The Explosion at Lletty Shenkin.
David Sims was indicted for having, on September 15th, committed the manslaughter
of David Thomas. Mr. Grove, Q.C., and Mr. T. Allen, conducted the prosecution ;
Attorney, Mr. Hollier. Mr. Gifford and Mr. Rees defended the prisoner; Attorneys,
Messrs. C. and F. James.
Mr. Grove addressed the jury on the part of the prosecution, stating that the deceased
person, into the circumstances of whose death they were about to inquire, worked at the
Lletty Shenkin colliery, at which a serious explosion took place on September 15th, the
day named in the indictment. About fifteen persons were injured. The deceased and
another person met their deaths ; Thomas having had his head fractured, in consequence
of being driven with violence against portions of tbe colliery, by the fearful concussion
of air invariably following these explosions. The prisoner was trustee of the colliery, and
the prosecution contended that he was responsible for its management — either that it was
his duty himself to adopt proper means for the ventilation of the colliery, or, if it was not
his duty to do so himself, he ought to have found a competent person to do so. The
learned counsel produced elaborate plans, exhibiting the interior workings of the colliery.
He pointed out instances in which it was alleged on the part of the prosecution, the
colliery was inefficiently managed. It was admitted that, as it fortunately happened,
several lives had been saved in consequence of the fact that a certain door had been
opened, which enabled the carbonic acid gas or "chokedamp," to escape. This door
ought not to have been left open — in fact, it had been so left through negligence, although
the circumstance had fortunately turned out. After minutely describing the plans, the
learned counsel said that he wished to speak with eveiy respect of the acts of the legislature.
At the same time he could not help expressing his regret that the act lately
passed did not contain some more stringent enactments, with the view of rendering the
proprietors and managers of collieries responsible for the fearful catastrophes that took
place. The act only provided that immediate information of the accident should be given,
and had no further provision, the legislature probably thinking it sufficient to rely on
the common law of the land. Operations in this country were not now carried out as in
times of old, by single individuals. They were carried on by large corporations or firms,
and it became highly important in this state of society to see that persons having the
management of these institutions, should be responsible for any loss of life occurring
through their negligence. It would be observed that they could very seldom fix upon the
person whose immediate act had caused the death, and even when that could be discovered,
it often happened that these calamities occurred through causes over which proprietors
and head managers only had any control. If they were not liable, the lives of hundreds
might be sacrificed, and no person held responsible. The learned Counsel having cited
dicta of Mr. Justice Maule and Lord Campbell, concluded by stating that it would be
for the jury to consider whether the death of the deceased had been occasioned through
the negligence of some one, and if they decided in the affirmative, was it the duty of the
prisoner either to manage the colliery efficiently himself, or if not, did it devolve upon
him to appoint some competent party to do so. After some further observations, the
learned counsel called the following witnesses :—
P.S. Parsons examined : I am a Sergeant of Police at Aberdare, two miles from the
colliery. The explosion took place on September 15th. I have often been there, and
know the place, went there on the night in question, and know the injury done. I have
a list of the injured, and produced it before the Coroner. On the occasion in question,
fifteen or sixteen persons were injured, and two deaths took place. I have known the
prisoner for five years. He resides fifty or sixty yards from the colliery. He is an agent,
and I have heard him give instructions about the colliery.
Cross-examined by Mr. Rees : I have seen him speaking to the men ; witness has not
joined in the conversation.
Re-examined : The instructions he gave were respecting the works. He was telling
the men where to go for things. It was respecting the men on the surface that I heard
him give instructions, men working with the trams and things of that description.
William Evans examined : I am a surgeon. I am an assistant of Mr. D. Davies, the
surgeon called in after the accident. Mr. Davies is not here, as he labours under rheumatic
fever. I went up to the colliery after the accident, and saw two boys who had been
killed. One was David Thomas, who had sustained compound fracture of the skull. He
had evidently been brought in contact with some hard substance, with violent force.
Mr. Rees said he would admit that the death of the deceased had been caused by the
explosion.
Samuel John examined : At the time of the accident I was working at the Lletty
Shenkin colliery. I had been working there for eleven months. This accident occurred
on September 15th, in the middle of the day. When I first heard of the accident, I was
in the fourth stall in the dip. I was engaged in cutting coal at the time of the accident
The first thing I observed was the puff at the explosion of the firedamp coming to me.
I laid flat down as soon as I could. I sustained no injury ; but my hair was a little singed.
The explosion came from the lower stall, in the direction of the fifth lower heading.
There was plenty of fresh air where I was, and I never saw foul air or firedamp in that
heading.
Cross-examined : Have never seen Mr. Sims (surveyor) underground in the colliery.
Never heard him give instructions as to what was to be done underground. It was
Mr. John John who gave me instructions. There is seven yards between my stall and
that in which the explosion took place.
His Lordship (to Mr. Grove) : One of your heads of charge appears to have fallen to
the ground. You put it, that either the accident had occurred through prisoner's inefficient
management, or through negligence in not providing a competent party. The
first of these fails, because it would appear the prisoner did not interfere underground.
George Wynn examined : I am carpenter at the Lletty Shenkin Colliery. Was so
on September 15th. After the accident I went down into the pit to repair the door.
Found the pieces mostly blown to the west, but the door from the lowest, or No. 9,
heading was blown to the south. I had been for some time working in the colliery. I
have frequently seen printed rules in the colliery. They were published in English
and in Welsh. Used to revive them when they were dirty. They had been framed by
Mr. Dobson. (Rules put in, counsel directing particular attention to No. 16, which
precluded any of the men from working with a naked candle in any place which presented
the least appearance of firedamp.) At that time these notices were posted about the surface
only, now they were posted underground as well.
Cross-examined : It was Mr. Rees who appointed me. He died eight months ago.
Re-examined : Prior to Mr. Rees's death the prisoner never interfered. Cannot say
whether he has taken Mr. Rees's place. Have seen him manage the buildings, and things
of that kind. Since the accident Mr. Martin has been appointed manager. Prior to the
accident he used to inspect the plans. He surveyed the colliery after the accident. It
was John John who superintended underground since Rees' death. Prior to the death
of the latter he was under Dobson.
Herbert F. Mackworth, Esq., examined : I am the Government Inspector of coal mines
for South Wales. I have been so since Nov. 12, 1851. I inspected the colliery after the
accident. Whenever I went to the colliery I saw Sims there. I had a conversation with
him in reference to the colliery. I gave him several suggestions, and he subsequently
told me that my suggestions were being carried out, underground as well as overground
I remember an accident in this colliery in June 5, 1852. On the 22d of the same month
I inspected the colliery, and had a conversation with Mr. Sims. The first point to which
I directed his attention was the state of the guides, by which the colliers went in and
out of the pit. I told him that I had spoken to the underground man about defects in
the colliery, and matters that required improvement. The underground man was David
Thomas. At that time John John was not the overman. I did not go so much into
detail with Sims, but gave him generally what I told the underground man. He made
no particular reply, but admitted my remarks to be correct. He made no objection
to my cautioning him. On June 22d I addressed a letter to the principal agent of the
colliery, and subsequently asked Sims if the suggestions in my letter were being carried
out ? and he said they were. (Letter read.) I had some further conversation with him
as to the overground works. I told him that a previous accident had taken place in
consequence of neglecting my instructions about the guides.
The learned judge said that it really appeared to him that the evidence did not show
that this gentleman personally interfered with the underground workings of the colliery.
Generally speaking, a person could only be held civilly responsible when, as a trustee or
proprietor, he did not provide for efficient management of works.
Mr. Grove observed that the question was, assuming that he did not personally interfere
in the underground operations, whether, as a trustee, it was not his duty to appoint
an efficient person to do so ; and that if it could be shown that the omission arose from
his negligence, whether he could not be made criminally responsible. The great evil in
the case was, that it would appear from the divided responsibility, that no person could
be fixed, whatever might happen.
His Lordship said that it struck him strongly that the evidence was not such as would
show the defendant criminally responsible. The testimony of Mr. Mackworth went to
show that he had spoken to the prisoner principally respecting matter on the surface.
He had generally referred to the overman on matters connected with the underground
workings.
Mr. Grove : Here was a letter addressed to the principal manager at the colliery,
which appeared to have been received by the prisoner, who evidently acted as such
manager. He thought the facts ought to be brought out, and if they were not such as to
justify a conviction, he would not wish to press the case.
His Lordship : You are now adverting to the general question.
Mr. Grove said that he could call John John and another overman to show that they
had not received this letter.
His Lordship : The prisoner may be civilly responsible, but the circumstances of the
case were not, in his opinion, such as to make him criminally so. Generally speaking, a
man could only be held criminally responsible for his own personal negligence ; civilly, he
would be responsible for the acts of his agents or servants. He did not mean to say that
extreme cases may not occur in which a man would be criminally responsible for the
negligence or incapacity of another — such a case, for instance, as knowingly to send a
boy, or a person known to have no experience, as a driver of a railway engine with passengers.
Here was certainly no evidence of such extreme culpability in the case.
Mr. Grove : The prisoner in this case, my Lord, had received ample cautions and
warnings. He had been present at the inquests held on the bodies of the sufferers, in
previous explosions.
His Lordship : The cases in which you have cited the opinions of Lord Campbell and
my brother Maule, are as different as possible from this case. In those cases death had
resulted from the personal culpability of the prisoner. From your opening, it would
appear that the main charge against the prisoner was that he had appointed an incompetent
person, whereas the evidence went to show that he had appointed no one. The
parties having to do with it appeared to have been appointed by someone else.
Mr. Grove : Well, I have stated to your Lordship all that the prosecutors are prepared
to prove. We mentioned that he, as trustee and manager of the colliery, ought to have
appointed a competent person to attend to the underground management.
After some futher discussion his Lordship told the jury that it did not appear to him
that the evidence was sufficient to render the prisoner criminally responsible, although
he may be civilly so. Excepting in extreme cases, a proprietor, trustee, or manager
could not be held criminally responsible for the acts of his servants. The learned judge,
therefore, directed the the jury to to acquit the defendant.
Verdict, "Not guilty."