Appendix VI.
Report of H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines upon the electrical apparatus involved in the ignition of firedamp on 10th July, 1929, at Milfraen Colliery, Blaenavon Company, Ltd., Monmouth.
I visited the colliery on 12th July, and in company with yourself and others, including the Agent, Mr. Cartwright, and the Colliery Electrician in charge, I made inspection of the Hopkinson electrical coal-cutting machine No. 928 in situ, at the coal face in the Black Vein Seam of Milfraen pit.
The motor is a 3-phase induction motor with a squirrel cage rotor, and it was used upon a 3-phase 500-volt system.
I also examined the trailing cable and the plugs and the gate-end switch box in use with this machine.
2. I did not find any such defect in the cable, or the plugs, or the gate-end switch box that would account for the ignition. I did observe that the earthing pin for the plug at the gate-end box was not properly inserted and could not be properly inserted. The reason for this defect was afterwards found to he that the plug had been hammered so as to deform the screwed hole provided for the reception of this pin.
3. As to the machine, I found that out of four set screws provided in the design for attaching a semicircular cover to the frame of the machine, over the terminal chamber or intermediate section between the switch box and the motor, three screws were missing and that the screwed boles in the lower frame of the machine provided for the reception of these three set screws were filled with stone chippings.
I also found that the fourth set screw was loose and could be lifted out of the hole.
It was afterwards found that this set screw was too short to engage with the screwed hole in the lower frame of the machine.
4. With regard to the semicircular cover, I also observed that it was not properly in place, i.e., it was not hard down upon the flanged horizontal seating that was provided for it on the frame of the machine. The ribbed edgings along the semicircular sides were standing above the corresponding edgings in the frame of the machine.
5. The result was that there was an opening along the horizontal flanged joint between this cover and the frame of the machine on that side adjacent to the coalface.
This opening extending horizontally for a length of approximately five inches was wide enough to allow feeler gauges totalling .06 inch to he inserted with ease.
The gauge available at the time did not enable me to determine the maximum width of the opening, but it was obviously greater than .06 inch.
6. The semicircular cover was so tightly held between the side flanges of the machine frame that it could not be moved either to close or open the horizontal joint, by any force that the electrician was able to exert.
7. With respect to the flat vertical end cover plate enclosing the switch box, I observed that the nuts were missing from three out of the five screwed stems provided for securing this cover plate to the switch box.
The joint surfaces, however, between this cover plate and the seating on the switch box appeared to be closed.
When gauged the width of the gap was found to range from .020 to .022 inch, while the breadth of the flange was 1 inch except at three places where it was inch.
8. As a result of my examination in the pit I formed the opinion that the opening in the enclosure of the electrical parts of the machine, between the semicircular cover and the frame of the machine was sufficiently wide to permit the flame of firedamp ignited within the enclosure to pass out and ignite firedamp in the surrounding atmosphere.
In other words, this part of the enclosure, in the condition in which I found it, was not effective to prevent open sparking.
9. On 16th July I again visited the colliery and made a thorough examination of the enclosure of the machine, which had been brought to bank for that purpose. I then found that the opening, which had been observed in the pit, between the semicircular cover and the frame of the machine over a distance of six inches ranged from .08 inch at the widest part to .072 inch at the narrowest part.
The breadth of the flanged joint where this opening was observed was, with respect to the cover 1 1/8 inch and with respect to the seating 1¼ inch, except at a point midway between the bolt holes where it was reduced to 1 inch. This reduction was caused by a segmental section cut out of the flanged seating at its external edge.
10. When set screws were inserted and screwed down this opening between the flanged surface, i.e., between the semicircular cover and the seating on the machine frame, was reduced to .004 inch.
11. The corresponding flanged joint on the other side of the cover was found to be open with a width of opening ranging from .031 inch to .035 inch over the whole length of the flange.
When set screws were inserted and screwed down this opening was reduced to .007 inch.
12. I did not find any other openings in the enclosure of electrical parts of the machine that were of material importance in view of the position and dimensions of the opening that I have recorded in this respect.
The width of the gap between the flanged joint surfaces between the upper and lower halves of the machine frame ranged from .002 inch to .008 inch; over a considerable distance on one side of the machine, i.e., that which was adjacent to the coal face, the width of this gap was .006 inch.
The breadth of these flanged joint surfaces ranged from 1¾ to 1½ inch.
13. The switch in the machine, for starting and stopping the motor, is an air break switch with three positions, i.e., there is a position for "starting" and for "running" with an intermediate "off" position.
There is a mechanical interlock which compels the operator, when he desires to start the motor, to move the switch first to the "starting" position and then, when the motor had begun to rotate, to move the switch smartly from the "starting" position, through the "off" position, to the running position.
To stop the motor the switch is moved from the "running" position to the "off" position.
14. In normal use therefore an arc or spark will pass between the fixed and moving contacts when the circuit is broken by moving the switch from the "starting" position to the "running" position and also when the switch is moved from the "running" position to the "off" position.
Sparks or arcs may also occur, and, indeed, are likely to occur unless the switch is in perfect condition, when the circuit is made by moving the switch to the "starting" position.
15. I observed the general condition of the switch in the machine. There was considerable local fusion of the contact surfaces between the fixed and moving parts of the switch. Such fusion would result from the normal use of the switch, i.e., by the arc or break flash when the switch was used to start or stop the machine. I observed in particular that, owing to this fusion, there was very imperfect contact between the two of the contacts which complete the circuit when the switch is in tbe running position. The effect of such fusion is to roughen the contact surfaces and thus to make the contact imperfect.
When electrical contact becomes imperfect, arcing or sparking is likely to occur between the fixed and moving contacts of the switch while the current is flowing, i.e., when the motor is running with the switch in the running position.
16. The whole of the enclosure of the electrical parts of the machine, i.e., the motor and the switch with the connections between these parts is one enclosure, so that if inflammable gas entered at any part of the enclosure it would have access to the switch.
Firedamp could enter the enclosure along almost the whole length of the flanged joint between the upper and lower halves of the machine frame. It could also enter, readily by the widely open joint between the semicircular cover, over the intermediate section, and the frame of the machine.
17. If firedamp accumulated in inflammable (explosive) proportions within the enclosure it would be immediately ignited by an arcing or sparking at the switch contacts.
If such gas was ignited within the enclosure, the flame or heated gases result ing from combustion would pass through the gap .08 inch wide between the flanges 1 1/8 inch broad at a temperature sufficient to ignite firedamp present in explosive proportion in the surrounding atmosphere.
18. It was shewn by means of laboratory experiments (see S.M.R.B. paper No. 5) Flame-proof apparatus for use in Coal Mines, First report — Flange protection, by I. C. F. Statham and R. V. Wheeler (page 37, Table XIX, experiment 326), that a gap width of 4/64 inch (.0625 inch) between the flanges 1 inch broad resulted in an external ignition.
19. Under the same experimental conditions it was shewn that a gap width of 3/64 inch (.047 inch) did not result in an external ignition.
It was also shewn that if the flange breadth was reduced to ½ inch the "safe" gap was narrower, but that if the flange breadth was increased beyond 1 inch the "safe" gap would not be enlarged.
20. These experiments were made with spherical vessels and under conditions that ensured that the gap width was not momentarily enlarged by springing, or temporary distortion, of the parts.
(Signed) J. A. Bernard Horsley.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.