Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Source: 1878 Mines Inspectors Report (C 2321), Manchester District by Joseph Dickinson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, page 57

Explosion in Unity Brook Colliery, 12th March 1878.

The explosion in Unity Brook Colliery, Kersley, near Manchester, by which 43 lives were lost, occurred at 10 minutes past 1 o'clock noon, on the 12th March 1878. Two seams of coal were being worked. The depth to the upper seam, called the Trencherbone, being about 300 yards; and to the lower, called the Cannel, about 360 yards. There were two shafts, with a winding engine at each, the downcast being the ordinary winding shaft for both seams. The workings were of small extent; the length on the level course being only about 350 yards, and the breadth from rise to dip about 200 yards. The dip was at the rate of about one in four, and the workings were on the dip of the shafts. Open lights were used in working both seams. Safety lamps being only used for examinations. The explosion took place in the lower or Cannel Mine. The workings in it as shown on the accompanying plan were divided into east and west sides by an engine plane or downbrow. There were five levels at each side, each of which had been driven out to the boundary, where the cut throughs were all completed from one level to another, and the pillars commenced to be worked back towards the shafts.

It appeared that in the pillar work at the east side a sink of ground and fall of roof took place about a month before the explosion, but not any such fall or sink had occurred at the west side. Early in the morning of the day of the explosion Mr. James Holt, the under-looker, on going his round as fireman in that mine before the men came down, found a little roof fallen in the west pillar work. But in other respects things were as usual. In the course of the morning he was called back to this fall by his assistant, William Mayoh. On returning he found the fall considerably increased, it having come down 3 or 4 feet in thickness over an area of about 10 yards by 7, and the roof was still settling down upon the gob walling which had been built for its support. Like most experienced miners accustomed to fire-damp, he was aware of the old rule and practice in this district that when roof is falling or likely to fall, especially if it be the first fall of roof in that part of the workings, open lights shall be excluded; but apparently it neither occurred to him, nor to any of the other experienced colliers at the place, that this being the first break in the roof in this part of the workings was just the kind of fall most likely to be accompanied by an issue of firedamp. He went on the top of what had fallen and found good air passing, and having arranged with his assistant to set a strong prop under one part, he went away to other duties, leaving the men at work with naked candles. Having finished in the Cannel Mine he went up into the Trencherbone, and after being there an hour or two he went up to the surface. It was then 1 o'clock. His usual time for coming up was an hour or two later, but the manager, Mr. Isaiah Johnson, being away that day on colliery business, he had to see to affairs on the surface. On entering the cage to come up the shaft from the Trencherbone mouthing he found a miner in it named Ralph Welsby, who was coming out from the east side of the Cannel Mine. It was also before Welsby's usual time for coming out, but that had apparently no signification, as he had arranged beforehand to visit a sick child. Ten minutes afterwards the explosion took place. All left in the Cannel Mine, 42 in number, and the onsetter at the Trencherboue mouthing, lost their lives. Both shafts were disarranged, some of the brick casing being blown out, timber broken, and landing plates torn up. One of the cages of the downcast shaft was at the top and the other at the Cannel at the time. The one at the top was not much damaged, as the blast there got vent through an opening underneath. No time was lost in roughly re-arranging things, and the rope that was down the shaft being fast was slung and disconnected. Holt then accompanied by two men named Teesdale went carefully down. They descended to within about 5 yards of the Trencherbone mouthing, when the further descent of the cage was stopped by debris in the shaft. Holt then got out and by climbing down the conducting ropes reached the Trencherbone mouthing and there found men alive.

At the time of the occurrence I happened to be engaged on office duties and was enabled in response to a telegram to reach the colliery at about 3 p.m., or within two hours after the explosion. I found that an iron hoppet had been substituted for the cage in order to pass the debris in the shaft, and by this means Holt was bringing men up from the Trencherbone. The air coming out of the upcast shaft was strongly admixed with after-damp, but there was no smell indicative of the mine being on fire. Fresh air was drawing down the downcast, but the men as they came up smelt strongly of after-damp, and some appeared to be suffering from the effects of it. They stated that they had heard no sign of life from the Cannel Mine, and that the fresh air only descended to the Trencherbone where it became mixed with suffocating after-damp which was coming up from the Cannel. Some mining engineers from neighbouring collieries had arrived, including Mr. Edward Pilkington and Mr. Simon Horrocks. We held a brief consultation on the pit bank, as to the after-damp in the downcast shaft, and quickly decided to continue getting out all who were known to be alive before making any change, lest all might be lost. These men, about 30 in number, having been got up from the Trencherbone, I then descended the shaft with Holt, he being the only person there in authority, to see if anything could be done for the men in the Cannel. We took with us two buckets of water to dash down and reverse the current in the event of finding it hovering on the balance or upcasting from the Cannel. On arriving at the Trencherbone we found the current had resumed its ordinary course and was downcasting. Had it been as reported by the men, it might have been serious for us as in consequence of the indicator on the winding engine not being accurately arranged to the hastily extemporised winding arrangements, and there being no one left down to signal the engineman to stop, the hoppet was lowered a few feet below the mouthing. On being raised to the mouthing we looked about for the missing onsetter, but without finding him. We saw that the main air doors were right and the furnace fire out, and then made the attempt to reach the Cannel, but found the pit so choked with timber and other rubbish as to need the aid of workmen to clear it away; and having shouted down the shaft without receiving any reply we returned to the surface and sent down the pit carpenters. In an hour's time they returned bringing with them the dead body of the onsetter which they had found amongst the rubbish in the shaft. Five hours had now elapsed since the explosion. Holt, myself, Mr. Woodward, and Mr. Grimshaw then entered the hoppet and descended, and creeping down among the rubbish in the bottom, avoiding contact with the shattered surroundings, we got into the Cannel Mine. The place was hot, with some after-damp which smelt strongly and affected the eyes, but which was apparently sufficiently admixed with air to be respirable. We first tried to go along the upper west level leading to where the roof had been falling in the morning, but the after-damp and fire-damp was too strong to admit of our going many yards. Leaving this we went down the engine brow, passing amongst considerable destruction, and went through the other parts of the mine as quickly as possible. All the men we came upon were dead. Their bodies were all burned and some of them badly injured, nearly all apparently lying where they had been first struck by the blast. The air doors and screens were blown away, yet without replacing a single one, or doing anything to restore ventilation, we got into all the workings except the inner parts of the two upper west levels. On getting to the lower side of where the ground had been falling in the morning we found an extensive fall, which was still falling a little. Having thus ascertained that no further life remained to be rescued we returned to the shaft. It was then about 8 p.m., or seven hours after the explosion, the exploration of the Cannel Mine having occupied us about two hours. That time, although short for such work, had appeared long to friends on the surface, anxious to know the result or to lend assistance. The manager also having returned, had with Mr. Martin and others descended to the Trencherbone, and Mr. James Stott, the managing partner, had come. To these and others deeply interested we communicated our sad news. I then, having first assisted in arranging what should be further done for the safety of those to be employed in temporarily restoring the ventilation and bringing out the bodies, returned home, leaving the colliery officials to carry on the work.

Next afternoon I again visited the pit. The upcast shaft had been explored and found damaged like the downcast, and the bottom nearly choked with rubbish, which had either fallen or been blown there. Such of the rubbish as materially obstructed the ventilation or made the required passage unsafe had been cleared away, and temporary screens put up to send the air current to the far ends, and all the bodies except three, which were afterwards found under the rubbish in the sump hole, had been carried to the shaft, and were being sent up in the hoppet. The fall in the west pillar work could now be reached and examined at the higher side as well as the lower. It now extended about 25 yards by 20, being about seven times the area it was when Holt left it before the explosion, and had fallen from several feet in height. The termination of it at the higher side was a small slip, as smooth as glass, but which only extended a few feet up and then ceased, the fallen part beyond having broken from ordinary roof stone. Fire-damp was issuing freely out of the cavity into the air current underneath. The mine almost throughout was coated with dust, and near the fall there was a deposit of soot. The fall was the centre from which the blast radiated. Timber, trams, air screens, and all the air doors, except two in the top level at the east side of the downcast shaft, where the blast had got vent up the shafts, were driven from this fall. Flame had apparently travelled with the blast all over the workings, and it seemed that either two currents had clashed together near the fall in the east side pillar work, or a little extra gas had been sucked out.

Afterwards, on the 18th March and 2nd May, when I was again in the pit, fire-damp was still issuing at the western fall, but in decreased quantity.

On the 15th January 1879, and on the anniversary of the explosion when I, again visited the pit, the pillaring had advanced about 100 yards from the fall, and fire-damp was still issuing at the explosive point from the fresh breaks. The issue of gas from the roof of the mine is therefore beyond any doubt.

At the inquest held by Mr. Coroner J. Broughton Edge, the evidence showed that for six months prior to the explosion no accumulated fire-damp had been found in the mine; the latest appearance being on the 22nd September, which was before the cut throughs between the levels had been completed at the far ends. The bodies of all the miners who worked near the fall were found out of their places of work, as though they had either not returned after being out for dinner or had come out consequent upon finding the roof to be on the move. In either case, probably lighted candles would not be left in the places which would admit of a large space between them and the fall to become filled with an admixture of gas before coming in contact with any candle, and thus account for the violence of the explosion. The underlooker and the collier who came out of the pit with him 10 minutes before the explosion testified to the air being all right when they left; and a large number of others including relatives of the deceased spoke as to the general safety of the mine. The only risk mentioned by any of them was from falls of coal and dirt, which are at times unavoidable in working, particularly in steep and jointy seams like these. One old miner stated that the air in the mine was as fresh as on the turnpike road, and when questioned about not using safety lamps to work with, maintained (as did others also) that considering the various kinds of accidents to be guarded against it was safer on the average to work a mine like this with open lights. There had been no pinching in the airways. The engine plane was between 7 and 8 feet wide and 4 feet 4 inches high, each level and airway being that height and 6 feet wide, with larger spaces at the pillaring. The air was divided into two main currents or splits, one ventilating the east and the other the west side, with a ventilating furnace in the Trencherbone Mine. Measurements of air are frequently unreliable even when taken with great care; however, they showed that in the Cannel Mine 16,000 cubic feet of air was passing per minute, which was declared ample for these small workings. The only conclusion, therefore, that could be arrived at was that the explosion occurred from an outburst of fire-damp accompanying the first main break of the roof in the west workings.

Safety lamps are now used in both seams, although against the expressed wish of many of the miners who have to undergo the risks. Their fear is that with the poor light of the Davy lamp more accidents will happen from falls of roof and coal. Possibly, however, if safety lamps had been in use, especially self-extinguishing lamps in an explosive mixture, the explosion might have been avoided. But inasmuch as open lights were in use, the great error of judgment was in not excluding them when the first break of roof was occurring. This omission is the more remarkable as in the succeeding difficulties attending the rescue of the men from the upper seam, and the exploration in the lower, the underlooker in charge showed himself to be possessed of practical knowledge and presence of mind.

Twelve years ago, on the 10th December 1866, a similar outburst of fire-damp accompanying a first break of roof occurred in the same seam of coal at the Bank Colliery, Little Hulton, when 8 lives were lost and 14 others, including the underlooker and fireman, were burned. On that occasion only safety lamps were allowed to be used, but some of the miners thinking that precaution unnecessary had opened them.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z