is required of it. The pit itself is distant 63 feet from the
handle of the engine, and that is a very short distance indeed. The height of the axle of the wheel
from the ground is 39 feet. The last stroke of the engine would raise the cage about 50 feet. I paid
particular attention to the indicators during the working of the engine, and I found them to work
exceedingly well. As far as my knowledge of inventions goes, I do not know that there are any better
indicators in use. I would make one suggestion as regards the machinery. I should consider it more
complete if the break were made to be applied always in winding up, instead of in merely fastening
the engine. When men regularly apply the break in winding up the rope they get habituated to it,
and they come to use it as a matter of course, but now the engine-tenter does not apply the break
until the engine is stopped. From the evidence which I have heard I can only account for the
accident by the neglect of the engine-tenter to stop the engine when he ought to have done. I have
myself been up and down the pit more than a half-a-dozen times, and in ascending I never knew the
cage go more than a foot above the ground, and therefore I judge there is no necessity that it should
do so.
A Juror. — Should you consider it any improvement if the indicators struck a little sooner?
Mr. Wynne. — I think not. The great advantage of the indicator is that the engine-tenter can see
the progress of the cage by it; but under the system of bell signals a man has to hear the bell struck
once before he begins to pay attention, and then he is sometimes too late. The excuse of engine-tenters
often was that he could not, for the steam, see the mouth of the pit, but in this case Gallon
had only to watch the indicator in the engine house. The engine-tenter ought to have his eye constantly
on the indicator, and not altogether to rely on the striking of the bell. I think the head-gear
is quite high enough, and that if it were higher the size of the wheels would put it in danger on a
rainy day. My opinion is that the engine-tenter had his eye upon the indicator very nearly soon
enough, and that it could only have been a matter of a second or two in the difference of the time
when the cage stopped and when it ought to have stopped, because, if the cage had been going at
great speed, the rope must have been broken. Supposing it to be true, as the witnesses have said,
that Gallon never left the handle, I am decidedly of opinion that he neglected to stop the engine at
the proper time. I cannot see any other possible way of accounting for the accident. I cannot too
strongly state my objection to men being allowed to go into the engine-room, as Tellitt and Williams
were. That, however, does not excuse Gallon, because he could stop the engine at the right moment
without seeing the pit at all. I think it right to remark that no person can go into the engine-house
through the door unless he has the key.
By a Juror. — It is quite a mistake to suppose that the engine-tenter can only stop the engine at
the beginning or end of a stroke.
Since this accident numerous inventions are about to be proposed and submitted, to
endeavour to prevent over winding, which I am about to bring under the notice of mining
engineers, and which I trust will result in the adoption of some plan to prevent the recurrence
of such calamities; and as Gallon has since been convicted of manslaughter at
Stafford Assizes, and sentenced to six weeks' imprisonment, I trust this case will be a
warning to all enginemen not to allow their attention to be drawn from the work they are
employed upon.