Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Particular (cont.).

Occurrence of the Explosion.

The explosion occurred at approximately 10 a.m. as Yorke and Hartlett were returning to 6's face by way of 6's dip.

It is not necessary to describe here the measures that were taken to help the injured and recover the bodies of the dead, but it is necessary to set out in some detail the evidence obtained subsequently from those concerned insofar as it throws any light on the difficult question of the point of origin of the explosion.

1. Yorke and Hartlett were between 500 and 600 yards from 6's face at the moment the explosion occurred. Yorke said he felt "a sudden rush of wind accompanied by dust; the dust was the road dust picked up off the floor". Hartlett said there was "like a strong gust of wind" and "just a bit of a thud"; the gust of wind did not blow him over, but stopped him walking.

2. E. J. Robinson, a stallman working at the loader in the intake road, stated that he heard no report whatever and saw no flash, but felt a rush of wind. His light was on a girder but was not knocked down; the light just went out and in again.

3. A. G. Cowell was working near the loader. He felt a strong gust of wind but saw no light, sparks or anything of the kind.

4. J. G. Marston was working at the intake end of 6's face, throwing his coal directly on to the loader. At the moment of the explosion he was facing the coal face, bending down. The noise was like a loud crash and there was a blast of hot air; he saw neither light nor sparks; he shut his eyes; the sound seemed to come over his right shoulder up in the roof; the explosion threw him on to the conveyor at the foot of the loader.

5. Harry Byard stated that at the moment of the explosion he was facing the first waste about 9 or 10 yards up the face from the wayhead; he was blown over; there was a loud explosion which sounded to be just at the back of him up in the roof, about 3 yards beyond him. He saw no light or flame or sparks — nothing whatever. There was a rush of very hot air; the conveyor and the loader were both working at the time of the explosion.

None of the men whose evidence is summarised above was burned at all by the explosion.

Proceeding further up the face, we come to the evidence of

6. Samuel Wright, who stated that he was working on the face about 15 to 20 yards from 6's gate road. At the moment of the explosion he was facing the wayhead; he heard a terrific bang which seemed to come from the direction of the far end, that is, from behind him; he was burned over the upper part of the body, blown over and peppered on the back by small coal.

Wright stated in evidence that there was only one bang and he did not see any flash or flame or sparks, or any lighting up of the face; he kept his eyes shut; the coal cutter was not working at the time of the explosion but the conveyor was.

All the men working inbye of Wright were badly burned and none of them survived to make any statement or to give evidence at the Inquiry. There is one fragment of evidence as to a statement made by Hayward at the time when Hayward and Marsden came out of the face together, badly burned, immediately after the explosion. Cowell stated in evidence that he heard Hayward say to Marsden, "Pity help those poor devils working in the top end". This statement might suggest — or at any rate lend some slight support to a suggestion on other grounds — that the explosion came on Hayward and Marsden from some point inbye of the place where they were working; this place, as far as is known, was at the coal cutter about 45 yards from the intake road along 6's face.

Condition of 6's face after the Explosion.

When the explosion occurred, Yorke sent Hartlett for the overman, Wightman, but on his way he met Mr. Smith acting Manager who immediately went down 6's dip towards the face, and came upon Wightman, Yorke and several of the haulage hands at the point where the return airway joined 6's dip.

Wightman told him (Mr. Smith) that the air was stationary in the face and not clearing. As the men present were anxious to go down the return airway he agreed to their doing so and he went out with them for about 200 yards. There was no blockage and the air was quite good and no smell of smoke, but he thought it foolhardy to go further by way of the return so brought the men back to 6's dip and then went towards the face.

The brattice cloths across 6's dip which divided the intake from the return were all in position and according to the evidence of the Overman, Wightman, had not been damaged by the explosion.

Wightman had sent for a shotfirer and relief deputy, James McCallum, and together, McCallum leading, they endeavoured to get along 6's face and, though the air was very thick with smoke, notwithstanding that Mr. Smith had arranged for an increase in the amount of ventilation, they with Byard, Marston and a third man, Dick Roberts, succeeded about a quarter before noon in getting as far as the coal cutter where they found the body of J. W. Morris. Later, the bodies of J. Casey, J. J. Miles and W. T. Hollis were found.

McCallum, in his evidence, stated that he examined carefully for firedamp as he went forward along the face but found none, and on a further examination made about one o'clock, after all the bodies had been recovered, he examined in the top end, the lip in the return airway and in the two topmost wastes and again found no firedamp. The roof along the whole face was weighting but he saw no signs of violence or other disturbance.

Mr. Smith, in company with the Undermanager and an Overman, David Casey, also examined the face and the return airway. They found no obstruction in the airway; the brattice cloth at the inbye end of the return airway was still in place and a test made for firedamp in the top end by David Casey showed the air to be clear. The roof was weighting, and Mr. Smith gave orders for sufficient props to be set to keep the face open.

Mr. Rowley and Mr. Scott, Senior and Junior Inspector respectively, inspected 6's face later in the day and Mr. Rowley's evidence on the weighting of the roof was to the effect that it was so severe, especially in the vicinity of the coal cutter, that if additional timber had not been set, the face would have been lost and inspection would have been impossible. Mr. Rowley said the explosion had left no evidence of force; there was a faint show of firedamp — less than 1 per cent — in the top end; two samples of the air taken opposite the coal cutter and one yard from the waste showed 10.8 and 11.87 per cent. of firedamp to be present. A further sample taken in the waste 13 yards on the outbye side of the coal cutter gave 6.61 per cent. of firedamp. The next waste outbye was clear and in the next a test was made by a deputy, Frank Thompson, who found 2 per cent. of firedamp to be present just above the edge of the waste lip.

The return airway was travelled and, except at its entrance, where there was ripping dirt down which, in the words of Mr. Rowley, "made it look a bit difficult to get in", it was quite a good road for about 100 yards when it got smaller for a short distance and then again became a good walking road.

Mr. Rowley considered that the explosion had been quite a small one and had covered a very limited area.

He said, "Except that the timbers were a bit blackened with dust at the top end, I quite think I could have been taken into that face and probably come out without having realised that an explosion had occurred".

Opinions As To Cause Of Explosion.

(a) Source of the Firedamp. — There was a divergence of opinion both as to the source of the firedamp which exploded and the means of ignition.

Mr. J. Ivon Graham, Deputy Director of the Mining Research Laboratory, University of Birmingham, called by Mr. Stewart, was of the opinion that there were two possible sources from which firedamp could have come, namely: (a) from the waste owing to barometric changes, and (b) from the soft mushy coal where Samuel Wright was making a "stamp" or "needle" hole for an 8-feet bar prior to the explosion. Mr. Graham discarded the first mentioned source for two reasons : (1) because in his experience in Newdigate and neighbouring collieries there is comparatively little firedamp in the wastes, and (2), although the barometer had been falling for some considerable time prior to the explosion, the rate of fall was so small that, in his opinion, it was improbable, having regard to the amount of ventilation passing along the face, that this change in pressure could have resulted in the emission of sufficient firedamp from the waste to form an explosive mixture in the face.

He thought the firedamp in this explosion had been suddenly emitted from the soft mushy coal. He based this view on his investigations in past years in connection with the amount of firedamp which may be taken up by coal and his experience of the evolution of firedamp from coal, particularly from outbursts in the anthracite area of South Wales.

Mr. Graham was fortified in his view by experiments which he made on samples collected by him of the soft mushy coal and of the normal hard coal in the Two Yard seam. He found that when samples of the mushy coal had been saturated with firedamp at a pressure of nearly one atmosphere, and were then subjected to a reduction of pressure of four-fifths of an atmosphere, they gave off in one minute 75 to 80 per cent. of the firedamp which had been put into them, whilst the sample of normal coal under similar conditions gave off only 1 per cent.

He explained that the tendency would be for the gas contained in the fine mushy coal in 6's face to be evolved very rapidly once that coal was exposed, and that the most probable point from which the gas in this explosion was given off was Where the bar was being set by Wright and where, after the explosion, a slip of coal was found to have fallen off the face. He calculated that from 10 tons of the soft coal 200 cubic feet of firedamp could be evolved in one minute.

Messrs. Smith, Yorke and Wightman also thought that the fire damp had come from the "slip-fault".

Mr. Rowley's opinion as to the source of the firedamp, given in his own words, was as follows :— "There were a lot of things operating that day which to my mind would tend to produce gas. You had a low barometer and you had the place on weight. You had the face somewhat disturbed and you would have gas given off from all these causes, chiefly though coming from the waste because of the low barometer

Mr. James McCallum, a witness whose work and testimony were very impressive, thought that the presence of firedamp was due to the heavy weighting which was on the whole length of 6's stall.

(b) Means of Ignition. — After the explosion, an electric lamp, No. 348, with its well glass and bulb glass broken, was found lying on the floor next the conveyor on the face side. The exact point along the face at which this lamp was found was in dispute. Mr. Rowley and Mr. Scott said the position as measured by tape and written down at the time the measurement was made, was 14 yards from 6's gate road. Mr. James Hamilton, Manager of Exhall Colliery, said he paced the distance from the lamp to 6's gate road and found it to be 25: paces, and this distance, which he called 25 yards, he wrote down in his note book at the time. Other witnesses spoke to finding the lamp at a point in front of the second waste, that is some 22 yards from 6's gate road.

The position of the lamp when found was of importance from the fact that, in the opinion of Mr. Graham and Mr. Smith, firedamp emitted from the soft mushy coal at the slip fault had been ignited by the still glowing filament of this electric lamp after the well glass and bulb glass had been broken.

This lamp had been issued to J. W. Morris, who with J. Blackwell had been put to hew off a knob of coal, and assuming that it was found, as, according to some witnesses it was found, opposite that knob of coal, the events visualised by Mr. Graham and Mr. Smith were :— Morris is hewing at the knob of coal with the lamp hanging near him: inadvertently he breaks the well glass and the glass of the bulb of his lamp by a stroke of his pick or other tool, and firedamp, issuing at the time from the mushy coal at the "slip-fault", is ignited at the still glowing filament.

This lamp was sent to Captain C. B. Platt, the Mines Department Superintending Testing Officer at Sheffield, and there examined. He found the filament broken, the fractured ends as seen through a microscope being blunt and not having the needle-like formation which would have been the case if the break had been due to burning in air or a mixture of firedamp and air.

Captain Platt produced micro-photographs of the broken filament which did not altogether appear to bear out his observation that the fractured ends were blunt, but he explained that his evidence was given not on what was shown by the photographs but on what he actually saw through the microscope, it being difficult to get a photographic result exactly as seen by the eye through the microscope.

Mr. Rowley did not agree that the broken electric lamp was the means of ignition. He considered that the firedamp had been ignited at the conveyor motor. He based that opinion on the fact that the face rose to the top end in which that motor was placed and he considered, when the firedamp was being given off from the waste, that point would be the most likely place for it to accumulate. He thought that if the broken lamp had been the means of ignition, in view of the contour of the face, a very much larger explosive mixture must have been present than, judging by the effects of the explosion, was in fact present.

That an explosive mixture could have been ignited at the conveyor motor was given in evidence by Mr. J. A. Bernard Horsley, H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines, who, when examining that motor on the day following the explosion, found a defect in the electrical contacts of the plug connector. This defect consisted of evidence of electrical burning or arcing between the pin and socket contact which served to convey the current from the plug on the trailing cable to the conveyor motor.

This plug was of the flat bat or pummel type containing three socket contacts in line. When the plug is pushed into the socket box on the motor the socket contacts in the plug engage with three pin contacts on the motor.

Two of these contacts, Mr. Horsley said, appeared to be unmarked but the third one showed obvious signs of electrical burning; the plug did not make a close fit in the socket, consequently firedamp would have access to the arcing contact which would be capable of igniting firedamp in explosive proportions and the flame would spread without difficulty to the surrounding atmosphere.

Mr. John Mackay, electrical tester for Messrs. Mayor and Coulson, who examined the conveyor motor and gave evidence, agreed that there were indications of arcing on one of the pin contacts, there being a general surface roughening on part of the surface towards the point of the pin. He thought some coal dust or something of that kind had got between the pin and the socket and intimate contact had thus been prevented; the plug was not flame-proof, but the pins were a good fit in the sockets and if the bolt which locks the plug in position is screwed tight home, the whole arrangement would be reasonably safe.

Remarks And Conclusion.

There are one or two facts which appear to upset the opinion that firedamp was rapidly evolved from the mushy coal in the "slip-fault". According to the evidence of Mr. N. C. Ebray, Surveyor, who made a Section from actual measurements of the position at the "slip-fault" where Samuel Wright had set an eight feet bar, the stamp or needle hole made for the face end of that bar had in fact passed through the clay, which was immediately in front of the mushy ground, and even through the mushy ground, yet firedamp, according to the evidence of the deputy, Yorke, who made tests, was not present. This seems contrary to the expectation of Mr. Graham who said that if Wright had pierced the clay, the firedamp would have come off at once.

Again, according to the evidence of Mr. Smith, there was in the No. 2 West face, of which inspection was made on 3rd November (when the barometer was as low as it was on 3rd September, the day of the explosion) a length, some 35 to 40 yards long, of mushy coal similar to that found in the slip-fault in No. 6's face, and yet tests made next to that mushy coal showed less firedamp to be present in the air than at other points on the face where such mushy coal was not present.

Mr. Smith also said that although similar slips were encountered from time to time, he had never seen any firedamp come from them.

Further, if the firedamp had been rapidly evolved from the mushy coal in the "slip-fault" in 6's face, as adumbrated by Mr. Graham, its first effect would have been to extinguish the flame lamp being used by Samuel Wright who, at the moment of the explosion, was kneeling sawing a tree, his lamp being alight and hung on a prop about 4½ ft. from the face and 18 inches to 2 feet above the floor, opposite the "slip-fault". According to Wright's evidence, the first he knew of the explosion was a terrific bang, and not that the light of his lamp was extinguished.

I am in agreement with Mr. McCallum and Mr. Rowley that firedamp would be given off due to the heavy weighting over the whole length of 6's face and with Mr. Rowley that it would also be given off at the "slip-fault" and, on account of the low barometer, issue freely from the wastes. But there is no evidence that the ventilation was not capable of diluting such firedamp as did issue due to these causes; on the contrary when the deputy, Yorke, made tests within an hour of the occurrence of the explosion, he did not detect the presence of firedamp. Moreover after the explosion had occurred, access to 6's face was not impeded by firedamp; there was firedamp in the wastes but not on the face.

At first, I considered the fall over the coal cutter was the most significant happening in that, if firedamp filled the cavity left by that fall, it might find its way into the top end and, in time, form an explosive mixture which would be ignited at the plug of the conveyor motor.

By the courtesy of Messrs. T. Wragg and Sons, experiments were carried out in their mine at Loxley by Mr. H. J. Humphrys, Senior Inspector, Yorkshire Division, and Dr. H. F. Coward and Mr. F. J. Hartwell of the Safety in Mines Research Board and Mr. G. A. Cutler of the Mines Department Testing Station, to ascertain if firedamp when issuing next the roof would form an explosive mixture in a fast end such as the top end of 6's face. The result of the experiments showed that, with an issue of firedamp at the rate of 4 to 8 cubic feet per minute, it was not possible under similar conditions of height, width, and ventilation as existed in 6's face at the time of the explosion, to obtain an explosive mixture more than 18 inches from the roof in the fast end. It would appear that to fill a fast end such as the top end of 6's face, one of two things is necessary; either a feeder of fired amp in that fast end, of which there was no evidence in this case, or a sudden emission of a fairly large volume of firedamp as a body and not as a stream.

It would appear therefore that the firedamp in the explosion had come into the face due to some sudden cause and was not due to a continuous feeder, and that that sudden cause was most probably, as suggested by Dr. Coward, a fall in the waste.

It is true that Mr. Graham said that, in his experience, there is comparatively little firedamp in the wastes in the Newdigate and neighbouring collieries: that experience, however, is not consonant with the evidence given at the Inquiry in respect of the waste next 6's face and in which Mr. Graham said he did not make a test.

As to the means of ignition, on the evidence of Captain Platt alone, it could not have been the damaged electric lamp No. 348. That evidence, the gist of which has already been given, was based on his own observations as well as on those of other investigators, in particular the investigations by Mr. W. C. F. Shepherd and Professor Wheeler as set out in the Safety in Mines Research Board Paper No. 36, entitled "The Ignition of Gases by Hot Wires".

Captain Platt's evidence as to the thinning of the ends of a filament broken by burning in air or a mixture of firedamp and air, was supported to a great extent by Mr. Graham who explained that he had carried out a number of tests to ascertain, if possible, the behaviour of a lighted electric bulb when broken in an explosive atmosphere, and he had found that by breaking such a bulb of the type used at the time of the accident, it was perfectly possible to explode a mixture of firedamp and air, provided the firedamp was "somewhere in the neighbourhood of 9 per cent. After ignition; the filament was broken and in most of his tests there was a tendency for the broken ends to be thinned at the end, just as happens when a filament is burned in air, but on two occasions he found that the ends appeared to him to be due to rather a sharp break.

There are other circumstances which make it difficult to agree to this damaged electric lamp being the means of ignition, namely

If, as suggested, this lamp was hanging near J. W. Morris as he was working at the knob of coal and was broken by him by a stroke of his pick or other tool, it is curious that he was not severely burnt by flame. According to the evidence of Dr. A. F. Wright, Morris, although he had a hairy chest and the skin was burnt by nascent steam or other hot product of the explosion, had not been exposed to flame for the hair in the area burnt was not singed.

Further, if this lamp was hanging opposite the knob of coal at the time of the explosion and firedamp became ignited by it after it was damaged, the three men, Wright, Byard and Marston, would it is certain have seen some lighting up of the face, if indeed they would not also have been enveloped in flame. Wright certainly was burned but Byard and Marston were not and none of the three saw any lighting up of any sort.

There is also the statement Hayward was heard by Cowell to make to Marsden: "Pity help those poor devils working in the top end" which seems to suggest that the explosion came from some point beyond the coal cutter where they were working.

The only other means of ignition suggested was arcing in the plug connector of the conveyor motor. This was the suggestion of Mr., Rowley, and on examination of this connector by Mr. Horsley on the day following the explosion it was plain to him that arcing had been taking place between the top pin and its socket. The effect of this arcing was also seen at a later date by Mr. Mackay, the maker's representative, who said no claim was made that the connector was flameproof.

Having considered the whole of the evidence, I have come to the conclusion that firedamp was suddenly ejected from the waste by a heavy fall and that an explosive mixture was formed in the top end of 6's face and there ignited by arcing in the plug connector of the conveyor motor.

Matters Arising Out Of The Explosion.

There are one or two points to which attention should be drawn:

(1) Although it would be difficult under present requirements to say that the use of the plug connector in such a place as 6's face was illegal, connectors which are not flameproof even in abnormal circumstances, such as arcing between pins and sockets, should not be allowed in any part of a mine to which General Regulation 132 (i) applies. In fact, I consider it desirable that none other than flameproof connectors should be used in any mine.

It is to be remarked that in the Newdigate Colliery, those connectors, which were not rated as flameproof, were at the time of the explosion in course of being replaced by others which were flameproof, and three only remained to be changed.

(2) It would be better when possible to have motors driving face conveyors placed at the intake end rather than at the return end of a face.

(3) The flame lamp (No. 680) of Samuel Wright was found after the explosion to be defective in that four of the pillars had come away from the top or middle ring of the lamp, thus weakening the general structure so that the framework was no longer rigid. The fractured ends of three of the pillars appeared to be old, that of the fourth had a new appearance.

There was no suggestion that this lamp was the cause of the explosion, but as the pillars of a lamp may be pulled away from the middle ring, or fractured within this ring, by the constant screwing up of the glass retaining ring, it is very necessary that the attention of lamproom attendants should be called to this possible defect.

I desire to record my thanks to the representatives of all the parties to the Inquiry and especially to express my appreciation of the spirit in which the problem was dealt with by them.

I have the honour to be,

Sir,

Your obedient servant,

Henry Walker.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z