Source: 1878 Mines Inspectors Report (C 2321), North Staffordshire District by Thomas Wynne, H.M. Inspector of Mines, page 60
Explosions of Fire-damp.
On the 27th March the Apedale Explosion occurred, by which 23 lives were lost, entailing great distress of mind by the delay in the recovery of the bodies, and an immense sacrifice of property to the owners; but to their credit it should be stated that, beyond the allowance from the Hartley Fund, they have themselves provided for the widows and orphans without any extraneous help, and they have now completed and set to work the very powerful Guibal fan that had been ordered previous to the sad catastrophe which it is now my painful duty to record.
With the able assistance of Mr. Maule, Q.C., the whole facts of the case were clearly brought out, and with the plan of the workings to refer to, the following evidence will be pretty well understood :—
The Apedale Colliery Explosion.
The Inquest.
An inquest on the bodies of the 23 men killed by the explosion of gas at the Burley Pit of the Apedale Colliery, which took place on the 27th March Inst, was resumed on Tuesday, at the George and Dragon Hotel, Chesterton, before Mr. Booth, coroner.
The names of the deceased are:
| Caleb Whalley (29), Apedale. | John Stockton (15), Silverdale. |
| Frederick Whalley (13), Apedale. | William Baggalley (25), Silverdale. |
| John Hackin (16), Silverdale. | Albert Handy (15), Silverdale. |
| Edward Smith (32), Silverdale. | Henry Piper (28), Halmerend. |
| William Bostock (15), Silverdale. | Abraham Riley (43), Boon Hill. |
| Joseph Braddock (28), Silverdale. | John Taylor (16), Newcastle. |
| William Baggalley (14), Silverdale. | Joseph Baggalley (35), Newcastle. |
| James Higginson (35), Silverdale. | James Mayer (60), Chesterton. |
| Thomas Dale (20), Silverdale. | Thomas Hughes (28), Chesterton. |
| Henry Yarwood (17), Silverdale. | Richard Fowler (60), Chesterton. |
| John Sanders (26), Silverdale. | James Cork (21), Wood Lane. |
| John Edwards (28), Silverdale. | |
Mr. Maule, Q.C., watched the proceedings on behalf of the Treasury; and Mr. Wynne and Mr. Gilroy, Government inspectors of mines, were also present. Messrs. T. J. Udall and J. Strick represented the company of Messrs. Stanier and Co., proprietors of the colliery; Mr. W. Brown (miners' agent), was also present.
The Coroner briefly reminded the jury of the purpose of the inquiry, and, without going into details, called
Mr. James Cope Cadman, mining surveyor, in the employ of Messrs. Stanier at Apedale, who produced plans he had prepared of the Burley Pit. The several seams were marked as the Bullhurst 8-ft, 7-ft., and 10-ft., and he explained the various features of the plans. The depth of the shaft was 484 yards. Witness gave further scientific evidence, and explained several points in relation to the seams.
John Whalley, fireman in the 7-ft. seam of the Burley Pit prior to the accident, said: That he was at work at the time of the explosion, which took place at about 20 minutes to two, and was in the south level. He felt an effect from it in his head, and afterwards heard it. There were several men working with him, and they all came up at once. About an hour and a half after the accident he went down again, but did not go into the workings. The seams were entirely distinct, and were worked separately. It was the custom in the whole of the seams to use lamps exclusively, and the head butty tried all of the lamps every morning. Witness saw this done on the day of the accident. It was customary for the fireman to go down the pit every morning at a quarter past five to examine the workings. On the morning of the explosion witness examined his workings, and found no gas at all. The fireman of the 8-ft. seam went down about the usual time. During the day he made several examinations, but found no traces of gas. The fireman had to be present to examine the shot, and ascertain if there was any gas. If they found it free from gas, permission was sometimes given to the man to fire his own shot. About three shots were fired in his end of the 7-ft. seam during the day of the explosion. As a rule the places were found free from gas, but if any were found, steps were taken for its removal before the men came down. Witness had worked over 20 years in coal pits, and he was of opinion that the Burley Pit was the best he had ever known as being free from gas. It was also well conducted in other respects.
Mr. Maule. — You tell us you went down to the workings about half an hour after the explosion occurred. Did you do anything after you got out of the cage at the bottom of the shaft? — No; I was told that there were plenty of men in the workings, and no additional assistance was required, therefore I went up again.
Mr. Maule. — Did you notice anything on that occasion whilst at the bottom of the shaft? — Nothing particular.
The Corner. — I suppose at the same pit you are not drifting in the mine at present; merely opening out? — Just so, sir.
Mr. Gilroy. — Were the shots always fired in the fireman's presence, when he gave permission for the workmen to fire them ? — Yes.
Mr. Gilroy. — Is that a strict rule? — Yes ; the rule laid down bv the manager.
John Shenton, head butty at the Burley Pit, said : That his duty was to thoroughly examine all lamps before they were taken into the workings. He saw that the lamps were in good order, as well as locked. No one was allowed to have a key except, the fireman. He examined the lamps as usual on the morning of the explosion. A short time before the accident he was down in the pit and chatting with Caleb Whalley. He heard no complaint at that time about the state of the workings, which he knew were almost always free from gas. He would have been sure to have heard had there been anything wrong about them. He had been accustomed to fiery seams of coal ever since he was a boy, and never knew one better kept than those in the Burley Pit. He had heard complaints of there being too much, but never too little, air. He knew that in one case, about 12 months since, a man endeavoured to check the flow of air, and was fined for so doing. Witness was in the pit at the time of the explosion, but not in the same seam, and was rendered insensible by the shock. — In reply to Mr. Maule, Q.C., witness said that he explored the pit after the accident, remaining down all the afternoon. He noticed that on the north side a lot of dirt and timber had been knocked towards the shaft. On the south side several timbers had been blown down, and there was some fire burning. It was not severe, and they put it out. In consequence of further fire being discovered the men were withdrawn.
Henry Viggers, at present a railway porter, but who was working in the Burley Pit at the time of the accident said: That he was working in the 8-ft. seam the Saturday before the accident. The workings were then free from gas, and there was plenty of air. He was working for 15 months prior to the explosion, and during the whole of that time they were quite free from gas. He had never found any gas in the working places, nor had he ever heard any complaints of shortness of air. He had been a collier all his life, and never knew a mine so well conducted as the Burley Pit. He was the only man living out of the company who had worked in the seam. He was astounded when he heard of the accident, and thought it must be a mistake. He always considered himself safe from an explosion when working there. It was a common thing for the colliers to make periodical examinations
of their workings, and they never found any gas present.
John Dale, a collier, who had worked for two years at the Burley Pit, and had left about a month prior to the explosion, was the next witness. He said that for about four months he was fireman in the 8-ft. seam. He never saw anything to complain of with regard to the air. There was often a good deal of grumbling by the men because there was too much air. He had been working in collieries for years, and never had any cause to find fault with anything at the pit. He was astonished when he heard of the accident, and no thought of accident ever occurred to him.
Mr. James Henry Price, certificated manager at the colliery, said: That the Burley Pit was laid out partly under his direction. He had been certificated manager for two years and a half, and prior to that he had acted as Mr. Bostock's (the late manager) assistant. There were two shafts, and ventilation was effected by means of a furnace drawing from 90 to 100,000 cu. feet per minute. The furnace was frequently tested, but the book showing the results was down the pit and destroyed. About 23,000 cu. feet of air per minute was used for the 10-ft seam, 25,000 cu. feet to 26,000 cu. feet for the 7-ft., and 23,000 cu. feet to 25,000 for the 8-ft. A fan was in contemplation, and the first part of the machinery for it came the very day after the explosion. He was in the habit of visiting the pit as often as required, sometimes once, sometimes two or three times a week. He was last in the 8-ft.seam on the 20th March. He had no special reason for going down the pit on that day. He found everything satisfactory. Caleb Whalley was his under looker, and assisted him in trying the air. He found all the workings free from gas. Witness explained by means of diagrams and sectional drawings the various methods of ventilation. He produced report books which were examined by the Coroner.
In answer to Mr. Wynne, witness said that it might be possible for the furnace flames to get up high enough to ignite the return air, and gave further explanation of the system of ventilation in use in the pit.
Frederick Cook, lamp-man, said that he gave out the lamps on the morning of the explosion, finishing at about six o'clock. He gave out about 94 altogether, but had no account of how many went into each seam. They were all in good condition, and locked.
Thomas Moore, lamp-man, said 69 lamps were returned to him. All were in good condition and locked. All his lamps had been returned with the exception of 12. The 11 lamps recovered from the 8-ft. seam were produced, all of which were more or less damaged.
In reply to Mr. Gilroy, witness said that the colliers always left their match boxes and pipes with him before they went down. Slips of paper were used to show which lamp every man had and they could not be changed without the fact being known.
William Scott, assistant certificated manager at the Apedale Collieries, said that the Burley Pit was not in his charge, but that he occasionally went down. After the explosion he was one of the first to go down the pit. They went to the south side and found a small fire, which they extinguished. Coal and timber were found on fire, but no brattice.
Cross-examined by Mr. Wynne. — Did you see anything that led you to form an opinion as to the cause of the accident ? — Witness : I did.
What was that? — I examined all the workings and went down the air dip, where there were traces of fire. I found places where the coal had been on fire, and the inference I drew was that the air was fired at the furnace and tailed up.
Did you find any trace of a shot that had been fired? — Yes, on the 6th June.
Did you draw any inference with regard to it? — No.
In answer to further questions, witness said that about two tons of coals had dropped down. The coal was coked about the third, fourth, and fifth thirlings. He pointed out on the plan, and when asked why the force of the fire seemed to be so much stronger at a distance from the place at which it originated, replied that it always got force as it proceeded until it got to its limit. — In reply to the Coroner he said he had been accustomed to explosions. The greatest amount of damage was, in his opinion, done by the first explosion.
Mr. James Lucas said : That at the time of the accident he was acting as manager for Messrs. Stanier at the Silverdale Colliery. He had been down the Burley Pit with the exploring party and once with Mr. Stanier. From the charred condition of the coal in certain places he was led to think that the explosion occurred where a shot had been fired about 40 yards up the dip, on a level with the furnace. The seam was very dusty, and the dust would catch fire before the gas. It would be possible for the gas to have accumulated owing to a door having been left open. He could not positively say whether the fire was due to the furnace or the shot, The shot had done its work. The workings in which the explosion occurred were efficiently ventilated, and it would be almost impossible for gas to collect unless a door had been left open.
At this point the inquiry was adjourned.
The inquiry was concluded on Wednesday morning, Mr. Maule, Q.C., and Messrs. Wynne and Gilroy (Government inspectors of mines) being again present, as was also Mr. Brown, on behalf of the colliers.
The first witness examined was Mr. Strick, who said he was general manager of the Silverdale and Apedale Collieries. He visited the Burley Pit after the explosion, on the 6th, 10th, 12th, and 16th July, the Government Inspectors of Mines accompanying him on the 12th. He visited the dips as far as the place where the explosion occurred. From the examinations made he was of opinion that the explosion occurred at the furnace. All the evidences, and traces of the fire seemed to start from the point between the furnace and the place where the shot was fired, and the heaviest places of the fire was along the "crut," in a straight line from the furnace dip. He considered the greatest force of the explosion was felt in the vicinity of the furnace, and that was the reason of the men being blown on to the top of it. — In answer to the Coroner, he said that he considered 23,000 feet of air, supplied by means of the furnaces, would be sufficient for the whole of the workings in the 8-ft. seam, in which the explosion occurred. Taking the whole of the workings, as far as he saw, he thought they were properly and skilfully constructed and carried out; but if he had laid them out himself he certainly should not have constructed them to cause the return air to come in the direction it did. According to the present plans the whole of the foul air from the mine generally would return over the furnace, a method he did not exactly approve of. He thought that if the furnace and its surroundings had been so constructed as to cause the return foul air from the Bullhurst Seam to pass over the furnace without coming in contact with the flame of the furnace, he should in all other respects approve of the plans and system of the workings.
Mr. S. B. Gilroy, inspector of mines, was next examined at some length. He stated that on March 27th he received a telegram concerning the explosion, and at once proceeded to the scene of the disaster. The last exploring party returned to the surface immediately after his arrival, and reported that fire was smelt in the south side workings, and the curbs in the up-cast shaft were on fire, the limits of their explorations being fixed by the after-damp, and consequently leaving no doubt as to the death of the men in the workings. A consultation took place, when it was considered useless to run further risk of life by sending men down the shaft. Witness then advised the flooding of the mine to quench the fire. The managers in charge replied that there was not sufficient water to do that, so that the next best thing was done, and that was to cast down some rubbish to plug the bottom of the up-cast shaft, and thereby cut off the supply of air which was then every moment increasing and spreading the fire. Witness did not leave the pit that night, Mr. Price, the manager, staying with him. About noon on the following day it was considered that the communication between the shafts was cut off, when a second explosion took place, which settled the question as to a further descent of the mine, which certain well-meaning, but foolhardy, persons were contemplating. Exploration being abandoned, steam pumps and other appliances were at once put into operation, and the flooding of the mine carried out. Witness went down the mine on the 7th June, and made an examination, and proceeded about 80 yards up the furnace drift. At that point the gas was then very strong, and the party were compelled to proceed with the greatest caution, so as not to displace the standing gas too rapidly. On the 12th July he made a further examination of the mine, and at one place found that the roof had fallen in about 20 yards, and in another place the coal was "coked" on both sides, indicating the fire in this particular place to have been very severe, and a thermometer there registered 86°. He also found marks of a shot in the back furnace dip, and the inference was that this shot was fired immediately before the explosion, but he would not put it forward as his opinion that the firing of this shot ignited the gas, inasmuch as there were other suppositions, but he would lay stress upon the fact that the only man within some distance of the spot authorised to fire a shot was Caleb Whalley, and the body of the collier who would have prepared that shot was found within 30 yards of it, and his jacket, which had been burnt, was found close to the shot. He could not say what was actually the cause of the explosion ; various reasons might be assigned. The first reason might have been the shot in the back furnace dip. The second reason would be the supposed ignition of the return air from the 10-ft. seam, which was carried, in conjunction with the return from the Bullhurst Seam, over the ventilating furnace, and which was in work that morning, and had the character of yielding as much gas as any mine in the district. Another reason for the explosion might be found in a supposed defective lamp, or in any other risk to which miners were habitually subjected. Traces of fire were found also on the north side, which made the matter very puzzling; and altogether witness never met with a case where the traces of an explosion were so contradictory and perplexing as in the present one. This fire might be accounted for by the two places on this side where the coal was burnt. It was more difficult to account for the quantity of gas than for the means of igniting it. It was witness' opinion that the pit was a very fairly conducted one, though he had at different times called attention to the fundamental error of allowing the return air to pass through the furnace; inasmuch as the gas was never found in any quantity, and as the amount of ventilation was calculated to render it harmless long before reaching the furnace, he did not consider it in his province to interfere. — By Mr. Maule. — A shot which does its work is equally dangerous with any other if the gas is near enough to ignite. Mr. Maule. — Do you suppose it was caused by the firing of the return air, or by the firing of the superabundent gas in the seam? — I think it is most probable, from the two theories put forward, that I should give the weight of the argument to the shot. If the shot fired the gas I should not expect to find the greatest force of the explosion near the shot. Experiments of a very conclusive character have been made in South Lancashire by a mines' inspector, which prove that coal dust has the effect of very considerably augmenting the force and extent of the explosion.
Mr. Wynne, inspector of mines stated: That on the 12th of July he was enabled to make such an inspection of the mine as to enable him to form a pretty accurate opinion as to the cause of the explosion, and although others may have a different opinion to his, it was quite clear to him that the gas fired at the furnace, and that the return air which passed over the fire had become foul at the time. It would be seen from the plan, that the air from the 10-ft. seam, and also from the Bullhurst Mine, was brought through a "staple" put into the 8-ft. level, where it joined the other, and together passed over the furnace fire ; and it appears that a few days previously a "thirling" was made out of the straight rise heading into the workings above, so that any gas that was given off in the higher workings had then a straight run to the furnace, instead of having, as before, to travel some distance round and have time to mix with the other returns before reaching the furnace. "It also appears that the door was put in near this 'cut through' and at the very time of the explosion some further alteration was being made at the spot, and although these changes would no doubt improve the ventilation in the upper workings, it was a grave mistake to make a material change in the return air courses until the fan was erected and the furnace abandoned, as a slight increase in the quantity of gases either from the 'small blower' or from the 'fault' would necessarily float directly on to the fire and cause an explosion. From the position in which the coal getters' clothes and tools were found, there can be but little doubt that a shot had just been fired in the return air course, and the general opinion at first was that the gas had fired at that shot; but however reprehensible it was to fire a shot in such a place, all appearances when I saw it were decidedly against the theory, for the whole force of the explosion took the direction from the pit and not towards it, and past the place where the shot was fired. When this colliery was laid out it seems to have escaped the attention of the manager that the rise workings would be 170 yards higher than the bottom of the shaft, and consequently would require a strong pull in the up-cast shaft to bring warm air and gas down to the level; but experience having taught him that lesson, a very powerful Guibal fan was ordered, and the foundations were actually commenced before this calamity happened, and will soon be at work, when they will have the command of any amount of air, and be able to ventilate the whole of the seams worked in these pits."
The Coroner said this was the whole of the evidence he intended to bring forward, and after briefly reviewing the chief features of the testimony of the various witnesses, he asked the jury to retire to consider their verdict.
About half-past two o'clock, after returning from consultation, the jury brought in the following verdict: "That the men lost their lives through an explosion of gas, but how and where it accumulated, or where it exploded, we have no positive evidence to show. We find also that there does not appear to be any blame to be attached to the management of the pit."
Upon the evidence being brought to your notice by Mr. Maule and myself it was considered by you a proper case for inquiry under the 32nd section of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, whether, the then manager, James Henry Price, was a fit and proper person to hold a certificate of competency under the said Act. The case was very clearly and fairly stated by Mr. Booth, solicitor of Tunstall, as all who read it will admit.
The Coal Mines Regulation Act.
In the matter of an inquiry into the conduct of James Henry Price, of Chesterton, in the county of Stafford, a person holding a certificate as manager of a colliery under the said Coal Mines Regulation Act.
Before William Spooner, Esq., County Court Judge, and Thomas Evans, Esq., as Assessor.
Statement of Case upon which the inquiry is instituted.
The inquiry is instituted under the 32nd section of the Coai Mines Regulation Act, 1872, upon the following circumstances ; namely,
1. That you, the said James Henry Price, are a person holding a certificate under the above-mentioned Act, and that under such certificate as manager you had the daily supervision of the Burley Colliery, situate in the parish of Wolstanton, in the county of Stafford, the owners of the said colliery being Messrs. Stanier and Company.
2. That on the 27th day of March last you, the said James Henry Price, as such manager as aforesaid did not cause an adequate amount of ventilation to he constantly produced in the mine of the said colliery to dilute and render harmless noxious gases to such an extent that the working places of the shafts, levels, stables, and workings of such mine, and the travelling roads to and from such working places should be in a fit state of working, and passing therein contrary to the 1st General Rule set forth in the 51st section of the said Act..
3. That you, the said James Henry Price, did permit the return air used for the ventilation of the said colliery to pass up a dumb drift and over the furnace of the up-cast shaft of the said colliery. The outlet of such dumb drift into the up-cast shaft being so near to the fire issuing from the said furnace that there was at all times a danger of an explosion happening, if from any cause whatever, the return air used for ventilating the said colliery should become so charged with gas as to be explosive.
4. That you, the said James Henry Price, did on the 26th day of the said month of March last having such daily supervision of the said colliery permit a thirling or air passage to be cut through from the north dips of the said colliery unto a brow called the furnace dip by means of which the air of the north dips had its course shortened by a considerable distance, and was taken more directly up such dumb drift as aforesaid to the up-cast shaft. The effect thereof being to decrease the opportunity for the gas which is carried away in the current of ventilation of becoming so thoroughly diluted by mixing with the air as it could do when its passage with the air was during a longer time through the greater distances.
5. That in consequence of such neglect and mismanagement of the said colliery by you, the said James Henry Price, an explosion occurred at the said colliery on the said 27th day of March last whereby 23 of the workmen at the said colliery were killed, namely, Caleb Whalley, Frederick Whalley, John Hackin, Edward Smith, William Bostock, Joseph Braddock, Henry Piper, Abraham Riley, William Baggalley, James Higginson, John Taylor, Thomas Dale, Joseph Baggalley, James Mayer, Henry Yarwood, James Cork, Thomas Hughes, John Saunders, John Edwards, Richard Fowley, John Stockton, Albert Handy, and William Baggalley, and the lives of the other workmen at the said colliery were seriously endangered.
Dated this 10th day of September 1878.
But when it was proved that Price was only an assistant to a previous manager (Bostock) when the workings were laid out, and that it was Bostock and not he that was responsible for the faulty laying out of the mine, Mr. Spooner and Mr. Evans did not think the grave error that I pointed out in my evidence of such a venal character as to justify them in withdrawing or withholding Price's certificate.