|
INQUIRY INTO THE ABERFAN DISASTER REPORT OF THE TRIBUNAL APPOINTED UNDER THE TRIBUNALS OF INQUIRY (EVIDENCE) ACT, 1921 To: The Rt. Hon. CLEDWYN HUGHES, M.P., Secretary of State for Wales INTRODUCTION 1. On Tuesday, the twenty-fifth day of October, 1966 resolutions were passed in both Houses of Parliament declaring that it was expedient that a tribunal be established for inquiring into a definite matter of public importance namely, the causes of, and all the circumstances relating to the disaster at Aberfan, Merthyr Tydfil, on Friday, the twenty-first day of October, 1966. 2. In pursuance of these resolutions a warrant was issued on Wednesday, the twenty-sixth day of October 1966, over the hand of the Secretary of State for Wales, which, after reciting the terms of the resolutions set out above, proceeded as follows :— "NOW I, The Right Honourable Cledwyn Hughes, one of Her Majesty's Principal Secretaries of State, do hereby appoint Sir Herbert Edmund Davies, one of Her Majesty's Lords Justices of Appeal*, Harold Harding, Esquire, and Vernon Lawrence, Esquire, C.B.E., to be a Tribunal for the purposes of the said Inquiry. AND I FURTHER APPOINT Sir Herbert Edmund Davies to be Chairman of the said Tribunal. IN VIRTUE of Section 1 of the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act, 1921, I hereby declare that the Act shall apply to the Tribunal and that the said Tribunal is constituted as a Tribunal within the meaning of the said Section of the said Act." 3. Acting under our Warrant we have conducted the inquiry called for by our terms of reference and now present the Report which we have drawn up in order to embody our findings consequent upon that inquiry. In the course of it we sat in public for the taking of evidence on 76 days. We also held a preliminary meeting in public on November 8th, 1966, for the purpose of considering the procedure to be adopted and to give directions and also to announce the arrangements that had been made for the hearing of evidence in public. 4. We visited the seven tips during the course of our sittings at Merthyr Tydfil and travelled round them in a tracked vehicle kindly provided by the Ministry of Defence: we also visited the surface of the colliery and were shown the coal preparation plant in operation. In addition to these visits we paid a number of others individually to the scene of the disaster and to other parts of Aberfan. We also held numerous informal meetings for discussion between ourselves. 5. At the preliminary meeting we announced that, while we had power to sit in private, we should do so with extreme reluctance. In the event we did not find it necessary to do so. We also announced that witnesses might give their evidence in Welsh if they would find it easier to do so, but no-one expressed such a desire. 6. We were empowered by Section 2(d) of the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act, 1921, to authorise the representation before us by counsel or solicitor or otherwise of any person appearing to us to be interested, or to refuse such representation. The word "interested" has not, as has been observed before, any precise meaning in this context. We adopted a construction which covered any person or group of persons who had been affected by the disaster and who had suffered loss or damage and also those who might be subject to adverse reflection, direct or indirect, from anything said in our report. In the result, a number of persons and associations were legally represented before us, and we set out at Appendix A a list of the names of those persons and of their counsel and solicitors. 7. The Act contains no provision giving us power to order that a witness be paid the cost of his legal representation or his expenses out of public funds. That gap in the Act was partially filled in the present instance by a public statement made on October 27th by the Secretary of State for Wales in the following terms: "The Government has considered what may be done to enable individuals who have suffered as a result of the Aberfan Disaster to be legally represented at the hearings of the Tribunal. If the Tribunal agrees to hear representations from a Solicitor or Counsel instructed by them, representing collectively those parents, dependents or others who have suffered loss or injury, the Government will meet the reasonable costs of this representation. Provision will also be made for the financial loss allowances to be paid to those who suffer loss of earnings through attendance as witnesses before the Tribunal. The maximum rates will be those applying to witnesses attending before Government Committees generally. Provision will also be made for subsistence and travelling allowances to be paid where appropriate." 8. At the request of the Chairman, counsel acting for the Tribunal were headed by Her Majesty's Attorney-General. On 7th November, 1966, the day before the preliminary meeting of this Tribunal, the Report of a Royal Commission** was published which dealt, inter alia, with the desirability of an Attorney-General's participation in proceedings held under the Tribunal of Inquiry (Evidence) Act, 1921. At the preliminary meeting the Chairman announced that, while that Royal Commission had, of necessity, to make its recommendations in the light of the type of Inquiries hitherto held under that Act, the present Inquiry was in his view of a totally different character. He went on to say that in the present instance the Attorney-General, a South Walian and an advocate with great knowledge of the South Wales coalfield and its people, would be able to assist us to an extent which could not normally be expected of the head of the Bar, however zealous. In addition to the Attorney-General we were assisted in the ascertainment of the facts and the presentation of evidence by Mr. Tasker Watkins, Q.C., Mr. Breuan Rees and Mr. Ronald Waterhouse (of counsel). We are indebted to them and to all other members of the Bar who appeared before us and their instructing solicitors for their help in the Inquiry. 9. As events transpired, the multifarious demands made upon the Attorney-General necessitated his leaving the Tribunal immediately after his opening address and prevented his appearing before us thereafter. Even so, we are unanimously of the opinion that he made so valuable a contribution that we take leave to doubt the wisdom of adopting any general rule which might hereafter totally exclude the participation of the Law Officers of the Crown in proceedings such as the present. 10. We were fortunate to have placed at our disposal the services of the Treasury Solicitor and his staff, to whom we are greatly indebted for the skill and efficiency with which they met the heavy demands made upon them. In all they took statements from 250 persons. Of these 136, whose names we set out in Appendix B, gave oral evidence before us. It is illustrative of the complexity of the matters covered by our Inquiry that the transcript of the proceedings at the public sittings for the hearing of evidence runs to 4,236 pages of foolscap typescript, and that no fewer than 61 maps and plans and numerous other documents were laid before us. We also had brought to our notice nearly 200 photographs of the tips and other places in Aberfan taken both before and after the disaster. The photographs taken before the disaster proved invaluable in showing the progress of tipping on Merthyr Mountain and the condition of the tips at several crucial periods. Their evidential value was much enhanced because none of them was taken for any purpose connected with tipping or the operations of the National Coal Board, nor were they taken to illustrate any theory or justify any special attitude. They were taken by members of the public who interest themselves in photography as a hobby, by the Press, by firms who make aerial surveys and by the Royal Air Force. We are deeply grateful to them all for the readiness with which they responded to our appeal, for their handiwork provided touchstones which frequently enabled us to make a firm decision when the oral testimony was in violent conflict. In addition, we received a large volume of correspondence either direct or through various Government Departments. We are greatly indebted to those who endeavoured to assist us in this way. At this point we wish to invite attention to the apparent disproportion between the amount of space taken up by various topics in the transcript of oral evidence and in our report. For example, the flooding at Pantglas and the plans for the construction of an aerial ropeway which occupied many hours are dealt with in short compass in our report. This is not because we believe these topics to be unimportant, but because, in our view, their relevance to our terms of reference can be briefly stated although they merited investigation at length as they revealed surprising evidence regarding the state of mind and the intentions of those concerned. 11. At the same time as we were preparing to take evidence we thought it right to set in train a series of scientific investigations under the general direction of Professor A. W. Bishop, of the Imperial College of Science and Technology. In addition to these investigations on our behalf, certain other investigations, in some cases complementary, were put in hand on behalf of some of the parties who appeared before us. The results of those investigations were reduced to writing and circulated to all parties. In view of their scientific interest, we have thought it right to arrange for separate publication of the papers. 12. We held our preliminary meeting and began our public sittings at Merthyr Tydfil for the convenience of those local residents who had been bereaved or had suffered loss or damage as a result of the disaster. We thought it right to call a large number of them as witnesses and to allow considerable latitude when they were giving evidence. We took their evidence first as a gesture of respect and out of consideration for their suffering, although, logically and chronologically, the matters to which they testified would have been taken later in the course of our proceedings. After the Christmas recess, however, we sat at Cardiff to hear the evidence of the National Coal Board, the Merthyr Tydfil Corporation and other public bodies and also the expert witnesses. We are grateful to the Merthyr Tydfil and Cardiff Corporations for making accommodation available to us and for the kindness with which we were treated by their officers. 13. At the preliminary meeting the Chairman, after indicating the far-ranging nature of the Inquiry, posed four broad questions:
14. On the 29th and 30th November 1966 the Attorney-General opened the facts. When he had concluded his statement, we (in accordance with the recommendation of the Royal Commission) afforded counsel for each of the parties before us the opportunity of addressing us briefly, and most of them did so. Thereafter one of the counsel appearing for the Tribunal called the witnesses and they were examined in chief either by their own counsel or, if they had none, by counsel for the Tribunal. Counsel appearing for other parties were then given the opportunity of cross examining them: if a witness was called by counsel appearing for the Tribunal he was then cross-examined by another of the counsel representing the Tribunal. We devised this procedure in the light of the recommendations of the Royal Commission and the Chairman announced it at the preliminary meeting. We understand that it met with the approval of counsel appearing before us and of those instructing them. 15. We were fortunate to begin the Inquiry with a certain amount of background knowledge of the coal-mining industry and some familiarity with its operation. At the start of this Inquiry we were aware of the fact that the great bulk of mining operations take place below ground and that most of the best men in the industry are employed there. It is there that coal is won and in that direction that the attention of those employed in the industry is naturally turned. Rubbish tips are a necessary and inevitable adjunct to a coal mine, even as a dustbin is to a house, but it is plain that miners devote certainly no more attention to rubbish tips than householders do to dustbins. 16. There was not lacking evidence that this is a widespread attitude in the industry. Even the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, which, with its subordinate regulations and orders, has many detailed provisions on the conduct of operations underground, is silent on the subject of refuse tips. Indeed they find a mention only in an interpretation section (Section 180) which declares that they form part of a mine. The Coal Mining Report of the Technical Advisory Committee ("The Reid Report" — Cmnd. 6610, March 1945) is silent on the topic of safety of tips and deals only with the mechanical means involved. It includes the following alarming and dangerous recommendation at paragraph 603 under the heading "Refuse Disposal": "Very little choice usually exists in the selection of the dumping site, but where possible a site with falling ground in front of the direction of advance, or sidelong sloping ground should be chosen. In such circumstances a greater amount of material can be dealt with at no greater cost". This seems to us to illustrate the generally prevailing attitude of mining engineers to the topic of the siting of tips up to this disaster. 17. We found that many witnesses, not excluding those who were intelligent and anxious to assist us, had been oblivious of what lay before their eyes. It did not enter their consciousness. They were like moles being asked about the habits of birds. 18. As we shall hereafter seek to make clear, our strong and unanimous view is that the Aberfan disaster could and should have been prevented. We were not unmindful of the fact that strong words of calumny had been used before our Inquiry began. But the Report which follows tells not of wickedness but of ignorance, ineptitude and a failure in communications. Ignorance on the part of those charged at all levels with the siting, control and daily management of tips; bungling ineptitude on the part of those who had the duty of supervising and directing them; and failure on the part of those having knowledge of the factors which affect tip safety to communicate that knowledge and to see that it was applied. 19. As we proceed with our report we shall find it necessary to refer to a number of members of the National Coal Board and its staff. A chronological table showing the names of holders of various appointments during the period 1956-66 is to be found facing this page. 20. The Merthyr Vale Colliery at Aberfan formed part of No. 4 Group in No. 4 Area of the South Western Division of the National Coal Board. The mine manager's office is at the surface of the mine, near the pithead; the Group Manager's office is also at Merthyr Vale about half a mile away from the mine: the Area Manager's office is at Aberaman, a few miles away from Aberfan; the Divisional Office is at Llanishen, near Cardiff, about twenty miles away from Aberfan; the National Coal Board's headquarters are in London. 21. At the time of the disaster the Chairman of the National Coal Board was Lord Robens and the senior official at headquarters was the Director-General of Production, Mr. W. V. Sheppard. The Chairman of the South Western Divisional Board was Mr. A. H. Kellett and the member of that Board with particular responsibility for tips was Mr. G. S. Morgan. The Area, Group and Mine Managers were respectively Mr. T. Wright, Mr. R. N. Lewis and Mr. T. J. Wynne. 22. Generally speaking, of those who gave evidence before us, the officials at Division and Area levels are qualified, both academically and professionally. Those at Group and Colliery levels, on the other hand, are qualified by statutory examination after long service in the industry and have risen to positions of responsibility by character and ability. * Sworn of the Privy Council on November 11th, 1966 ** Cmnd. 3121.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||