Cause of Crumps at Pendleton Colliery. — The vital question to be answered, if possible, is — What causes the sudden uplift of the floor, which is the chief and most destructive effect of the crumps experienced in this Colliery? It is not entirely a matter of depth with its consequent great pressure difference. For if it were so, we might expect crumps to happen universally below a certain critical depth. In the Rams Seam at Pendleton, the immediate cause would seem to be the relative weakness of the floor. It further appears that it is the floor at and near the working face which is especially liable to burst, and this because of an increased weight brought to bear upon the coal at the working face. A gradually increasing weight upon the coal at the face must come about consequent upon the working out of the seam, relieved of course, and to that extent diminished, by the artificial support of the roof by timbering and packs in the goaf, and relieved also by breaks in the roof near to the face, which have the effect of throwing more roof weight upon the packs in the goaf.
In any consideration of the great stresses which affect the strata in mines, such for example as the weight of the roof concentrated by cantilever action upon the coal at the working face, it is important to take into account the great effect produced by a sudden blow, as when some powerful compressive or bending stress is suddenly released. The "Bumps" which sometimes occur in working the Thick Coal of South Staffordshire are brought about by the sudden collapse of large masses of rock in the higher roof, where a space has been left between the sagging immediate and softer roof and the stronger roof above. It is quite possible that a similar thing happens at Pendleton Colliery where portions of the more massive roof may suddenly fall upon the softer metal roof, which has already sagged in the goaf. Such violent impact would be sufficient to produce a great and momentary increase of weight on the coal face, and this sudden extra weight might be sufficient to overcome the resistance of the floor, which in consequence would burst up and produce a crump.
In this connection it may be noted that the shaley character of the floor between the Rams Seam and the Little Rams Seam would lend itself to a lateral shearing movement away from the coal-face towards the packs when the increased downward pressure on the coal-face is felt. The appearance of the chocks and props after the accident of November, 1925, was consistent with such a lateral thrust of the floor away from the coal-face.
There is another way in which a sudden and violent shock may be imparted to the coal-face, and that is by the sudden release of stresses induced by the bending or arching of the roof, the release being due to fracture some distance from the face. By this means the coal-face or pillar would suffer a powerful and instantaneous downward blow, which might produce a serious crump.
Minor crumps which involve the sudden spalling or "rating" of large and small lumps and masses of coal from the coal-face are of frequent occurrence at Pendleton Colliery, and occasionally cause serious injury to the miner. Such occurrences, as well as the crushing and splintering of the body of the seam for some distance into the face, are part of the same general phenomena as the more severe crumps which are accompanied by a sudden uplift of the floor, and all are the result of the same group of causes.
It has been said already that the ground where the Rams Seam is being worked in the deepest part of the Pendleton Colliery, and where severe crumps have occurred, is traversed by a number of nearly east and west faults. It is necessary to inquire whether these faults are in any way a pre-disposing cause of crumps.
On general grounds it may be argued that the presence of such faults must lead to greater instability than would obtain in their absence. It is well known to geologists and seismologists that sudden slippages along old faults frequently take place, and that many earthquakes, small and large, in this country and abroad, arise from such slippages.
A sudden movement along the plane of fracture of one of the faults traversing the Pendleton Mine, involving it may be only a slight further dislocation, might be sufficient to disturb momentarily the stress equilibrium in the rocks, and so help to produce a crump.
Another way in which faults, it is suggested, may be a contributory cause was referred to in evidence by the General Manager of the Colliery. A section of unworked coal may be isolated by faults on one or more sides, with the result that there comes a time when so much roof weight is thrown upon the unworked remnant of the section, which is of the nature of an unworked pillar, that the critical point of floor resistance is reached, and a crump ensues. Whether this is the real explanation or not, it is significant that serious crumps have occurred in heavily faulted ground at Pendleton. In other coalfields abroad, as for example in Nova Scotia, faults are believed to be a contributory cause of such sudden disturbances.*
To decide whether or not this is the real explanation of the effect produced by one or more faults bordering an unworked section or pillar of coal, it would be necessary to know the nature of the faulted ground, and whether the strata adjacent to the fault were in a state of lateral tension or compression, and further, whether the fault-plane is in the nature of a fracture similar to fractures which appear in the roof of a mine. But the vital question would be, as indicated above, whether the fault is still "alive," and small slippages still taking place or liable to happen along the fault-plane.
Factors contributing to increased pressure at Pendleton Colliery. — If we are right in concluding that it is the increased, and in some cases suddenly increased, roof pressure on the coalface which is the chief cause of crumps at Pendleton, at all events those severe crumps which involve injury and loss of life, we have to inquire as to all known factors which may contribute to such an increased pressure.
Apart from the baring of the roof and consequent removal of support in extracting the coal, how far is the weight on the coalface increased, directly or indirectly, by the inclination of the strata, by faults, presence or absence of cleat, and method of working?
With regard to the inclination of strata, which at Pendleton is about 1 in 3. it has been found that the liability to crumps in the Rhenish-Westphalian coal mines** is greater when the measures are horizontal or nearly so than is the case when the measures dip at a considerable angle, although instances are cited where violent bumps accompanied by heavy falls occurred in inclined beds.
The facility with which the roof breaks behind the coal face is an important matter, and related to the method adopted in working the seam. It will be evident that where the solid roof can fracture easily and regularly as the coal-face advances, the extra weight thrown upon the coal-face by opening out will be continuously limited by such breaks. Therefore any practice which tends to produce such regular fracture and steady fall of the roof in the goaf near to the coal-face will conduce to safe working and tend to avoid crumps.
The experience at Pendleton Colliery accords with what we should expect, namely, that in working the coal to the rise, the roof tends to break more freely and regularly than when it is worked to the dip. Since at Pendleton the main cleat makes a relatively small angle with the strike, breaks in the roof tend to develop the more easily when the coal is worked either to the rise or to the dip than when worked "on end."
The significant fact emerged in the evidence of the General Manager that most of the serious crumps at Pendleton Colliery have occurred when the Rams Seam was being worked "on end," and this in spite of the fact that the face is often stepped. A possible explanation for this advanced by Mr. Browne seems to us reasonable. It is that when the coal is worked "on end," the roof cannot fracture so readily as it does when the coal is worked to the rise, and, to a less extent, to the dip. The inevitable result is, therefore, that when the coal is worked "on end," an ever increasing weight comes on to the coal at the face, with the serious risk of a severe crump.
* "Occurrence of Bumps in the Springhill No. 2 Mine of the Dominion Coal Company, Ltd." Report by G. S. Rice, Chief Mining Engineer, U.S. Bureau of Mines.
** See note on p. 7.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.