The Plodder Seam
(7) The Plodder (sometimes known as the Ravine) Seam has a worked section at Bickershaw of about 6 feet. It lies immediately over the Haigh Yard Seam. These two seams, and their associated dirt bands, have an overall thickness of 18 feet. The Plodder Seam is well known in the coalfields as one liable to spontaneous combustion, particularly in the Wigan and Leigh areas, and there is at Bickershaw a long experience of trouble from this cause. With seams so close together as the Plodder and Haigh Yard, spontaneous heating can occur in the individual working of either, since the extraction of any one is bound to expose, in part, the other. The risk of self-heating is often associated with such thick seams in close proximity.
(8) At Bickershaw Colliery the Plodder Seam was developed in a south easterly direction on a line of almost full dip at an average gradient of 1 in 7. By 1959 a large amount of extraction had taken place and large goaf areas formed. Progress was by a developing face to the dip with wing faces advancing east and west respectively.
(9) At the end of August, 1959, only two longwall faces were working in the Plodder Seam; Nos. 1 and 2 Dip Faces with a combined output of about 550 tons per day. The only other accessible face was the No. 9 East, which ceased production on 14th August, 1959 (see Plan). It was still being ventilated, and a small team of men were engaged in salvaging material. Of the three open faces, No. 2 was ventilated by an air current separate from the others, while another split of air was conducted, first along No. 1 Dip Face after which it passed into the Main Level of the No. 9 East Face, where it was augmented by some intake leakage from the No. 4 Brow. The quantity of air ventilating No. 9 East, when last measured on 21st August, 1959, was 14,700 cubic feet per minute, and the average percentage of inflammable gas in the return airway from this face as determined at a point 10 yards from the face on No. 9 East Top Level was 0.95 per centum. Of this gas some was contributed by No. 2 Dip Face, the air on which normally contained about 0.3 per centum in a quantity of 12,500 cubic feet per minute. A rough estimation suggests an average emission of firedamp on No. 9 Face alone of the order of 100 cubic feet per minute.
(10) The No. 9 Face had advanced about 800 yards alongside the goaf of the old abandoned No. 8 Face to the rise side, keeping contact with this goaf as it progressed, while the No. 9 right hand or dip side was forming a coal rib. Both Main and Top Levels of No. 9 Face were supported by steel arches. The general dimensions of the Main Level were 13 feet wide by 10 feet high: those of the Top Level, 9 feet wide by 7 feet high at the face, but, owing to severe crush probably associated with the nearness of the No. 8 goaf, it was reduced in size to about 3½ feet by 4½ feet for about 200 yards of its total length.
(11) The No. 8 East Face, when working, was 160 yards in length. It ceased production on 9th August, 1957, and stoppings were put in some three months later. These stoppings were later extended by the stowing of waste dirt and by October, 1959, the No. 8 Top Level stopping was 150 yards long, and the No. 8 Main Level stopping, 100 yards long.
Events Before The Sealing Of No. 9 Face
(12) During the morning of Sunday, the 4th October, a deputy, F. Hodgson, accompanied by a workman as a travelling companion, was making an ordinary week-end inspection of No. 9 Face. These two men entered the face by the Main Level (intake), travelled up the face, and then out by the Top Level (return). Immediately on leaving the face at the Top Level, Hodgson noticed a smell of "heating" when he was about 3 yards outbye the face ripping lip. He also recognised some haze and "sweating" on the roof at the higher side, adjoining the abandoned No. 8 Face. These findings were communicated to the manager who subsequently made an examination of the place accompanied by the assistant manager, Mr. Allison. Mr. Lawson decided that it would be practicable to deal with the heating by excavating or "digging out" the pack, and steps were taken at once to do this.
(13) During that Sunday afternoon, and the two following shifts, men were engaged in removing the packing, and from the evidence of those engaged on this work, it is possible that this excavation eventually penetrated for some few feet at least, into what was originally the right hand pack of the abandoned No. 8 Face. About the heating there was no doubt: the packing material taken out was hot and had to be quenched with water before being cast aside, and at one time or another incandescence was observed by Mr. Allison and by one of the deputies immediately in supervision.
(14) By the end of the morning shift of Monday, the 5th October, it was decided that all the heated material had been removed and quenched and steps were then taken to restore the roadway side by filling the excavation with sand, faced with a sand bag wall. All this was completed by the end of the morning shift on the 6th, by which time the road surfaces were observed to be sensibly cooler.
(15) During the digging out operations, and the subsequent re-sealing of the affected part of the packing, atmospheric conditions were not unduly uncomfortable. Samples of the atmosphere from the general body of the air in No. 9 Top Level on the return side of the place where the heating was found did not, on analysis, give gaseous constituents of the character which might have been expected from heated ground of the intensity actually observed. The carbon monoxide content (0.0014-0.0036 per centum) was not unduly high for the Plodder Seam at Bickershaw.
(16) Although the management were convinced that the heated material had been successfully removed, the occurrence served as a warning that it was time for the No. 9 Face to be abandoned and stopped off. Salvage operations were almost completed, and Mr. Lawson therefore decided to put in final stoppings.
(17) It is the usual practice in the Plodder Seam at Bickershaw to seal off abandoned panels by first building stoppings in the levels some 70 to 100 yards inbye of the main airway from which they were set out. Once the sealing of the panel has been completed, the remaining space outbye the stopping is then used for the intermittent stowing of waste dirt, with the result that the stoppings are gradually increased in thickness until they can be finally faced with a masonry wall alongside the main airway.
(18) It is also usual when ordinary stoppings have to be built for members of the Central Rescue Corps to assist. This course is taken, not as an emergency measure, but because these men are trained in the building of stoppings and their help usually results in the stoppings being built more quickly. Since their training takes account of fire and explosion risks, their procedure is always in accordance with these risks whether or not they are known to exist.
(19) The building of the stoppings in the two roads leading to No. 9 Face was begun on the morning shift of Friday, the 9th October, and work was continuous. In the Main Level, the place selected was 72 yards from the No. 9 Scouring at a point where the steel arched roadway was about 13 feet wide and 10 feet high. The stopping in the No. 9 Top Level was 64 yards from the Scouring where the roadway was from 5 feet to 7 feet wide and 3 feet to 3 feet 6 inches high. The stoppings were constructed mainly of bags of sand with some intermingling of bags of dirt filled on the spot. They were said to be reinforced with old arches or rails or whatever else was handy, both at the inbye end and throughout their length. During the erection of the stoppings the practice was adopted of leaving narrow tunnels about 3 feet square through the base of each stopping with the object of preserving some ventilation round No. 9 Face, until the sealing could be completed finally and quickly by plugging the tunnels simultaneously with further sand bags.
(20) Both stoppings were complete except for the sealing of the tunnels by about 10 a.m. on the 10th October, at which time the Top Level (return) stopping was 11 yards in length, and the Main Level (intake) stopping 8 yards in length. The final sealing of the tunnels was completed about mid-day: the intake at 12.15 p.m. and the return half an hour later.
(21) When both seals were completed, the separation doors in No. 9 Scouring between intake and return levels were opened to provide a free flow of air from the No. 1 Dip Face into the main return (No. 3 Brow). The immediate result of this was that for 64 yards of No. 9 Main Level, and for 53 yards of No. 9 Top Level there was no positive ventilation. This would not necessarily produce at once a vitiated, poisonous, or inflammable atmosphere at the face of the stoppings since all stoppings leak a bit at first, and there would still be a small flow of air through them if only because of a small pressure difference resulting from the difference in level of the two stoppings. For the two "blind" ends outbye the stoppings the manager had made provision for auxiliary ventilation by installing fans should their need arise. However other events supervened, and I do not think the operation of the fans would have changed the circumstances. However, as an aside, I feel it my duty to say that auxiliary ventilation should have been put into operation as a prudent measure against the accumulation of dangerous amounts of inflammable or noxious gases following the arrest of the main ventilation by the stoppings.
(22) The No. 9 Face, and parts of the two roads leading to it, were thus finally sealed off almost two months after coal production ceased, and four days after the heating in the Top Level had been dealt with.