IX. Summary Of Conclusions
71. Summarising the results of the Inquiry, I find that
(1) The source of ignition in this explosion was a spark produced by the operation of the relighting device of flame safety lamp No. 9 after the deliberate removal of the spirit vessel which had been made possible by the cutting of the lead rivet lock ; the lamp was opened in order to adjust the internal relighter, which was believed not to be functioning properly; the opening of the lamp was a grave misdemeanour and a contravention of Section 34 (1) (iii) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911; there were two men, a deputy and a shotfirer — both subsequently killed by the explosion — at the meeting station in the return airway and main haulage road from the Wheatley Lime Seam District when the relighting device was operated in the opened lamp, but there is no evidence to show who actually opened the lamp and who then operated the relighter.
(2) The spark from the relighter in the opened lamp ignited an inflammable firedamp-air mixture in the general body of the air current passing the meeting station at the time, causing a firedamp explosion.
(3) The flame of the explosion traversed a distance of approximately 3,000 yards, including nearly all of the inbye working roads and faces and more than 1,000 yards along the main return haulage road outbye the meeting station.
(4) The explosion developed moderate violence in the South 2 Conveyor Gate and in the 1 in 7 Drift in the Evison Bord haulage road, but elsewhere the explosion was mild in character.
(5) The explosion was mainly one of firedamp and it is not possible to say with, certainty that coal dust contributed to it, or if it did, to what extent.
(6) The main source of the firedamp was the abandoned workings in the Old North 1 District; this firedamp was forced out of the Old North 1 District by the fixing and closing, or nearly closing, of a door in the intake airway between the two entrances to the old district; this door had been fixed on the night shift about half-an-hour or thereby before the explosion occurred; and it is not possible to say which of the five persons in the district at the time fixed the door.