Appendix E
National Coal Board Recommendations On Underground Stowing
1. Before and since nationalisation the desirability of stowing mine waste underground in the Colliery being operated has been clearly recognised by the coal mining industry. There has been and still is much consideration given to the multiplicity of problems involved and many experiments have been carried out in relation to run of mine rubbish and washery discard (including tailings).
2. In general terms underground stowing is technically feasible, though the problems vary from colliery to colliery and even from seam to seam but the cost is too great to be justified The increased rate at which the coal face must advance if advantage is to be taken of modern mining methods makes it more difficult than ever to apply, economically, a system of stowing large quantities of the waste underground. There has to be considered not only the actual cost of stowing but the decrease in rate of output of coal which must necessarily follow. If underground stowing were generally employed the result would be a financial burden that the coal industry could not bear.
3. Stowing, albeit technically feasible, creates hazards which cannot be ignored. Airborne dust is increased and in South Wales in particular this can bring an added risk of pneumoconiosis.
4. The German coal industry has experienced problems that are similar to those experienced in the United Kingdom. In the Ruhr there has been a marked decline in underground stowing in recent years. Whereas in 1958 about 50 per cent. of all coal was obtained in conjunction with solid stowing today the figure has been reduced to 16 per cent.
5. Ten years ago the Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Housing and Local Government stated in the House of Commons that "there has been the idea of underground stowage of the spoil material, but very often that is not practically possible." (see Hansard for 23rd May, 1957). With greater mechanisation since 1957 and more intensive mining methods underground stowing is today even less of a practical proposition.
6. At the present time stowing is employed in some exceptional cases mainly to improve the conditions of faces and underground roadways and to minimise surface subsidence where normal methods of strata control are inadequate. In South Wales stowing is being practised in approximately 2½ per cent. of the working faces.
7. The conclusion is that underground stowing is not economically practicable though technically feasible. Modern mining methods entail multi-shift working of rapidly advancing, highly mechanised faces. Under these conditions stowing is a practical impediment to the type of mining necessary to make the industry economically viable.
8. The underground stowing of tailings has been the subject of special study and experiment, but (a) it has not yet proved possible successfully to avoid the clogging of the stowing pipes and (b) even if this problem could be overcome in the future it would not be economically practicable to stow tailings for the reasons set out above.
7th March, 1967