Heys Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1857
Report of Joseph Dickinson (page 25)
At Heys, the serious explosion in which 40 lives were lost occurred at a time when, so
far as could be ascertained, there was no suspicion of danger. The seam of coal in
which it took place is about three feet thick, and is called the New Mine, which is the
lowest and one of the most fiery at present worked in this colliery. The dip is steep,
being at the rate of 1 in 2, and the whole of the workings lie to the deep of the shafts.
The total distance to the extremity of the workings from the top of the pits being about
one mile. (See accompanying Sketch.) Everything seems to have been going on as
usual during the morning, and at dinner-time the engine which drew the coals up the
brow was stopped, and the doors of the two underground boiler fires were set open. This
continued until it was nearly time to resume work at 1.25 p.m., when the engineman
observed flame in the top of the underground engine-house, as though it commenced
from the flues leading from the boilers, and immediately afterwards flame spread about and
there was a violent explosion. The engineman who saw this was got out alive, but he
afterwards died from the burning. The other 39 who were down the brow, including
the taker-off at the top of the brow, who had gone down to see if the rails were clear,
were all killed, 30 of them being badly burned and many much mutilated. The workings
in the seam were going on in two principal places, one being about 280 yards from
the top of the engine-brow, called the "stumpings," where the coal was being got in the
return air by pillar and stall work ; and the other in the levels from the bottom of the
engine-brow and the up-brows which go out of these levels was all narrow work. It
was in the far ends of these levels, and especially up the up-brows, where the explosion
left most traces of fire, the coal in some of the up-brow workings being charred, and
the general direction of the blast seemed to be from the extremities.
Safety-lamps, some locked and some unlocked, were used in the workings ; and it was
only at the engine, on the engine-brow, at the lamp station on the level in the main
intake, and at the two boiler fires which were fed by return air where any open light was
allowed. Such being the conditions under which the mine was lighted, together with
the evidence of the engineman, it appears possible that the gas was ignited at the boiler
fires, the return air serving as a train into the inner workings. But as the engineman
was badly burned, he may not have clearly recollected whether he saw the flame or felt
the explosion first ; and as a safety-lamp, which had apparently been open at the time of
the explosion, contrary to the regulations, was found up one of the up-brows, it seems
probable that the gas was lighted at it. As to how the workings became charged to this
explosive state there was no direct evidence to show. The workmen who worked in
the night shift were unanimous in their testimony as to the sufficiency of the ventilation,
and did not think the explosion could have occurred unless some unusual quantity of
gas had been liberated, or some derangement had taken place in the ventilation. There
are three ways that occur to me to account for the foulness. First, a quantity of firedamp
may have issued from the old workings near the top of the engine-brow into the intake
air, and been carried hy it into the inner workings. Secondly, a sudden outburst of firedamp
may have taken place from the roof or floor, or from the seam itself in some
part of the mine. And thirdly, the quantity of air going into the workings at the
time may have been insufficient to dilute and render harmless the firedamp ordinarily
given off into the mine. As to the first of these suppositions, had gas come out of the
old works and gone in with the return air, it would probably have to pass an open light
which the taker-off had with him on the brow, and also the open light at the bottom of
the brow, at one of which it would probably have lighted before it reached the far ends,
where the fire of the explosion had evidently been most intense; besides, the air both
before and since has always been found to draw into, and never out of the old workings.
As to the second supposition, a small fault known to be near to a main fault had been
cut through about three yards, in the far end of the levels, and after the explosion there
was an audible and rapid issue of firedamp at the place. Firedamp was also audibly
issuing near the faces of the up-brows, but whether any other and more sudden issue
took place can only be conjectured. The third supposition, that the air going into the
inner workings was insufficient to dilute the firedamp ordinarily given off, is apparently
the most probable. Or it may be taken in conjunction with the second, namely, an
increased quantity of firedamp from the fault. There are several points tending to show
that leakage may have been going on and the ventilation weaker than usual at the
time. 1st. The coal, &c. about the flue and airway between the boiler fires and the
upcast shaft had been on fire a few months before the explosion, and the damage was such
that a new flue and airway were being made. This new flue connected the downcast
shafts with the principal upcast shaft, and it had doors in it. One witness stated that the
air was sometimes very strong in it, and although he withdrew his statement when he
discovered that the air so passing was all lost to the workings, yet leakage here was probably
one element causing the explosion. 2nd. The return air from two upper seams,
called the Bent mines, which were being worked went into the same upcast, and they
may have had more than a fair share of the air, which would weaken the ventilation in
the new mine. 3rd. A new level was being made from the engine-brow to the stumpings,
going from the main intake towards the return. It was stated that this level had not
been holed through before the explosion, and that there was also an air-door in it which
was closed ; but after the explosion, this level was found holed through between the
intake and the return, and the air-door blown to pieces by the blast. No one was at
work in the place, and it is impossible to tell with certainty whether the thin partition of
coal which it was said was left when the place was stopped had fallen down before the
explosion, or was blown down by the blast. 4th. The inner workings depended for air
upon check-doors between the engine and the boiler fires, separating the main intake
from the return air, through which doors the engineman had to pass and repass. 5th. The
air depended upon a similar separation between the main brow and the stumpings ; and
also upon numerous brick and mortar stoppings, where, as at the doors, if leakage
were taking place, it was so much air lost to the inner workings. 6th. It was about
the warmest time of a sultry day in July, when natural ventilation would be weakest.
It was also at the dinner-time, when the boiler fire-doors were both set open to slacken
the fires (which was the principal power upon which the ventilation depended), and when
no discharged steam from the cylinder was going into the flue to assist ventilation ; and
when possibly some of the younger workpeople were unthinkingly sitting in groups
obstructing the air; this just succeeding the time when the colliers had been in
full work laying bare fresh surfaces of coal, all pouring out firedamp. The airway man
also, it appeared, had just gone through the airway, against the air, which would be
some obstacle to the current, causing less air to pass. More work was also going on than
formerly in the up-brows, and the workings were becoming extended, whilst the ventilating
furnace which was formerly used, in addition to the boiler fires and steam, had
been discontinued. The firedamp in the mine is also of a pure kind, and sometimes
fires without any well-defined blue cap, which may have occasioned danger to pass
unnoticed. Altogether, seeing that the keenest parts of the explosion were in places
where firedamp would naturally lodge were the mine insufficiently ventilated, it seems
likely that the explosion originated from the workings being insufficiently ventilated ;
or that there was not sufficient surplus ventilation. The system of working pursued in
driving out the levels to the extremity, before beginning to get the coal back, is in
accordance with the best and safest system of working a fiery seam of coal in the
steep mines of this part of the country. But the pillar and stall work called the stumpings,
going on in the return air, and which had to be entered from the in-take, between
which trams and persons were constantly passing, introduces an element of danger which
is, in my opinion, a bad feature.
I stated at the inquest, that every great explosion which I have investigated has
occurred in mines worked upon the pillar and stall system, which is pursued in the
stumpings in this mine, and upon which system it is much more difficult to ventilate
efficiently, than when the seam is first drained of its firedamp by driving the levels to the
extremities, as by such course, when most air is wanted, any quantity can be brought to
bear at the extremities where the firedamp is chiefly generated. That, even with the
most skilful management, explosions in these steep and fiery mines, when worked by
pillar and stall work, without being first drained of their firedamp, seem unavoidable :
and it is not surprising that they should occur as often as they do, when, as in this case,
in my district nearly every colliery is managed on the surface ; that is, the owner and
manager (the owner of this colliery being a respectable type of such a class) gives
directions, but leaves the management to an underlooker, who although an intelligent
man selected from the workmen, is without the previous training required in a viewer;
and often, no doubt, does not possess the moral courage requisite to withstand the pressure
that is put upon him to send out more coal than the capabilities of the colliery will admit
of. That as the workings in many collieries are now getting deeper, and the winnings
becoming more expensive to make, more men are being put into the same pit, and that
unless accompanied by improved management, explosions will continue as before, and
become more and more fatal according to the increased number of men working in the
same mine. That there was ample work for one underlooker in this colliery ; but that
for about a month before the explosion he had had to divide his time between this colliery
and an adjoining one, no one being left in charge except the airway man, who had no
one to assist him on his duties being increased. That the firemen, five in number,
worked as colliers, and were therefore workmen, some other person than whom is, in
my opinion, intended by the term fireman in the rules. The explosion is a striking
illustration of the necessity of feeding furnaces and boiler fires with fresh air, and to
have safety-lamps locked and every open light excluded.