57. Summarizing the results of the Inquiry, I consider it established —
(1) That the initial firedamp explosion originated near the waste edge close to the face of the rise split off No. 14 Level, one of James Todd's working places in the stooping section, No. 2 District, Dunnet Seam, when firedamp was ignited at the flame of the open acetylene cap lamp carried by Thomas Reid.
(2) That the initial explosion was followed almost immediately by a second firedamp explosion, which spread along the waste to adjacent places and that this explosion was followed by a series of lighter explosions and the burning of gas along the waste edge, causing flame to persist.
(3) That the firedamp had collected gradually over a period of time in the higher cavities of the waste or goaf formed by the stooping, where its presence could not normally be detected, and that some of it had been expelled therefrom into Todd's working place by roof movements or falls of roof in the waste shortly before the return of the workmen after their meal interval.
(4) That the persistent flame caused fires in at least five separate places, due initially to the ignition of timber at or near the waste edge and the subsequent ignition of fallen or loose pieces of oil shale.
(5) That these fires were sufficiently brought under control to permit of rescue operations but were not wholly extinguished, largely due to inaccessibility, with the result that the fire area had to be sealed off.
(6) That John McGarty was fatally injured through his head striking a sharp object when he was blown down by the blast from the second explosion and that the 14 other men lost their lives from the effects of breathing afterdamp produced by the explosions and subsequent fires.
(7) That there were no breaches of statutory requirements.