Accident No. 46 in the List.
Explosion at Lower Elsecar Colliery, near Barnsley.
This mine was in the Barnsley coal (9½ feet thick), at a depth of 154 yards,
and employed about 140 persons.
The ventilator was a fan, eight feet diameter, placed under ground, and
driven by a steam-engine at the rate of 170 revolutions per minute; fire-damp
prevailed more or less ; Davy lamps were used to light the works ; and two
"fire-triers" were appointed to examine the pit in a morning, and to superintend
the operations during the day.
The air was "split" into two currents, one of which traversed the northern,
the other the southern district.
In the latter was a pair of west bord-gates, driven to the "rise," and considerably
in advance of the "banks" or "stalls," towards a couple of new pits that
were being sunk for the purpose of improving the ventilation.
At noon on the day of the accident the "fire-triers" were not on duty, and
in their absence a boy propped open a trap-door, on which the airing of the
before-mentioned west bord-gates depended ; the door remained open about
half an hour, during which a quantity of gas collected in the upper part of the
bord-gates, and when the air was restored to its proper channel by shutting the
door, the accumulated gas travelled with the current until it reached a point
where a man was working with his Davy-lamp gauze screwed off, and a
dreadful explosion followed.
Here was a concurrence of two reckless acts of disobedience ; first, the
leaving open of a door ; and second, the removal of the top of a safety-lamp ;
and the two combined led to a catastrophe which destroyed ten persons and
injured twelve others.
The open door might not have produced fatal results if the lamp-top had
been screwed on ; and in all probability one or both of these violations of rule
would have been prevented, or discovered in time to avert the disaster, if the
superintendents had been in the pit as they ought.
The following is an abstract of the evidence and observations offered at the
inquest, which was ably conducted by Mr. Badger, the coroner. Earl Fitzwilliam's
solicitor and agents, the Government Inspector of Coal Mines for the
district, and a number of witnesses, were present.
Joseph Hodgson said : I am a "fire-trier" in the Low Elsecar pit ; my duty
is, along with William Ford (another fire-trier), to examine the works and
see that they are safe before the men go down.
We went into the pit on the day of the accident at four o'clock, A.M., and
inspected the whole of it; we found it safe to work in.
I left the pit about six o'clock, and went down again about half-past eight.
Ford remained in the pit. It is the duty of one of us to remain in the pit all
day, but we left it at half-past eleven, and we did not return until after the
explosion, which took place at a quarter past one o'clock.
We turned a stream of water down the engine-pit to cause ventilation, and
then we descended to search for the men.
We got some of them out from the north district, uninjured. On the south
side some stoppings were blown out, which we replaced with sheets, and we
forced the air forward to the southern extremity of the mine.
We found nothing amiss between the third and fourth bord-gates, but in the
second and other bord-gates ten doors were blown out, and a number of
stoppings.
I did not find any of the dead bodies, they were discovered by others.
Every collier was furnished with a Davy lamp when at work. On the following
day we made a search for the missing lamps ; one was found where
Stenton laid, and the lamp-bottom was about two yards from the lamp-top ;
in Mallinder's bank we also found a lamp without gauze.
It is supposed that a boy named Lindley left a door open in the long west
bord-gates, and the gas accumulated in them ; and when the door was shut
again the air carried the gas to Stenton's bank, and fired at his naked light.
(By Mr. Morton, the Government Inspector.) The colliers descend at six
o'clock. Our orders are to go at four and examine the pit. There are no
candles allowed in the works, but an oil-lamp is used at the bottom of the
upcast pit.
There is not a furnace, but the pit is ventilated by a fan, invented by
Mr. Biram.
I have charge of the safety-lamps, but I do not examine them every day.
We have a man to clean and trim the lamps, and formerly they had locks on
them, but they have been taken off by the colliers, who don't like lamps with
locks.
I am afraid they unscrew the lamp-gauzes sometimes, but they have orders
not to do so.
We have no fines, but a person would be discharged for disobedience. If a
lamp wants trimming during the day, it must be taken to the pit bottom.
We have no positive directions that Ford and I should remain in the pit all
day, but I think it is the duty of one of us to be in the pit at all hours when
the men are at work.
(By Mr. Newman, the solicitor to Earl Fitzwilliam.) I attribute the accident
to the opening of the trap-door, and to working with a naked light.
It is supposed that Lindley propped open the door, and that Swift afterwards
shut it. I believe the explosion took place where the deceased Stenton worked,
his lamp-top having been taken off.
On the morning of the explosion the air was going up to and returning from
the face of the long west bord-gates, and all the stoppings were good.
William Ford said : I am a fire-trier, along with the last witness.
On the morning of the accident I examined the workings of the north, and
Hodgson visited those of the south district.
I found the north side in a safe condition, and Hodgson said the south side
Was safe.
After breakfast we again inspected the workings, and found all right, except
in a goaf between the first and second bords of the southern district, where a
little fire-damp was perceived, and I told Dickenson and Mallinder, who were
near it, to be careful; I showed them the gas, and cautioned them not to go
into it ; I also told Stenton to be careful.
Hodgson and I went out of the pit at half-past eleven o'clock, and we had not
returned when the explosion happened at a quarter-past one.
We have always gone out together at meal times, and we have not had positive
orders that one of us should remain in the pit when the men were at work.
I considered the pit was safe ; the accident was caused by setting open the
door in the long west bord-gates; and the subsequent shutting of it conveyed
the gas to Stenton's naked lamp.
Swift told me that he found the door open and that he shut it.
After the explosion we went to the underground engine, and tried to start the
ventilating fan, but it was disabled, and the after-damp was so strong that we
were obliged to leave it.
On the north side we found five men at work who did not know what had
occurred.
In the south district several doors and stoppings were blown out by the explosion,
and we hung sheets to restore the air to its proper course.
The door that had been propped open was blown out ; here we found Moulson
alive ; we next came to the dead bodies of Fletcher and Stenton ; after
wards we found Dickenson and Mallinder dead ; and in the first bord-gate on the
south side Walker and Hurst lay dead.
(By Mr. Morton.) The rule is, that the colliers are not to go down in a
morning until Hodgson and I report the pit to be safe.
I did not traverse the long west bord-gates on the day of the accident, and I
did not consider it needful to examine those bord-gates every day.
We work the banks with Davy lamps, but I did not think it necessary to do
so, and I believe the works will be quite safe when they are repaired up again.
We have not allowed the lamp-tops to be unscrewed.
The coal is blasted, the shots being fired with touch-paper. I have frequently
seen the gas ignited by the gunpowder, and sometimes serious mischief has
ensued.
Occasionally the men remove the lamp gauzes to snuff the wick ; I do not
fine them or discharge them, but I admonish them.
I found a lamp without gauze in Stenton's bank, and I found another near the
door that had been propped open. We have always given strict orders not to
leave doors unclosed.
After working hours Hodgson or I ought to see that all the doors are shut,
and that the air is going properly.
We have sometimes absented ourselves, and we have not regularly remained
in the pit during working hours as we ought.
The air generally has been good, and we have not had any person killed in this
pit during five years.
The ventilating fan goes night and day, and only stops when it is broken.
John Swift said : Immediately after dinner on the day of the accident I found
a door in the long west bord-gates propped open with a brick, and I shut it.
Lindley and I were the only hurriers that passed through the door, and
Lindley was the last to come through it.
The door stood open more than half an hour, and the explosion took place
five minutes after I shut it.
It ought not to have been propped ; I never found it so before, and the rule
is not to leave doors open.
I work with a safety-lamp ; we take the lamp-tops off sometimes, but not
every day.
The masters have told us not to unscrew the gauzes.
When I came through the door at dinner-time, Lindley followed me ; I
opened the door and propped it with a brick, and Lindley ought to have shut
it. I cannot say whether he shut it or not.
John Beardshall said : I am a labourer in this pit, and was between the first
and second bord-gates in the south district when the explosion happened.
There was a good air where I worked.
I always use a lamp, and we are told by Ford and Hodgson not to remove
the gauzes.
James Moulson said : I was in a bank on the south side of the long west
bord-gates at the time of the explosion.
Swift and Lindley took coals away from me, and I saw them go to dinner; I
remained in my place, and just after dinner I felt a blast, and I was taken home
insensible from the effects of afterdamp .
It was Swift's duty to open the door, and Lindley's duty to shut it immediately
after he passed through.
George Charles Hague said : I am clerk to Mr. Biram, Earl Fitzwilliam's
colliery viewer.
On the day after the explosion we found a lamp-top in the long bord-gates,
and we found a lamp-bottom without a gauze in Stenton's bank.
The pit was generally in good working condition prior to this accident ; the
quantity of air varied from 25,000 to 33,000 cubic feet per minute.
The fire-triers paid great attention to the state of the goaves, but I think it
was not expected that one of them should remain in the pit during working
hours.
(By Mr. Morton.) I have nothing to do with the management of the pit, but
I go down occasionally.
This pit always has been, and is now, more fiery than any other in the neighbourhood,
but owing to its strong ventilation it was considered safe to introduce
naked lights.
I should not now like to dispense with safety-lamps, on account of the
quantity of gas and the neglect that sometimes occurs at the trap-doors.
When the pit was first opened safety-lamps were absolutely necessary.
(By Mr. Newman.) Although I think the banks might have been worked
with candles, the colliers had strict orders to use lamps.
James Utley said : I am underground steward at this pit ; I instructed
Hodgson and Ford to see that the safety-lamps were kept in proper order ; they
were to go down at four o'clock a.m. and examine every working place, and
every goaf; and if they wanted my opinion on any matter, I gave it.
We have no printed or written rules as to the working of the colliery, and I
never saw any such elsewhere.
I did not particularly direct Hodgson or Ford to remain in the pit all day, but
they were to visit the workings several times daily ; and in the afternoon when
coal work ceased, they were to see that all the doors were shut, and the air going
right.
I never saw any of the men using naked lights ; if I had I should have sent
them away.
Hodgson told me that a collier took his lamp-top off, and I immediately
discharged him.
I was not in the pit on the day of the explosion, but I was there on the previous
Monday to examine a goaf that contained gas, and I turned some air into
it which cleared it.
I did not descend the pit again until the day after the accident.
(By Mr. Newman.) I am not aware that it is customary at neighbouring pits
to have written or printed rules. Hodgson has no instructions to examine the
Davy lamps, unless the men bring them to him for that purpose.
The colliers take their lamps out at night ; Denton trims them, and delivers
them next morning.
The lamps are not locked, and there are not any locks on them.
(By the, Jury.) One hundred and seventy lamps are provided for this pit. If
the lamps are taken home by the colliers, they ought to be examined before
they are used again.
Hodgson told me that the men complained about the lamp-oil being bad, and
that it did not burn well, but coked on the wick, and they could not see to work.
Either Hodgson or Ford should be in the pit until evening, but there is no
particular order about that.
(By Mr. Morton.) It is the fire-triers' duty to go every morning into every
working place, and also to inspect the works at the close of the day.
They are neglecting their duty if they examine the long west bord-gates only
twice a week.
We have no defined hours for their attendance at the pit ; I believe they are
allowed to go out together to dinner, and I have not fixed at what hour they
are to return in the afternoon.
I cannot say that either of them really go down the pit every day after
dinner ; I have not given them any orders on the subject.
I am both top and bottom steward, and I have four working shafts to
attend to.
There are no locks or pickers on our lamps ; the men would have them taken
off, but I did not give my consent one way or other.
Denton trims the lamps, but does not inspect them ; and I am not aware
whether Hodgson examines them daily or not.
Mr. Biram is responsible for the ventilation of the mine, but I should be
blamed for defective doors or stoppings, or for a want of brattice boards.
If the men work twenty or thirty yards out of the air-course without brattice
boards, it is unknown to me, and I have not prohibited their doing so.
We do not send any person specially to attend to the ventilating fan only on
Sundays ; the men working at nights have orders to attend to it ; but there are
not people in the pit every night, and it is not any particular person's duty to
attend to the fan at nights.
William Ford looks after it during the day in addition to his other duties.
I don't think it prudent now that the fan should be left unattended in the
night.
I had a man for a long time to work it, but three months ago he discontinued.
I have frequently examined the long west bord-gates where the explosion
occurred ; we have had considerable "blowers" of gas there, and one of them
was so strong as to occasion a fire that burnt for two hours.
I have not prohibited the blasting of coal with gunpowder, except in the long
west bord-gates, where it was dangerous ; and I stopped the blasting there some
time ago.
The firing of the shots is done by the colliers, and we have not any person
appointed to direct when and how the shots are to be fired.
We do not use either a barometer or a thermometer at this colliery.
Mark Barber said : I was in the north district of the pit when the gas
exploded on the south side, and it did not injure any of the workmen on the
north side.
I complained to Hodgson about the lamp-oil being bad; it coked upon the
wick.
Good oil would last until night, but we have been obliged to unscrew the
gauzes in the banks, to remove the coke from the wick.
I cannot say whether the lamps are examined in a morning, but I believe not.
Charles Morton, of Wakefield, one of Her Majesty's Inspectors of Coal Mines,
said : Yesterday along with Messrs. Biram, Woodhouse, Jeffcock, and others,
I examined the pit, with a view to ascertain the state of the mine and of the
ventilation, and to discover the causes of the recent explosion.
My belief is, that in consequence of the leaving open of the door in the
long west bord-gates, gas accumulated in the upper portion of them. They
have been driven in advance of the rest of the works for a length of about
300 yards.
The effect of shutting the door by the boy (Swift) would be to restore the
air to its usual course, i.e. up one of the bord-gates and down the other ; the
air current thus restored, and also rendered inflammable by the gas that had
collected in the bordgates, then passed northward into Stenton's bank, where
it came in contact with a naked light (a Davy lamp without a gauze), and
ignited.
With regard to the ventilation of the mine, the air has been judiciously
divided by Mr. Biram into two distinct portions, one of which goes along the
North Levels to ventilate the northern district of the mine, and the other
travels on the South Levels to ventilate the southern district.
If the air had not been so divided, but carried in one stream, a great loss of
life would have arisen from suffocation in the northern district, where it appears
the workmen remained safe.
Yesterday, the volume of air on the south side of the pit was rather more
than 8,000 cubic feet per minute, and on the north side about 12,000 cubic feet
per minute.
In my judgment this amount of air may be, and ought to be doubled ; and,
if the air is not considerably increased, naked lights must be rigidly excluded.
I did not perceive gas to a dangerous extent in the goaves. I observed some
working places twenty or thirty yards out of the air-course that were not
furnished with brattice-boards ; this want of air is at all times unhealthy to the
collier, and often perilous.
I think the trap-doors are unnecessarily numerous, and a diminution of their
number is practicable and expedient, and would tend to lessen the risk of
accident from their being left open.
The doors are not fixed in such a manner as to insure their shutting of
themselves, and casualties may arise from this circumstance.
The doors are not fixed in such a manner as to insure their shutting of
themselves, and casualties may arise from this circumstance.
It is satisfactory to find that the "fire-triers" examine the works prior to the
descent of the colliers in a morning ; and it is needful for the safety of the
latter, that a similar watchfulness should be continued without intermission
throughout the day.
This pit ought never to be left during working hours without a superintendent ;
and if on the day of the explosion the "fire-triers" had remained on
duty, it is very likely that they would have discovered the open door and
naked lamp in time to avert the disaster.
It is unsafe to leave the ventilating fan unattended during the night, and
such inattention may lead to serious results.
It is gratifying to hear that the "fire-triers" are expected to go round the
works at the close of the day, and see that they are left in a safe and proper
condition ; but from the evidence already adduced it is uncertain whether this
excellent regulation is, or is not, strictly and constantly complied with.
Concerning safety lamps, they ought to be daily inspected, cleaned, trimmed,
and locked by a careful man appointed for the purpose ; but it is obvious that
the duty has been partially and loosely performed.
Many of the Davy lamp-gauzes are too coarse in the mesh ; they have fewer
than 600 apertures in a square inch, and they ought to have 784, which is the
number recommended by Sir Humphrey Davy, and a decrease of that number
may lead to explosion.
It is further desirable that every gauze should be fitted with a bright tin
shield, which reflects light and protects the flame from the action of rapid
currents of air.
In reference to the removal of gauzes in the works, there has been a laxity
of discipline ; the lamps are not furnished with wire pickers, therefore the wick
cannot be trimmed with the tops on ; and as there is not a lamp-station or a
lamp-keeper under-ground, the colliers prefer to run the risk of unscrewing the
gauzes in the mine, rather than lose time by ascending to the surface, where
the lamp-cabin is inconveniently placed.
When the smoking of tobacco is permitted, and the blasting of coal with
gunpowder is indiscriminately practised, it is not surprising that the workmen
should presume occasionally to take off lamp gauzes.
The combustion of tobacco and powder is inconsistent with the use of safety
lamps ; and if the blasting of coal be continued, it ought to be placed under
the superintendence of prudent and competent persons.
I recommend that the lighting by Davy lamps (with the additions and
improvements on it which I have suggested), should be persevered in ; and that
the system of watching, airing, and managing the mine should be conducted on
those methodical and salutary principles which characterize the best regulated
collieries of Durham and Northumberland.
I feel it my duty further to allude to the absence of fixed rules, either written
or printed, at this colliery, and to advise the adoption of orders and regulations
somewhat similar to those now in use at the Shipley, Swanwick, Cinderhill,
Babbington, Granville, and Moira collieries in the Midland Counties ; and a
printed copy should be given to every person employed at this establishment.
(By Mr. Newman.) Having heard the evidence with regard to the cause of
this accident, are you not of opinion that it might have happened with all the
precautions you have suggested ?
(Mr. Morton.) It might, but I think it improbable that it would. In such
a fiery mine one steward ought to be constantly on duty during working
hours, and the presence of both the stewards would be desirable where 140 men
and boys are using safety lamps.
I do not consider the continual presence of two stewards is absolutely necessary,
but prudent and commendable ; and emergencies frequently arise which
would require the services of both stewards as long as the colliers were at
work.
(Mr. Newman.) Is it possible for one or even two stewards to see all the
underground works every half hour, so as to be sure that the trap-doors are
shut and the lamp-tops on ?
(Mr. Morton.) Two stewards might do it; but I think they would be
unreasonably hurried.
(Mr. Newman.) Then, unless they were unreasonably hurried, all that happened
in the half hour during which the door was open might have occurred without
two stewards discovering it in time to prevent the mischief?
(Mr. Morton.) It is possible, but I think unlikely.
If there were two stewards continually perambulating the works, it is not
likely that hurriers would leave doors propped open, or that colliers would
habitually unscrew their Davy lamp gauzes on pain of dismissal if detected.
John Thomas Woodhouse, colliery viewer, said : Yesterday I carefully
examined the workings of this pit, in company with Messrs. Morton, Biram,
and others.
In many places I did not find gas sufficient to fire in the lamp. There was
a level driven south for a distance of thirty-one yards without artificial
ventilation, but there was not any firedamp in it.
In some of the works I found gas issuing, and in others I perceived only a
trace.
I examined several of the goaves, which I found ventilated, and free
from gas.
In the third bord-gate on the south side, I saw a wall that had been shaken
by the explosion, and at a point in this locality the gas fired in our lamps.
In the neighbourhood of the third bord-gate I found strong evidence of the
effects of the explosion.
Almost all the brick stoppings in the long west bord-gates had been blown
out, and at the western extremity, gas was escaping from the cracks in the
coal.
The bank on the north of these bord-gates was in ruins from the violence of
the blast, but I found no gas there.
It appeared that the fire had extended beyond the No. 1 south bord-gate,
and burnt two men, but I did not find any gas there.
In the first north bord-gates the stoppings had been blown out and were not
all restored ; consequently, they were filled with gas.
I examined the whole of the north side workings, and goaves, and found the
air much better than it was on the south side, but I did not see any gas.
As to the cause of the explosion, I concur entirely in the opinion of Mr. Morton,
the Government Inspector.
With respect to the ventilation, I approve of the mode which has been
adopted of dividing the air into two currents ; the value of which was proved
by the fact that the colliers in the north district were not aware of the explosion
having taken place.
Without the concurrence of two circumstances, namely, the leaving open of
the door and the removal of the lamp-top, the accident could hardly have
happened.
Nevertheless, I should now recommend that an increased volume of air
should be introduced into the pit, and the fan worked and watched day and
night.
The evidence of Mr. Morton includes every suggestion that I could have
made.
As regards the laxity of discipline which Mr. Morton referred to, I am
satisfied that the fire-triers thought they were doing what was best for the
security of the workmen.
(Mr. Morton.) Would you, under your own direction of a fiery colliery, have
permitted the various derelictions of duty, discipline, and management, of which
we have heard here, relating to doors and lamps, the inattention to the fan, the
absence of both fire-triers in the middle of the day, and the omission of all
printed or written regulations ?
(Mr. Woodhouse.) Certainly not; because the experience that I have had in
the Midland Counties has proved the needfulness of establishing the strictest
discipline ; and I have found it absolutely necessary to issue printed rules to
all the workpeople at the collieries under my control.
Thomas Dunn Jeffcock, colliery viewer, said : I examined this pit, in
company with the Government Inspector, and others.
Having heard the evidence given by Messrs. Morton and Woodhouse, who
have so correctly and clearly described our progress, I do not think it requisite
to repeat the details.
I think that with proper care of the lamps, the ventilation was sufficient for
the safety of the mine. I concur with Messrs. Morton and Woodhouse as to
the cause of the accident.
I think there has been laxity in regard to the Davy lamps, and I am of
opinion that one fire-trier should always be in the pit during the hours of work ;
but the general management and mode of ventilation I consider to be good.
If the fire-triers were to find a larger amount of gas than I saw yesterday, it
would then be necessary to increase the volume of air, which might easily be
accomplished by driving the fan at a greater speed.
Unless the quantity of air be now considerably augmented, I would not
venture to introduce naked lights into the pit.
Printed rules are not generally adopted in this locality, but I believe the
Oaks Colliery, near Barnsley, has printed rules.
Robert Charles Webster, colliery viewer, said : Having heard the evidence
given by Messrs. Morton, Woodhouse, and Jeffock, I agree with them as to the
condition of the pit, the cause of the explosion, and generally as to the suggestions
thrown out by them for the future management and discipline of the mine.
George Lindley, after being cautioned by the coroner as to the effect of any
statement he might make, said : I was tramming on the day of the accident ; I
got my dinner in the pit, between twelve and one o'clock, and then the explosion
took place.
I am not guilty of what is laid to my charge, for I did not leave the door
open. Swift propped it open, and I do not know who came through it after
me.
Benjamin Biram said : I have been mineral agent for Earl Fitzwilliam about
thirty years.
I do not offer any further testimony as to the origin of the explosion, and I
have not the slightest hesitation in confirming the statements made by Messrs.
Morton, Woodhouse, and others on the subject.
With respect to the air which has been circulating through the pit, I affirm
that it was amply sufficient to clear away all the gas which was likely to be
found in any of the workings, provided no neglect had occurred.
I think that every precaution has been taken with regard to the inspection
of the pit, and I have no reason to suppose that the officers employed under me
had not done their duty to the best of their judgment.
Mr. Morton believes that the fire-triers have not attended properly, but when
the works had been twice examined on the morning of the explosion, and no
symptoms of danger appeared, I apprehend that no great blame can be attached
to the fire-triers for not being in the pit during the space of an hour and a half
at noon.
Concerning the safety-lamp discipline, I regret that it has not been stricter,
and that the rules and regulations which are enforced elsewhere have not been
observed here.
As regards working the pit with safety lamps, there is probably not one
colliery proprietor in ten in this locality who would have thought it necessary
to use them.
I believe that scarcely any firedamp is to be found in the bank-faces. What
ever gas exists in the coal is liberated by driving the bord-gates, which are
generally kept 30 or 40 yards in advance of the banks, and it would undoubtedly
be prudent always to drive them with the aid of lamps and brattices.
With respect to the endings, the fact that gas is hardly ever seen in them is
confirmatory of what I have already said as to the safety of working the banks
with naked lights, for if firedamp existed to any extent, it would certainly be
found in the endings.
It has been said that to work the mine without safety lamps it would be
necessary to have double the volume of air ; but with ten times the quantity of
air, unless colliers are careful, there cannot be exemption from explosions. If
a hurricane could be driven through the airways, and this door had been left
open, it necessarily follows that the gas which accumulated in the long west
bord-gates would have ignited on coming in contact with a naked light.
As to the gauze of the lamps being coarser than that recommended by Sir
Humphrey Davy, it has been used under the most trying circumstances in this
pit, and it still retains the confidence of the men.
With regard to the fan being left during the night without any person to
attend to it, probably a wrong impression may prevail ; it is worked by steam
from the boilers at the surface, and it is kept going night and day.
It is seen by the fire-trier at the close of the day, and he visits it again at
four o'clock next morning ; and if in the interval anything happened to stop it,
the only effect would be to delay the descent of the colliers, if, on inspection by
the fire-triers, the pit was not found in that secure state which is requisite before
the workmen are permitted to go down.
A safe condition of the works may also be produced by a waterfall, which can
be passed down the engine-pit, so that danger will not arise even if the fan were
stopped for some portion of the night.
Until within a limited period a man did look after the fan in the night, but
latterly it was thought unnecessary.
If the fan is left in motion in the evening and found going next morning, we
infer that it has not stopped during the interval.
The inferiority of the oil has been mentioned. I try to provide oil of the
best quality, and I have no reason to suppose that it has not been obtained.
A few weeks ago a sample of oil was sent to me for experiment, and it was
thought somewhat inferior ; but I afterwards tried it in my own office, and it
appeared to me good.
All the Davy lamps had originally wire pickers, and many had locks ; the
workmen preferred the lamps without pickers and locks. My own opinion is
that it is better to have both, but I did not consider these additions to the lamp
of sufficient importance to insist upon them being used.
With respect to blasting the coal with gunpowder, I have always thought
that I might safely leave it to the discretion of the underground steward.
As regards safety lamps, I am conscious of the responsibility attaching to the
production of a lamp of my own, possessing the principle of safety, with the
additional advantages of cheapness and increased light, from the possibility of
its leading to diminished exertion to attain complete ventilation. I strongly
deprecate the use of any safety lamp as a substitute for abundance of air ; but
where efficient ventilation is established, my own lamp can be employed in a
current of air too strong for the burning of a candle, and it is a preventative of
accident arising out of any sudden influx of firedamp.
I have felt, however, that I could not urge the use of my own lamp in the
pits under my control ; and therefore it has been left to the workmen whether
they would adopt it or not. It combines the several principles of safety which
Mr. Morton thought necessary, it is locked, it has a shield to guard it from a
current of air, and with a mesh of Sir Humphrey Davy's standard, it will yield
four times the light of an ordinary safety-lamp.
The "fire-triers" are under the direction of the underground steward, who
appoints them, and has power to discharge them, and I consider him responsible
for their efficiency.
I have not ordered that one of them should always be on duty during
working hours, and I do not know a pit in this neighbourhood that has two
fire-triers.
Mr. Badger, the coroner, then addressed the jury as follows :— I will
endeavour to bring before you such portions of the evidence as, in my opinion,
are important to be borne in mind in considering your verdict.
The explosion, which has caused the death of the ten persons whose bodies
you have viewed, occurred in the afternoon of the 22nd December 1852.
The pit has been worked five years, and this is the first fatal explosion which
has happened since the workings commenced.
At four o'clock in the morning, Hodgson and Ford, the fire-triers, commenced
their usual underground examination, in which they spent two hours, and they
found everything safe ; then a second inspection was made about half-past eight
in the morning, when Ford found on the south side, and near where the explosion
subsequently took place, indications of the presence of firedamp in a "goaf,"
which led him to caution Dickinson, Mallinder, Stenton, Battison, and others,
(of whom the first three were killed,) not to enter the "goaf."
At the first and second sitting of this inquest, there appeared to be some
doubts as to whether it was the rule, that one fire-trier should always be in the
pit during working hours : Hodgson states that there is such a rule, whilst
Ford, his colleague, is not aware of it. But, I think from what has been said by
Messrs. Utley and Biram, you may conclude that one of them was not always
required to be in the mine.
The fire-triers state that they left the pit at half-past eleven, and before their
return, the explosion which resulted in the death of ten persons, and the injury
of twelve others, had occurred. Hodgson and Ford are both of opinion, (and
in this they are corroborated by the evidence of Mr. Morton, the Government
Inspector, and of Messrs. Woodhouse, Jeffcock, and Webster, experienced
colliery viewers,) that the explosion was caused in the following manner:—
The trap-door between the long west bord-gates on the south side of the pit
was propped open by some person, whereby the usual current of air was diverted.
This led to an accumulation of gas in the upper portion of the bordgates.
When the door was closed by Swift, the air returned to its accustomed course,
and the current thus restored and rendered inflammable by the accumulated
firedamp, passed from the bordgates into the bank, where Stenton was working
with the gauze of his Davy lamp screwed off, when the gas fired, and produced
the disaster.
Swift states that Hodgson and Ford had given positive orders that the
doors were to be kept closed ; Swift shut the door on his return from dinner,
and in five minutes afterwards the explosion took place.
The jury must bear in mind the position in which the bodies were discovered,
and the condition of the safety-lamps. The bodies were found in and near to
the first and second bord-gates on the south side.
In the second bord-gate, Stenton was found dead, and his safety-lamp was
found without gauze.
The witnesses state their belief that the gauze had been unscrewed, (a very
common and dangerous practice with colliers,) and that the separation of the
parts could not have been caused by the explosion.
The ventilation of the pit appears from the evidence of the Government
Inspector to have been judiciously arranged, but not sufficiently strong.
There are the usual downcast and upcast shafts, and a ventilating fan (the
invention of Mr. Biram), which is worked by an underground engine, and is
kept continually in motion.
The air is divided at the bottom of the downcast shaft into two separate
currents, one being carried through the north, and the other through the south
district of the mine.
The Government Inspector and Mr. Woodhouse state, that if this plan had
not been adopted, a more awful loss of life would have arisen from suffocation
by after-damp in the northern district, where a large number of workmen
remained uninjured, and in ignorance of an explosion having taken place. It
appears that, if the miners had been working with their lamps perfect, the
accident would not have occurred ; and that the leaving open of the trap-door,
would not alone have caused the deaths of these persons, had not they, with a
recklessness of consequences too common among men similarly employed,
deprived themselves of the safeguard which science has devised for them.
It is for you to decide whether it required both the keeping open of the door
and the presence of naked lights to cause the explosion. If you are satisfied
that both these circumstances occasioned the accident, then, since the person
whose lamp was found without the gauze has lost his life, you may decide
whether any and (if any), what person still living is criminally answerable.
If, from the testimony of Swift, and from the voluntary statement of Lindley,
who, although he denies having left the door open, yet does it in such a way as
to leave little doubt about the fact, you are satisfied that Lindley left the door
open, you must then decide as to the amount of blame attaching to him.
It appears that it was the duty of the first trammer to open the door, and of
the last trammer, immediately on passing through, to shut it.
But this is a duty somewhat different from the definite and special duty of a
person charged to do a particular act, as in the cases of Regina v. Haines
(2 Carr. & Kirw., 368), and Regina v. Barrett (idem, 343). In the first of
these cases the prisoner Haines, being a bailiff of a mine, whose defined duty it
was to see to its general ventilation, was accused of negligence in omitting to
construct an air-heading, in consequence of which an explosion of firedamp,
resulting in the death of a man, took place.
In the second of these cases an engineer, having the management of an
engine supplying a pit with air, neglected his duty, from which neglect death
ensued.
In both cases the prisoners were acquitted ; the first upon the merits, and the
second under the direction of Mr. Justice Wightman, upon a technical objection
to the indictment. And here I must explain to you that, if death be occasioned
by the neglect of several, they are all guilty of manslaughter ; and it is no
defence for one who has been negligent to say that others have been negligent
also, and thus as it were to divide the negligence amongst them.
In this case you must be satisfied, firstly, that the opening and subsequent
closing of the door was the cause of the explosion ; secondly, that it was the
duty of the last trammer to shut the door ; thirdly, as to the person who left
open the door ; and fourthly, whether there was in such person alone, or along
with others, an amount of gross negligence, a want of ordinary caution, or a
reckless disregard of the safety of human life, amounting to the crime of
manslaughter.
There are many gradations of culpability before we arrive at that which
constitutes manslaughter.
Where the moral blame ends, and the criminal liability begins, is generally a
very difficult task to decide.
That task, with the evidence as your guide, and to the best of your skill
and judgment, it is now your duty to perform.
Before the jury deliberate upon their verdict, I wish to call the attention of
all persons present, who are interested in the working and management of
coal-pits, to the evidence of the Government Inspector, and the experienced
colliery viewers who have been examined. In all cases of mining accidents
which I have had to investigate, (and unfortunately they have been many, and
amongst the most awful that have occurred in the kingdom,) two things have
always been apparent, namely, laxity in the discipline of the pit and recklessness
of the workmen.
Until by education or otherwise, the miners can be taught that however
small may be the value which they put upon their own lives, they have no
right to appraise so lightly the lives of their fellow labourers, I am afraid that
even comparative safety in collieries will be difficult to attain.
But much may be done to this end by the exertions of intelligent managers,
who are placed over this important branch of our industry.
I trust that Mr. Biram will lose no time in carrying out the suggestions
of the Government Inspector, supported as they are by the opinions of
Messrs. Woodhouse, Jeffcock, and Webster.
The absence of printed rules is much to be reprehended. The use of safety
lamps should be strictly enforced, on pain of discharge. A miner who works
with a naked light, should be instantly discharged and punished ; for although
Mr. Biram may think that some of the banks can be worked with candles, yet
as he cannot prevent careless boys from leaving doors open, a similar accident
may again occur, if naked lights be used.
Supervision of the safety lamps should at once be established. The gauzes
appear to be too coarse ; they ought not, according to Sir H. Davy's opinion,
to have less than 784 apertures in the square inch. The lamps should all be
locked, and furnished with tin shields and wire pickers, as recommended by the
Government Inspector. The oil should be of the best quality, Smoking
tobacco in the mine should be prohibited, and blasting by gunpowder (except
under the direction of an intelligent steward) should not be permitted.
The continual attendance day and night upon the ventilating fan, and the
constant presence of at least one fire-trier in the pit during working hours,
appear to be absolutely necessary.
If the colliers were liable at any moment to be discovered working with
naked lights, and when so discovered instantly dismissed, the dangerous
practice of unscrewing the gauzes of the Davy lamps would be quickly abandoned.
These suggestions of experienced witnesses I have thought it my duty
briefly to recapitulate, in the earnest hope that the gentlemen now present, and
others who, by means of the press, may have their attention drawn to this
important subject, will be induced to study the evidence taken at this inquest,
and thereby be urged to increased activity in their endeavours to prevent a
recurrence of these fearful calamities.
The jury then found a verdict of "accidental death," and strongly recommended
that the suggestions of the Government Inspector, as to the improved
working of the mine, should be immediately carried out.