II. — Particulars Of The Colliery And Its Background
(a) General
Creswell Colliery, formerly owned by the Bolsover Colliery Company Limited, was taken over by the National Coal Board in 1947. It is included in the No. 4 Sub-Area of No. 1 Area of the East Midlands Division, and is situated in Derbyshire near the Nottinghamshire border and lies about six miles southwest of Worksop.
The mine was under the daily supervision of Mr. G. Inverarity who, after a spell as a spare manager under the Bolsover Colliery Company, was appointed manager of Creswell Colliery in November, 1946. Mr. G. S. W. Payton, after a period as Safety Officer, was appointed undermanager in January, 1948. To assist them they had six overmen, a safety officer, a training officer and a number of deputies and shot firers. Above the manager was an Agent, Mr. J. A. Tankard, who, in turn, came under the direction of the Sub-Area manager for No. 4 Sub-Area of No. 1 Area, Mr. W. E. S. Peach. The No. 1 Area Production Manager was Mr. J. Brass, the Area General Manager was Mr. W. V. Sheppard, and Mr. W. H. Sansom was the Divisional Production Director. All of these higher officials from the undermanager upwards hold First-Class Certificates of Competency under the Coal Mines Act, 1911.
The mine has two circular shafts, each 18 feet in diameter and completed in 1896, which were sunk to work the Top Hard seam at a depth of 444¼ yards. The High Hazel seam was intersected by the shafts at 329 yards from the surface. In 1939, for exploratory reasons, the upcast (or No. 2) shaft was sunk to the Low Main seam at a depth of 736 yards. A cross-measure drift was then driven from the Top Hard seam to the Low Main seam and a connection was made with No. 2 shaft. In 1933 a cross-measure drift was driven at 1 in 3 from the Top Hard up to the High Hazel seam to enable faces in this seam to be opened out. Output from the High Hazel seam was gradually increased to replace the declining output from the Top Hard seam. Work ceased in the Top Hard in 1941, and, thereafter, all the output came from the High Hazel, so that at the time of the accident an extensive area of this seam had been worked out.
The High Hazel seam has an average inclination of 1 in 30, is about 4 feet 6 inches thick, and was worked by advancing longwall methods in three main producing districts, known as the North-West, South-East and South-West Districts. There were 1,144 men employed underground and 355 on the surface. During the three months prior to the fire, the weekly output of the colliery was just over 14,000 tons, about half of which came from the South-West District, The coal from all three districts was transported to the pit bottom by trunk-belt conveyors and wound at the downcast shaft. Coal filling and winding were done on the day and afternoon shifts. Repair and maintenance work was done on all three shifts, but mostly on the night-shift. The general sequence of work on the coal faces was: cut, fill, pack and turnover.
Since the South-West District was the district directly concerned with the fire, it is the only one about which details need be given.
(b) Method of Working
The general lay-out of this district is shown in Plan No. 1. There were two main roads serving the district, the Main Intake, which was used for the transport of coal in trunk-belt conveyors, and the Main Return, which was used for the transport of men by an endless-rope haulage man-riding set. These two main roads were 60 yards apart for 1¼ miles from the pit bottom and 34 yards apart for the remaining 1¼ miles. A little more than half-way inbye, a downthrow fault — known as the Elmton Fault — was encountered. Originally, the South-West District was laid out to work coal only as far as this fault, but in 1945, it was decided to work coal beyond this fault. Consequently, in that year, two dip drifts, the intake dipping 1 in 9 and the return dipping at 1 in 6, were driven through the fault, which at this point is in the form of a trough, the first throw being downwards with 195 feet displacement, followed by an upthrow of 85 feet, making a total downthrow displacement of 110 feet.
Apart from 57's heading, which was winning out a new face not far inbye from the shafts, there were five double-unit faces in the district. Of these, No. 59's — the only one on the outbye side of the Elmton Fault — was a double-unit face, 295 yards long, where the seam was undercut by machine to a depth of 4 feet 6 inches in a dirt-band one foot above the floor. The coal was shot down by explosives and hand-filled on to conveyors. It was regarded as a standbye face and was only worked as required.
Beyond the Elmton Fault there were four working faces and an abandoned face, No. 63's, which had been stopped when it reached an unproved fault at a distance of 840 yards to the right, off the main intake. Materials had been drawn off from this panel except for the supports in the right-side gate and the central-loading gate. The four working faces were known as the 74's, 64's, 68's and 65's respectively. Particulars of these faces are as follows
The 74's face was 167 yards long and formed the development panel for the area. Four gateways were formed in this development to provide two intake and two return airways. The working face was 2½ miles from the pit bottom. No. 64's was a double-unit face, 300 yards long, which had advanced 1,000 yards to the left off the main intake. The 68's face was 450 yards long but only two-thirds of its length was in production. This part of the face had advanced 410 yards to the left off the main intake, whilst the remaining one-third of the face, which had been stopped, had advanced 450 yards. No. 65's was a double-unit face, 330 yards long, which had advanced 300 yards to the left off the main intake.
With the exception of No. 68's, the working faces were machine cut at floor level to a depth of 4 feet 6 inches, the coal being shot down and hand-filled on to face conveyors. The production part of 68's face was worked by a Meco-Moore cutter-loader which took off coal to a depth of 3 feet 3 inches along the face and loaded it on to a face conveyor. Coal from the face conveyors in all faces was transported by gate conveyors to the main trunk conveyor system on the South West District main-intake road. Steel props and bars were used throughout on these faces and the three-props-per bar system was in general use. The normal thickness of seam on these faces was 4 feet, but from 5 to 6 inches of top coal was left up to form the immediate roof.
Prior to 1948, under-tub endless-rope haulage had been in use for transporting coal to the pit bottom along the main haulage road but in July, 1948, a complete change-over was made to trunk-belt conveying to a central loading point 90 yards from the pit bottom. The belts were of 7-ply construction with rubber facings. At the time of the accident this main trunk-conveyor system comprised three conveyors in tandem: No. 1 belt, from the No. 1 transfer point near the pit bottom to the No. 2 transfer point, a distance of 1,703 yards; No. 2 belt, from the No. 2 transfer to No. 3 transfer point, a distance of 1,080 yards; and No. 3 belt, from No. 3 transfer for a distance of 1,060 yards to the point where the gate-belt conveyor from 74's face delivered its coal. With the exception of the coal from 59's face which was delivered on to the No. 1 belt at a point 69 yards outbye the No. 2 transfer point, the coal from all other faces was fed on to the No. 3 belt. These three main belts were each 36 inches wide and were each driven by 100 h.p. Sutcliffe Goliath Units. The belt speed was about 350 feet per minute. Each transfer point was covered in by a sheet metal canopy and water sprays were fitted for dust suppression. The roadway throughout was of ample cross-section and an endless-rope haulage was installed along one side of the conveyors for the transport of supplies. On the outbye side of the Elmton Fault, the roadway was supported by steel arches, camber girders and straight girders, but on the inbye side of the fault, steel arches were used as standard practice.
The complement of workmen in the South-West District on the three shifts was : day-shift, 93; afternoon-shift, 163 ; and night-shift, 122. On the nightshift of the 25th/26th September, however, because of transference of workmen from the South-East District, 133 persons were employed in the South-West District.
(c) Ventilation
The general direction of the ventilation, the air splits and the quantities passing at various points as recorded in the air-measurement book for the month of August, 1950, are shown in Plan No. 1.
About 60,000 cubic feet of air per minute entered the main South-West intake and trunk-conveyor road. Approximately one mile inbye, a split was taken off to ventilate 59's panel, leaving 44,000 cubic feet of air per minute to pass on down the intake drift through the Elmton Fault. Thereafter, other splits were taken off to ventilate, on the left side, 64's and 68's panels, and on the right side, 65's. The remainder of the air went forward to ventilate 74's development face. All faces were on unit ventilation. Safety lamps were used throughout.
(d) Fire-Fighting Arrangements
The measures, both in men and materials, for fighting fires on the surface or in the underground workings were well organized and, as will be seen from Plan No. 1, the facilities provided in the South-West District appeared to be ample to cope with any emergency. Fire-fighting water ranges were laid along the main-intake airways from the shafts to points near each working face. Hydrants were installed at intervals of approximately 250 yards and, in addition, at points such as gear-heads, junctions and transfer points. The pipes were usually 2 inches diameter, but a start had been made to replace those in the North-West District with pipes of 2½ inches diameter. Recent additions to the ranges in the South-West District were all this size, but preparations were also in progress to renew the South-West pipe range from the shafts with 3 inches diameter pipes. Water was supplied from the 5 inches rising-main in the downcast shaft which served as the pump range from the Top Hard seam. The pump in this seam was run only during the night-shift and arrangements were therefore made to feed water into the main from surface tanks during the day and afternoon shifts. In addition, another 1 inch diameter pipe was also used to supply water via the upcast shaft into the fire-fighting mains. This supply was kept running continuously and was generally sufficient to feed all the dust suppression water sprays. Reducing valves were fitted at each shaft bottom to regulate the pressure in the mains.
Fire stations were arranged at points along the main road. Plan No. 1 shows the standard equipment at each station. Manual force pumps were not kept at each fire station but one could quickly be transported from the shaft bottom. The equipment was examined and reported on monthly. Rules were laid down for the organization and conduct of fire-fighting work and fire drills were carried out regularly. The water pressure at the shaft bottom was between 400 and 430 lb. per square inch. Flow tests were made periodically and the last test made in June, 1950, at 59's hydrant gave a flow of 45 gallons per minute at a flow pressure of 20 lb. per square inch.
(e) Man-riding Trains
Arrangements were made for the mechanical transport of men to and from their work in the South-West District. These consisted of two man-riding trains operated in the main-return airway by an under-tub endless-rope reversible haulage, known locally as the "Paddy." The two trains were attached to the rope — one at the outbye end of the haulage and the other at the inbye end — so that when the haulage was running one train travelled inbye while the other travelled outbye. A three-rail track was used with a length of double track at the "meetings," situated between 400 and 500 yards outbye from the top of the Elmton Drift.
(f) Telephones
Telephones were installed at the following places to serve the South-West District
| | (1) |
59's junction, serving No. 2 transfer point and 59's face, which was 330 yards distant.
|
| | (2) |
No. 3 transfer point.
|
| | (3) |
64's loader gate junction.
|
| | (4) |
Main road near 65's loader gate, serving 65's face which was 350 yards distant.
|
| | (5) |
68's junction, serving 68's face which was 360 yards distant.
|
| | (6) |
74's transfer point at the end of the main-trunk conveyor system, serving 74's face which was 425 yards distant.
|
| | (7) |
64's tandem in the loader gate, serving 64's face which was 410 yards distant.
|
| | (8) |
Passbye or "meetings" on the man-haulage in the main-return airway.
|
| | (9) |
Inbye terminus of man-haulage in the main-return airway.
|
| | (10) |
Foot of Elmton Drift, main-return airway.
|
The main underground telephone system was controlled from a switchboard in an office situated in the main-return airway near the bottom of the upcast shaft. One attendant was employed at this switchboard on each shift on which persons were employed underground. On the day and afternoon shifts, the two coal-drawing shifts, there was usually a number of persons working within speaking distance of the telephone exchange, so that if the attendant received a telephone message which had to be given to someone near the pit bottom or which required some action in the vicinity, such as the tripping of a near-by electric switch, the attendant could call to someone to deliver the message or take the necessary action, without himself leaving his office. If, on the other hand, any such message was received on the night-shift, the attendant would normally have to leave his switchboard for a short time to deliver or act upon the message, because few persons worked within speaking distance of the exchange on this shift. This was a matter of little importance in ordinary circumstances but, as will be seen, it was of importance on the morning of the fire.