Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Source: 1889 Mines Inspectors Report (C 6015), East Scotland District by J. B. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, page 34

The Mauricewood Pit Disaster

(This report embraces a period up to the end of April 1890.)

On the 5th September 1889 a fire took place in the Mauricewood Pit of the Penicuik Coal and Ironstone Mine, causing the loss of 63 lives.

The usual inquiries by Mr. R. L. Stuart, the Procurator-Fiscal for the county of Edinburgh, and myself, as Inspector of Mines for the district, were made into the accident.

A special inquiry under section 45 of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1887, was held by your direction by Mr. Henry Johnston, Advocate, Edinburgh, as Commissioner, and Mr. Thomas Bell, Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines, Durham, as Assessor.

On the evidence as to facts given at the inquiries and from examinations of the mine and inquiry made by myself and the Inspectors assisting, Mr. R. McLaren and Mr. H. Johnstone, I beg to submit the following report:—

Description of the Mine.

The workings of the Mauricewood Pit are situated in the parish of Glencorse, county of Edinburgh.

The mine is owned by the Shotts Iron Company, Limited, and has been in their possession since the year 1875. The Shotts Iron Company own other collieries and mines in the counties of Lanark and Edinburgh; and have blast furnaces in operation at Shotts, in Lanark.

The affairs of the Company are controlled by a Board of Directors, of whom Mr. Robert Bell is chairman, Mr. A. W. Turnbull is the secretary and general commercial manager. Mr. John Love is the certificated manager of the Penicuik Mine; the other officials at the Mauricewood Pit at the time of the fire were:—

George Muir, oversman, killed by the fire.

William Gall, mechanical engineer.

Edward Lydon, inspector or fireman.

George Hunter, inspector or fireman.

David Penman, inspector or fireman, killed by the fire.

Robert Dickson, roadsman, killed by the fire.

James Somerville, roadsman, killed by the fire.

On the 5th September there were employed at Mauricewood Pit —

Underground  77 persons.
Above ground  25 persons.
Total  102 persons.

When the fire was first observed there were 70 persons underground, and of this number 63 were lost and 7 survived. A list is appended showing the occupation, name, age, where working, and when recovered of the persons killed.

The Mauricewood Pit is situated on the west side of the Midlothian coal field; this coal field lies partly in the county of Edinburgh and partly in the county of Haddington; it is about 21 miles long and about 8 miles wide, and is entirely separated in a landward direction from the other coal fields of Scotland. The coal field embraces the upper or true coal measures and the lower or carboniferous limestone coal measures, and is underlaid by the oil shale or calciferous sandstone measures. The Midlothian coal field is characterised by the extremely steep inclination of the beds at many points and by the general absence of fire-damp. Where the beds are lying at more than 45° they are locally known as "edge" seams.

The strata mined at the Mauricewood Pit, a section of which is given on Plan II., lie in the carboniferous limestone or lower coal series; the measures near the pit dip to the southeast at the rate of 40° to 50° for a horizontal distance of about 400 yards from the outcrop ; beyond that distance they flatten out. The seam worked is a composite seam, and is known as the Great Seam.

The Penicuik Mine comprises two establishments, the Greenlaw and Mauricewood Pits, situated about 1,000 yards apart in a direct line, and connected underground by a single road marked on Plan I. as "Communication Road."

At Greenlaw there was a vertical shaft up which mineral was raised and which was downcast for air, and an incline in the seam from the surface known as No. 1 incline. This incline was upcast for air; it was fitted with ladders and contained steam pipes.

At Mauricewood there was only one communication from the surface, a vertical shaft 19½ feet by 5½ feet, and 84 fathoms deep. The shaft was divided by a wooden mid-wall into two sections; one 14½ feet by 5½ feet, downcast for air and containing pumps, two cages and dook ropes ; the other 5 feet by 5½ feet, upcast for air and containing steam pipes. The incline extending from the surface at Mauricewood, and marked on Plan I., No. 2 incline, was closed and not in use. The shaft passed through the Great Seam at 59 fathoms from the surface, and was continued 25 fathoms below. From the point where the shaft intersected the Great Seam an incline in the seam extended into the basin ; this incline was reached at the level of the bottom of the shaft by a level crosscut mine at a point called the dook head. See Plans II. and III.

The various levels, to be mentioned hereafter, were named from their distance down the incline from the dook head, and considerably exceeded in vertical depth from the surface the distance their name indicated.

The Mauricewood and Greenlaw Pits were separate establishments in every respect, except that the Greenlaw shaft was the second shaft or outlet for Mauricewood Pit in compliance with section 16 of the Coal Mines Act, and that the Greenlaw water flowed to the bottom of the Mauricewood Pit; both these purposes being fulfilled by the single communication road already mentioned.

Mining operations at Mauricewood had been commenced at the outcrop as shown by Plan I., and the mineral was then drawn to the surface by the abandoned No. 2 incline. As the workings extended downwards the shaft had replaced this incline, and from near the bottom of the shaft the incline had been driven in the seam still deeper until the bottom of the basin was reached. In driving the main incline a companion incline had been driven with it nearly the whole distance. This second incline was used as a return air way from the 80 fathom level upwards, but below that point it had been abandoned and replaced by a new road marked on Plan III. "ladder way and new pipe upset."

At the time of the fire the whole output was being obtained from the basin or flat portion of the field.

The mine was free from fire-damp and coal dust, and the ordinary Scotch miners' open light was used throughout.

The general features of the mine may be gathered from the plans; a more detailed description will be given under the heads of —

Working faces.

Carriage of mineral to the surface.

Ventilation.

Pumping water.

Ingress and egress of workmen.

Working faces. — These are shown on Plan I. On the east side ironstone was worked longwall; on the west side coal was worked longwall below the ironstone waste. Carriage of mineral to the surface. — The ironstone and coal were filled at the working faces into hutches, which were pushed to the lye or siding by drawers. The ironstone from the east side passed down a self-acting endless chain incline, and was then drawn by ponies to the foot of the main or winding incline. The coal from the west side was drawn direct from the lye to the main incline by ponies. These roads were of the ordinary size. Three ponies, each about 12½ hands high, were used. The main incline was traversed from the 160 fathom level to the dook head by two carriages running on wheels on rails laid to a 3 feet 3½ inch gauge ; these carriages held two hutches each, and were worked by ropes proceeding from a hauling engine on the surface, the ropes passed down the downcast section of the shaft to the point where the Great Seam was cut and then direct down the seam. The carriages worked like cages in a shaft, one descended while the other ascended. The main incline was 11 feet wide by 5½ feet high ; the roof wras ironstone, which required little timber ; the sides were lined with a continuous wooden barring 3 inches thick, this barring was covered in places with canvas brattice cloth to prevent leakage of air. At the dook head the laden hutches were removed from the carriages and pushed along the level crosscut mine by runners to the foot of the shaft, up which they were drawn singly in cages running in wooden guides. The level crosscut mine was about 8 feet wide by 5½feet high.

Ventilation. — The ventilation of the mine was caused by a Waddle fan on the surface, 18 feet diameter, and ordinarily making 45 revolutions per minute. The natural heat of the mine and the heat from the steam and exhaust steam pipes, to be described hereafter, must have assisted the ventilation. The air descended the downcast side of the shaft in one-column to the point where the Great Seam was cut; here it divided, one portion passing direct down the incline to the dook head, where it was rejoined by the other portion, which descended to the bottom of the shaft and passed along the crosscut mine. The whole current, with the exception of scales, which were large and will be described; descended the main incline to the 120 fathom level, where the air, intended for the ventilation of the workings, split into two currents, From this point the course of the two currents was stated to be as follows. The west side split passed to the bottom of the main incline, then along the haulage road to the west, round the coal faces and back to near the foot of the main incline as shown on Plans I. and III., where it crossed above the east side haulage road by a natural air crossing and into the pipe upset.

The east side split passed into the 120 fathom level on the west side of the main incline, across the main incline by a natural air crossing (in which a door is shown which was kept open, see Plan III.), along the 120 fathom level, down two roads of from 2 feet to 3 feet square in the waste as shown on Plan I., thence to the ironstone faces, returning by the east side haulage road to an engine-house at the 160 fathom level; this engine house was at the bottom of the return upset and was separated from the 160 fathom level by a wooden partition which was stated to be open to the passage, of air at the top and at the east end, a door at the west end of the partition usually stood open, but if shut did not prevent the passage of air into the engine-house by the openings already mentioned, see Plan IV. The air then passed a regulating door above the engine-house marked R on Plans III. and IV., and which, it was stated, was kept a few inches open, and so into the pipe upset where it joined the west side split. This regulating door was set in a wood frame partly covered with canvas brattice cloth.

The east side haulage road between the bottom of the main incline and the engine-house at the 160 fathom level was open and contained no door. It was stated by Mr. Love that there was no movement of air in this portion of road under ordinary conditions, but that if the regulating door above the engine was opened wide then air passed direct from the main incline to the pipe upset — as under any conditions it would appear likely to have done. One witness stated that the regulating door in the upset at the 160 fathom level was closed, and that the east side air passed to the foot of the main incline, and then passed into the west side.

The east and west side currents after joining in the new pipe upset ascended in one current to the 80 fathom level. From this level to the top of main incline there was a return air way on each side of the main incline, namely, the pipe upset and a ladder way on the west side; by means of two natural air crossings at the 80 fathom level, one above and one below the main incline, a portion of the return air from the east side of the main incline passed to the west side.

The return air passing to the west side travelling way by the undercast air crossing passed through an engine-house at the 80 fathom level; by closing a door in the overcast air crossing the whole west side current was forced through the engine-house. It was stated that this door was under the control of the engineman, and it was found about half open after the fire.

The return air passing up the pipe upset from the 80 fathom level crossed above the main incline by a natural air crossing about 5 fathoms from the dook head and joined the air coming up the west side travelling way, and the whole passed up the seam to the upcast section of the shaft which it entered about 30 fathoms above the bottom.

It was stated that up to within a few months of the accident the ventilation had been arranged on a different plan ; the air descended the main incline in one current to the 160 fathom level where it split, the west side current, passing as already described, but the east side air passed in a reversed direction, entering the pipe upset at the 120 fathom level, the door in the air crossing there being closed.

The dimensions of the return air ways from the west side working faces to the pipe upset and of the intake air ways for the east side from the two descending roads already described appear to have been about 5 feet by 4 feet. These roads were not examined until after water flooding the mine had been removed, and then, owing to falls, a complete examination was not possible.

The dimensions of the pipe upset between the 160 fathom level and the 80 fathom level were about 8 feet by 3 feet, this area being reduced by crowns, props, steam and water pipes, and ladders, see Plan II.

The pipe upset above the 80 fathom level was measured in nine places, and the mean dimensions were 5 feet 8½ inches by 2 feet 11½ inches, this area was reduced by crowns, props, steam, exhaust steam and water pipes, and ladders to an average effective area as an air way of 4 feet by 2 feet 11½ inches, see Plan II.; the minimum effective area as an air way for a short distance was 2 feet 6 inches by 2 feet 9 inches.

The west side travelling way was about 4 feet by 3 feet 6 inches.

The single road into the upcast shaft from the dook head level was about 5 feet by 6 feet.

The upcast section of the shaft as already stated was 5 feet by feet reduced by the area taken up by steam pipes and collarings.

The following data are available as to the quantity of air circulating in the mine :—

(1.) The last monthly measurement of the air before the fire was made on the 28th August at two points near the foot of the main incline marked A. and B. on Plan I., and on the 160 fathom level.

The east side split measured as return air 1,953 cubic feet per minute.

The west side split measured as intake air 1,915 cubic feet per minute.

(2.) Mr. Love stated that he had measured the air passing along the crosscut mine and found it to be 14,000 cubic feet per minute, but he had made no entry in the ventilation book to this effect.

(3.) After the fire it was found that of the whole air descending the shaft on one occasion 45 per cent., and on another 30 per cent., of it came direct down the seam.

(4.) Before the fire on the 6th February 1889, Mr. H. Johnstone measured the air in the crosscut mine and found it to be 8,640 cubic feet per minute.

Mr. Love's measurement of the air in the crosscut mine, 14,000 cubic feet per minute, is probably too large. 10,000 cubic feet per minute may be assumed, and if we assume this to be 75 per cent. of the total quantity, we have 13,333 cubic feet per minute descending to the dook head, and of this quantity 3,868 cubic feet per minute was measured on the 160 fathom level.

The large loss of air between the dook head and bottom of the main incline was accounted for by air passing to Greenlaw Pit by leakage through the door in the communication road, by air passing direct to the return by leakage through a door in the dook head level, by air escaping from the main incline to the pipe upset above the 80 fathom level (which was stated to be large in quantity), and by air allowed to pass through a rhone or air box and past a door at the 80 fathom level. There would probably be some further loss of air below the 80 fathom level, particularly at the 120 fathom level, where the intake and the return air ways were separated by a stopping of brattice cloth.

The leakage of air from the main incline to the pipe upset was what might be expected, considering that these roads were separated by only about 9 feet of strata; this strata was said to be crushed and not air-tight.

The door at the 80 fathom level between the intake and return air ways is marked A. on Plan IV. It was made of plain deals &¾ inches thick, and had two cross pieces. It was hung on two hinges and opened to the main incline. It was not hung so as to close by its own weight; for the purpose of closing the door there was a balance weight on a chain passing over a fixed pulley and attached to the door. The door when pushed open to the full, or approaching the full extent, caught the bottom, and then the weight did not close it. It also appeared that if the door was opened rapidly and the weight jerked against the pulley it stuck there and the door did not close. The door did not close tight, and there was space at the top, sides, and bottom through which air leaked; a flap of canvas was nailed to the bottom of the door, which is not shown on the plan.

The normal direction of the pressure of air on this door was from the intake to the return and tended to keep it close.

The internal dimensions of the rhone or air box were 7 inches by 5½ inches ; it extended into the engine-house as shown on Plan IV.

It appeared that the enginemen had been in the habit of keeping the door A. a few inches open by placing an obstruction between it and the frame, so as to obtain a supply of fresh and cool air from the main incline, and that the rhone had been put in to meet their requirements.

Pumping water. — An engine on the surface raised water from the bottom of the shaft for 18 hours per day. The growth or quantity pumped was equal to 260 gallons per minute throughout the whole day.

An engine at the 80 fathom level, situated in the return air way, forced water to the dook head for 17 hours per day. The quantity of water pumped was equal to 94 gallons per minute throughout the whole day.

An engine at the 160 fathom level, situated at the bottom of the return air way, forced water to the 80 fathom level for 10 hours per day during the night. The quantity of water pumped was equal to 36 gallons per minute throughout the whole day.

The steam for the two underground pumping engines was brought down the upcast section of the shaft, along the level crosscut mine, and down the return upsets, see Plan III.; the pipes were 5 inches diameter, and were covered with composition, felt, and zinc.

The engine at the 160 fathom level exhausted into water at that point, the exhaust steam from the 80 fathom engine was carried in pipes to the bottom of the upcast section of the shaft.

The water pipes were laid in the return upsets, and were 6 inches diameter.

Ingress and egress of workmen. — The ordinary route between the surface and working faces was by the cages in the Mauricewood shaft, by the crosscut mine, by the carriages on the incline, and by the haulage roads from the foot of the incline.

Alternative routes from the 160 fathom level to the 120 fathom level were (1) the two intake air ways in the waste. These roads were of small size lying at a high inclination, and were not fitted with ladders. After the water flooding the mine was removed the farthest east of these roads was travelled and found to be an available route ; and (2) the pipe upset by which also the 80 fathom level could be reached; this road was fitted with ladders laid on the pavement. The temperature of this road under ordinary conditions is not known, but it would probably not be excessive. The upset could be entered either by passing through the engine-house at the 160 fathom level and through the regulating door, or by the west side return air way.

From the 80 fathom level to the dook head level there was the return air way on each side of the main incline, both provided with ladders. The temperature of the return air way on the east side was too high to permit of its use as a travelling way. The temperature of the return air way on the west side was stated to be such as to allow of its use as an ordinary travelling way.

From the dook head level to the Mauricewood shaft there were two roads besides the crosscut mine: (1) the return air road in the seam fitted with ladders, but of a high temperature; (2) the continuation of the main incline, which was not provided with ladders.

From the dook head level the Greenlaw shaft could be reached by the communication road.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z