Report on the
Causes and Circumstances attending the Fire which occurred at
the Cadder Colliery on Sunday, August 3rd, 1913.
Justiciary Buildings,
Jail Square,
Glasgow,
October 25th, 1913.
Sir,
In obedience to your directions, I proceeded to Glasgow. I descended the Cadder
Mine on Saturday, 20th September. I opened the proceedings on Monday, 22nd, in the
Justiciary Buildings, Jail Square, and examined 38 (thirty-eight) witnesses. It was
impossible to see the exact scene of the fire, and Mr. McLaren, the Senior Inspector for
the West of Scotland, having examined the place, was of opinion that it would be so
dangerous to open it up. I decided therefore against the attempt being made, and to deal
with the case upon the evidence we had got. I closed the Inquiry on Saturday,
September 29th.
The following gentlemen appeared before me :—
Mr. C. D. Murray, K.C., and the Honourable William Watson, Advocate, instructed
by Messrs. John C. Brodie & Sons, W.S., Edinburgh, and Aitken & Dunlop, Writers,
Glasgow, for the Carron Company, the owners of the Cadder Colliery.
Mr. Robert Smillie, President of the British Miners’ Federation ;
Mr. John Robertson, Vice-President of the Scottish Miners’ Federation ;
Mr. James Murdoch, Miners’ Agent, Hamilton ;
Mr. J. Robson, Miners’ Offices, Durham ;
Mr. G. Barker, Abertillery, Monmouthshire, for the British Miners’ Federation, with
Mr. G. Craig Macintyre, and Mr. J. C. Allan of Messrs. Hay, Cassels & Frame, Writers, Hamilton, as
their Legal Advisers and on behalf of the representatives of the relatives of the deceased
and the injured workmen.
Mr. Alexander Shaughnessy, Writer, Glasgow, for Robert Armstrong, father of the
deceased Charles Armstrong.
Mr. H. P. Macmillan, K.C., and Mr. L. H. Strain, Advocate, for the Lanarkshire
Coal Masters’ Association, instructed by H. and S. Bururn, W. S. Edinburgh and
M. Bishop, Writer, Glasgow.
Mr. Digby S. Brown, for the representatives of the deceased Hugh Anderson.
Mr. W. Craig, Writer, Glasgow, for the Scottish Mine Owners’ Defence and
Mutual Insurance Association, Limited.
Mr. D. Wright, General Secretary, for the Scottish Colliery Firemen and Shot
Firers’ Association.
Mr. George Giles, Depute Procurator-Fiscal, attending on behalf of the Commissioners.
Mr. W. Walker, H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines for Scotland.
Mr. Hugh Johnstone, H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines, Midland and Southern
Division.
Mr. Robert McLaren, H.M. Senior Inspector of Mines, Scotland Division.
Mr. Robert Nelson, H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines, Home Office, London.
Mr. J. Masterton, H.M. Junior Inspector of Mines, Scotland Division ; and
Mr. A. H. Steele, H.M. Junior Inspector of Mines, Scotland Division, acted as
Secretary.
List Of Witnesses In Order Of Their Examination
| Colin Campbell | Mining Engineer |
| James Bonar | District General Manager |
| Professor Latham | The University, Glasgow |
| Archibald Spiers | Manager, No. 15 Pit, Cadder Mine |
| Dr. Douglas | |
| Dr. Miller | |
| James McWinnie | Manager, No. 17 Pit, Cadder Mine |
| James Owens | Under-Manager, No. 15 Pit, Cadder Mine |
| Andrew Lawson | Winding Engineman, No. 17 Pit |
| Edward Flynn | Electrician, No. 15 Pit |
| John Lees | Boiler Furnaceman, No. 15 Pit |
| William Brown | Fireman, No. 15 Pit |
| Robert Dunbar | Miner |
| Arnold Hughes | Electrical Engineer to the Carron Co. |
| Professor Thornton | Armstrong College, Newcastle-upon-Tyne |
| David Stevenson | Instructor to the Cowdenbeath rescue station |
| James Forrester | Captain of the Cowdenbeath rescue brigades |
| Robert Nelson | H.M. Electrical Inspector Of Mines |
| Michael McDonald | Miner |
| David Downie | Under-manager, No. 17 Pit |
| James Baird | District Manager, Cannon Co. |
| Donald Kelly | Miner |
| Wm. McLaren | Miner |
| Hugh Dickson | Fireman, No. 15 Pit |
| John Carey | Miner |
| Quinton Davidson | Shanksman |
| John Marshall | Winding Engineman, No. 15 Pit |
| Patrick Etherson | Pit Bottomer |
| William Johnstone | Fireman |
| Michael Keenan | Miner |
| John Cairns | Miner |
| Dr. Dale Logan | |
| A. B. Muirhead | Electrical Engineer |
| A. H. Steele | H.M. Junior Inspector of Mines |
| R. McLaren | H.M. Senior Inspector of Mines, Scotland Division |
| R. Currie | Lecturer in Mining |
| Hugh Johnstone | H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines, Midland and Southern Division. |
| W. Walker | H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines for Scotland. |
I had also before me precognitions taken by the Procurator Fiscal of the evidence of
most of the witnesses and five documents, viz. :— A circular dated April 8th by the Chief
Inspector of Mines ; a circular issued by the Lanarkshire Coal Masters’ Association dated
April 19th, 1913 ; a letter dated April 22nd, 1913, from the Secretary to the said
Association to H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines for Scotland ; a letter from Mr. Pate,
General Manager of the Carron Co., to the Chief Inspector of Mines ; and a letter dated
April 25th from H.M. Divisional Inspector for Scotland to Robert Baird, Secretary of the
Lanarkshire Coal Masters’ Association. These letters are printed as an Appendix to this
report. Two plans are appended, out of the five put in at the hearing, which sufficiently
show the various parts of the mine referred to in this report. Shorthand notes were taken
of the evidence and a copy of them accompanies this report.