Appendix VIII.
M.D. Circ. No. 31.
Mines Department,
Dean Stanley Street,
Millbank, Westminster,
London, S.W. 1.
12th November, 1928.
Dear Sir,
I wish to call attention again to the accidents which occur from time to time through ignitions of firedamp attributable to the use of electric power at or near the coal face. During the last five years there have been 13 such accidents and they have resulted in the deaths of 17 persons and injuries to 52 others.
These accidents almost invariably have two features in common, viz
(a) A temporary and, generally, local deficiency in the ventilating current, together with failure on the part of the officials in the area directly affected to detect that deficiency in time or to appreciate its probable consequences, and
(b) A coincident defect in the flame proof enclosure of the electrical equipment, or some equivalent defect in the accessories designed to prevent open sparking.
1. Ventilation. — In several instances the working of coal-cutting machines in fast ends of longwall faces where ventilation was either quite inadequate or totally absent, has resulted in explosions of firedamp not only in seams which were admittedly fiery, but also in seams which, prior to the accident, had been considered comparatively free from firedamp.
The necessity for ventilating thoroughly the fast sides of machine faces has been emphasised again and again in the published reports of H.M. Inspectors. I emphasise it again now. I disapprove of reliance being placed under such conditions upon "leakage through the pack" or similar expedients. I deprecate also the use of auxiliary fans and the like, run intermittently to "clear the district."
It is not always sufficiently appreciated that the use of coal-cutting machines is likely to result in the emission of more firedamp than is the case under hand-working conditions in the same seam, if only because fresh coal surfaces are much more rapidly exposed by the former process than by the latter.
Good ventilation is always necessary, but it is doubly so in machine-cut faces. It is essential to ensure not only an ample and constant general ventilating current, but also that from hour to hour under the changing conditions the details of bratticing are kept right and all possible steps are taken to guard against the temporary accumulation of even a small quantity of inflammable gas.
I ask all managers concerned to impress this second point on their firemen and deputies and to consider seriously, according to the conditions of the mines in their charge, whether the ordinary two or three inspections per shift by the deputies are sufficient in machine-mined districts.
I believe that there are still many of them who when they investigate the matter closely will find that during coal-cutting operations a closer supervision and more frequent inspections are desirable not only on grounds of safety but on economic grounds also.
2. Defects in the Electrical Apparatus — These can be classified under two heads, viz —
(1) Imperfection of design.
(2) Lack of proper maintenance.
The first sometimes contributes to bring about the second; but the evidence is that neglect to maintain the apparatus in its designed condition of safety is the usual contributory cause of the accident.
During the years 1914 to 1927 inclusive there were 28 instances of the ignition of firedamp by open sparking, and in the majority of these, serious and obvious defects were found in the enclosure of the electrical working parts. The number of accidents is not large, but with all explosions there is the potentiality of a big disaster and I am afraid that conditions predisposing to similar accidents still exist in some cases. They are brought to light from time to time in the course of official inspections.
One of the commonest defects is the loss or omission of screws from cover plates, whereby an opening is left into a switch box or some equally dangerous part of the apparatus.
An even more common, but less obviously dangerous defect, results from insecure fixing of cover plates where screwed stems have been broken in the hole. Sometimes these are not replaced and sometimes they are unskilfully drilled out with resulting damage to the thread.
Automatic interlocks, to prevent the withdrawal of the plug while the current is flowing, are not universal and are sometimes inoperative, and few of the commoner types of plugs in use can be regarded as flame-proof even with such an interlock.
To secure greater efficiency and uniformity in the safety features of design of electrical machinery I suggest that the following principles should be regarded as essential in flame-proof enclosures, viz. —
(a) no unbottomed screw boles through the walls of the enclosure;
(b) some device, such as a spring washer or a lock nut, to check the tendency of screws to work loose under vibration;
(c) no unshielded projecting screw heads, nor, in case of movable machinery, projecting edges of cover plates which may be caught and displaced;
(d) no drain plug-holes or other similar openings so placed that they cannot be readily inspected;
(e) no connecting passages between separate parts of the enclosure; (f) a terminal box, for the external circuit connections outside the flame-proof enclosure;
(g) a flame-proof plug and socket coupling, such as the B.E.S.A. type.
I ask that these requirements should be definitely specified by mine owners in ordering all new equipment, and that steps be taken at all mines where this has not already been done to modify existing equipment to comply with items (a), (b) and (g).
Nevertheless, while sound design will make the task of efficient maintenance easier, it does not do away with the need for frequent systematic and skilled examination of the machinery, followed, where necessary, by prompt and effective repair.
This work of inspection and repair should be entrusted only to trained mechanics, who should receive special instructions to enable them to recognise defects that may result in open sparking. It is too much to expect a coal-cutting machine-man, or a fireman, or even a mechanic uninstructed in the principles of flame-proof enclosure, to recognise defects in the equipment which, although they may seriously impair its safety in the presence of inflammable gas, may have no effect at all upon its ordinary working efficiency.
I have publicly expressed the view that in the future the working of coal seams is likely to depend more and more upon the use of cutting machines driven by electricity. I believe it will be little short of disastrous to the interests of the industry if confidence is impaired and development is checked by untoward and avoidable accidents with such machines, and it is with this consideration in mind, second only to the vital interest of safety, that I urge mine managers to adopt the suggestions set out in the foregoing paragraphs.
Yours faithfully,
(Signed) H. Walker,
H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines.
To the Owners, Agents and Managers of Mines in which electricity is used.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.