Points Arising At The Inquiry.
Ventilation. — Asked if he would like to give his opinion as to the method of ventilating the workings being a proper one, Mr. F. L. Jacob said he would rather not do so.
On the same subject the Manager, Mr. John Whitticombe, was asked the following questions by Mr. Carey :— "Q. 2909. If there were difficulties in maintaining ventilation in George Rees’ place, had it ever occurred to you that the whole system of ventilation of the Pentre Seam was rather defective ? — A. No.
"Q. 2910. Have you ever thought about it ? — A. No.
"Q. 2911. It had never occurred to you that it might have been a wise policy to have special ventilation there ? — A. No, we had ample, and the district was properly ventilated, in my mind, from end to end.
"Q. 2912. Whatever the reason may be, you cannot get away from the fact that at a certain moment of a certain day the ventilation was not all that it ought to be, can you ? — A. You cannot get away from the fact that something occurred.
"Q. 2913. I am only putting it to you whether it had occurred to you that it might be desirable to improve the condition by splitting the wind instead of having one circuit of wind? If you do not agree, say so. — A. I did not see the necessity of it."
A glance at Plan I will at once show how very easily the scheme of ventilation could have been improved, but it would appear from Mr. Whitticombe’s answer to the questions put by Mr. Carey, that no thought had been given to the matter. There can be no other reason; a system which comprised two doors across the main haulage road within 300 yards of the downcast shaft when, by the provision of one overcast, the ventilating current could have been taken straight to the face of that road and there split right and left, and the two doors dispensed with, supplies sufficient proof.
Searching for Matches and other Prohibited Articles. — A man, Morgan Thomas, was appointed to search on the morning shift and he gave evidence to the effect that he searched every man on that shift every day. This evidence was contradicted by the evidence of several of the workmen, some of whom said that when on the morning shift they had never been searched, and others who said that when on the morning shift they had been searched by Morgan Thomas, but not every day.
On the day of the explosion Morgan Thomas was not at work, so there was no search of the morning shift men on that day.
The fireman on the afternoon shift and the fireman on the night shift were authorised to search on those shifts.
The unfortunate fireman of the afternoon shift — Cheney — was not present to speak for himself, but the evidence of the men who had worked on that shift was to the effect that when working on the afternoon shift they had never been searched.
In regard to the night shift, the fireman, Gordon Hughes, said it was his duty to search the men on that shift and that he did search them "occasionally; not every day". He searched "about twice a week very nearly all of them". I have already remarked that I was not impressed with Hughes as a witness.
I fear the truth is that little searching, if any, was done of the men who worked on the afternoon and night shifts, and this fear is strengthened by the fact that after the explosion a cigarette was found contained in a tin box in a waistcoat pocket. This tin box measured approximately 3 inches by 2 inches by 1 inch, and was therefore not an article which could be easily missed by any person making a proper search. Its presence, having regard to its contents, seems to show very clearly that the man to whom it belonged knew perfectly well that no searching was being done.
General Remarks.
It appeared to me that some of the witnesses who were asked for their opinion as to the cause of the explosion, withheld that opinion because they did not wish to blame any person who had lost his life. Whilst such an attitude can be respected, it seems to me to be one which is neither helpful in such an Inquiry as this nor conducive to the prevention of similar accidents from similar causes in the future.
In conclusion I desire to express my thanks to the representatives of the several parties present at the Inquiry.
I have the honour to be,
Sir,
Your obedient Servant,
Henry Walker.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.