The first witness called was JAMES DAVIES — sworn.
Examined by the Coroner,
1. Where do you live ? — No. 3, Don Street, Newton.
2. Are you a collier ? — Yes.
3. Do you work at the Hyde Lane Colliery ? — Yes.
4. How long have you worked there ? — About 18 months.
5. What time did you go down the pit on the 18th of January last ? — About 10 minutes to 6.
6. Where were you working ? — No. 6, Far End Brow.
7. No. 6 level ? — Yes.
8. At the far end, did you say ? — Yes.
9. How far is that from the pit mouth ? — Somewhere about a mile.
10. Did you see the under-looker when you went down ? — Yes.
11. Who was he ? — Edward Jackson.
12. Is he one of the killed ? — No.
13. Did you ask him whether your working was all right ? — He was not my fireman.
14. Who was your fireman ? — Joseph Wilde.
15. Did you see him ? — Yes.
16. Did you ask him ? — Yes; and he said it was all right.
17. He told you that your workings were safe ? — Yes.
18. Did you perceive any gas when you got there ? — No.
19. Were you working with a naked light ? — Yes.
20. Was anybody else working with you ? — Joseph Fish and James Hall.
21. How far were they ? — They were near the same place, William Haslam as well.
22. Did you see Haslam ? — Yes.
23. Were they all three killed ? — Yes.
24. Did they make any remark to you about the presence of gas ? — No.
25. About a quarter past nine did anything occur Yes, a heavy shock came and a loud report.
26. Did you see something ? — No, I felt something.
27. What was the result of the shock upon you ? — It threw a lot of dust, and cut me in the face and arm on the left side, and blew me over the side.
28. Dust and small stones did you say ? — Yes, and coal mixed together.
29. Were your lights extinguished ? — Yes.
30. All of them ? — Yes.
31. You did not see any flame ? — No.
32. What did you do then ? — It came down upon me, and I crept quiet into the waggon road.
33. Did you remain there for some time ? — Yes.
34. In your working ? — Yes.
35. How long ? — I cannot say. It was in the dark. I had no watch.
36. Then you went into the waggon road ? — We searched about and found a bottle with some tea in it, and we drank some tea. I wet my waistcoat and put it over my mouth, and told the others to do the same. I then got a nail and placed it in my mouth.
37. Was there any after-damp ? — Yes, we found some on the road.
38. You did not find it on your working ? — No.
39. You got a nail and put it in your mouth ? — Yes.
40. And told the others to do the same ? — Yes.
41. Did they do so ? — I cannot say, sir.
42. Where does the westerly direction lead you to ? — What ?
43. You say you went westward ? — No; I said I drank some tea and wet my waistcoat.
44. You wrapped your waistcoat over your head ? — Yes.
45. Where did you go into then ? — Some distance along the waggon road.
46. Towards the pit shaft ? — No, we turned back.
47. When you got into the waggon road ? — We went about 40 yards.
48. Did you see anything ? — We smelt some damp, and we turned back. I went down into the place below, No. 5, in the working — the top end of the working.
49. Did the others go with you ? — No; and I came back and found the air strong and warm.
50. Strong and damp ? — Yes. We stopped back behind the pack a few minutes where it was fresh, by the pack walls on the air road. And then we went on the road and found it a little thinner than before, and we travelled on.
51. Was that the horse road ? — No, the level back.
52. What is the number of the level you went down ? — No. 6.
53. Is that the second time you went down there ? — Yes.
54. The air was then clearer ? — Yes.
55. Were you able to proceed ? — Yes.
56. Did you come across anything ? — Yes, we found a man at the road end.
57. Who was he ? — William Haslam.
58. He was the one with you ? — Yes, he was waiting for us.
59. Where was William Haslam ? — The road end.
60. Was Haslam on the jig or the level ? — On the level.
61. Was he dead ? — Yes.
62. Then after that ? — We came down the brow. When we got to No. 2 we met another man there with a lad.
63. Who was with you all this time ? — Joseph Fish. We could not get any further than the level end.
64. Did you know who was in No. 2 level ? — Yes, Henry Slater.
65. Where was he lying ? — He was standing or sitting down.
66. Oh, he was lying ? — Yes.
67. Who was with you, do you say, before you got to Fish? — Only Fish was with me when we got to Slater.
68. What did you do then ? — He asked who we was. We told him Fish and Davies, and we said, "This is a bad job," and he said, "It was ; and we had to make the best of it." Some went further down to the bottom of the road.
69. Did he go with you ? — Yes; he started with us, and followed us. I said, "We will get through this door an quick as we can, where there is some fresh air." When I got to the turn brow, I shouted, and got no answer.
70. What did you say ? — I shouted to him, "there was a better air;" but I got no answer, and we went down to where the fresh air came on.
71. You went forward after you got no reply ? — Yes; I went down to the bottom of the turn brow.
72. Where there was fresh air ? — Yes. I stopped there till some one came.
73. Who came? — Moores and John Fish first.
74. Were they working in the pit at the time ? — Yes, they worked on that level further in. They had been out, and were coming back again seeking the watch; and they asked me how I was, and I told them ; and I said "that I could travel a bit further;" and they said there were some one behind, and he had two lads. And I travelled on till I got to the pit shaft.
75. Did you come across any other body ? — No, not from then; only what was alive.
76. They were taken to the surface ? — Yes.
77. During the whole time that you have worked there have you seen any gas ? — No.
78. No indications of gas ? — No.
79. Have you had any reason to complain of the ventilation ? — No.
80. Had you plenty of ventilation at your working? — Yes.
81. How long have you been a collier ? — Somewhere about 26 years.
82. Do you consider the mine a safe one ? — Yes.
Examined by Mr. Atkinson.
83. What part of your working were you in when the explosion occurred ? — At the pack wall.
84. At the back of the face ? — Yes, at the bottom.
85. Were you burnt at all ? — No.
86. Was your face not ? — No; it was tatooed with splinters, together with the coal and dirt.
87. Did you use a safety lamp as well as a candle ? — Yes.
88. Where was the lamp ? — It was down in the road at the time.
89. At the same place as you were ? — No; Fish had gone with his lamp. They had something. They could not see with the candle. It blows the flame about in the, lower road. This lamp, now, let us see where he was.
90. (Coroner.) The lamp was down the road ? — In the waggon road.
91. (Mr. Atkinson.) How far from the face ? — The lamp ?
92. Yes ? — It might be a 10 yards on the road. We had done the morning then.
93. Did you observe any difference in the ventilation that morning to what it had been previously ? — No.
94. Had you heard any fall in the goaf ? — No, not that morning.
95. Nothing at all ? — Not that morning.
96. I am referring to that morning. No signs that the goaf was weighting ? — No.
97. I do not quite understand where Fish was. Could you explain ? — He was about 10 yards from either brow. We call it "snap breakfast" — 10 yards north from the face.
(A Juryman.) Do you mean 10 yards waggon road ?
98. (Mr. Atkinson.) Ten yards outbye from face ? — Ten yards at the far end of the. face on the waggon end, nearer the brow.
99. (A Juryman.) He was not in the sixth level ? — Yes, that was in the sixth level.
100. (Mr. Atkinson.) You say he had your lamp on account of the strong current of air there ? — He had with it in the walling; we were done walling.
Examined by Mr. Sawyer.
101. Did you find that door between the far end brow and the turn brow open or shut ? — Shut.
(Coroner.) Which door is that ?
(Mr. Sawyer.) It is in the horse level.
102. (Mr. Atkinson.) The door we are asking about is that on the horse level on the inbye side ? — It is on the left-hand side of the jig as you go down.
103. It was shut ? — Yes, it was shut.
104. (Mr. Sawyer.) And you are quite certain that you saw no flame at the time of the explosion ? — Yes, sir.
Examined by Mr. Ellis.
105. When you went into the place that morning, which of you had the lamp ? — Me. There was no one but me went to the top.
106. And did you go further into the place than the candles did to start with ? — Yes, I went to the top.
107. With the lamp ? — Yes.
108. How far behind ? — I went to the waggon prop.
109. Where did you leave the lighted candle ? — About 10 yards in the level.
110. Away from the face of the coal ? — Away from the bottom end.
111. You had the locked safety lamp ? — Yes.
112. What did you do ? — I examined the face all the way up, and went back to the gob.
113. Did you examine into the gob ? — I did not go into the gob myself.
114. Well, there was no gas ? — No.
115. Having examined the far end, where the gas would be if there was any, what did you do ? — I came down.
116. And then you went on with your candle ? — Yes.
117. Is that what you always do ? — Yes, one of us.
118. The first one who goes in examines with the lamp always ? — Yes.
119. And that is the rule in the mine ? — Yes.
120. And you have always done that ? — Yes.
121. After the explosion happened, or at the time that it happened ?
(Coroner.) I understand that he took his lamp all around and returned to his candle because he found it safe.
122. (Mr. Ellis.) And that is the regulation of the mine, and the usual practice ? — Yes.
(Coroner.) It is the usual practice ?
123. (Mr. Ellis.) Yes. (To witness.) Now, at the time of the explosion, which way were you facing ? — Facing north, towards the brow; looking at the face of the coal.
124. And whereabouts did the blast strike ? — In the left cheek.
125. The left cheek and left arm ? — Yes, the left cheek and the left arm.
126. Before the explosion and from the time that you went to work, had you noticed any difference in the air to what it is ordinarily ? — No.
127. Were you working with your shirt on ? — Yes, all of us.
128. Why was that ? — Because it was cool.
129. Why ? — The air is too cold to work there without a shirt.
130. When you tried to get down the level into the jig, to begin with, it was too strong for you ? — Yes.
(Coroner.) You say too cold to work without a shirt, is that on account of the draft ?
131. (Mr. Ellis.) Why is it ? — The air is so cold. We always work with the shirt on.
132. And you worked with your shirt that morning ? — Yes.
133. The first time that you tried to get down the brow, you said the air was too strong for you ? — Yes.
134. Have you any idea how soon it was cool enough to get down ? — I cannot say. It was a minute or two.
135. But it was not very long ? — No.
136. And then the air began to cool ? — Yes.
137. And you got as far as where the level went into the jig ? — Yes.
138. Did you find the boy Haslam in the level ? — Just at the level end of the jig.
139. That is where he would be (pointing to the plan) ? — Yes, he would be waiting at that point to hook on.
140. And you found him there ? — Yes.
(Mr. Ellis, addressing the Coroner.) I think you got it that it was ordered that the place should be examined ?
(The Coroner.) I will take it from the manager, now I have got it from you.
Examined by Mr. Broadbent.
141. How many seams of coal are there in this colliery ? — There are three working.
142. You were in the middle seam ? — It is the middle seam. No, it would be the top seam.
(Mr. Ellis.) This evidence could be got from other people, who would know more about it.
(Mr. Broadbent.) Then I will not trouble this witness.
Examined by Mr. Dickinson.
143. You said, on this morning you did not hear any fall in the roof, nor any sign of weighting ? — No.
144. Had there been previously any fall in the goaf, or any sign of weighting ? — Not that morning.
145. Had there been previously any fall in the goaf or any sign of weighting ? — It had fallen many a time, but not that morning.
146. Falls of roof ? — Yes, what we call the goaf.
147. Had there been any heavy fall — what you call a general weight ? — There has been at different times.
148. Did any gas ever come off with any of these falls ? — I have never seen any.
149. What was the distance between the levels ? — Betwixt the what?
150. What was the distance between the levels? — About 14 yards.
151. In each of these 14 yards what width of pack wall was there ? — We had 4 feet on the outside, and then the others according to the level below the road. The road dirt was put on the lower side. We take the levels 4 yards wide, sometimes a little over, and sometimes a little under, according to the dirt.
152. The levels were 3 yards wide. How much pack wall did you build ? — About 4 feet; sometimes it might be 5.
153. On the lower side or the higher side ? — The lower side.
154. Was that built from the floor to the roof? — Yes.
155. Was it built so tight that it would carry the air along on the level when driven ? — Yes; we left 18 inches on the low side, while there was about 18 inches below the low side rail, so that we had to put pipes and sheet on the other side to keep the air close, and to drive it.
156. For pipes, did you say ? — We both had pipes and sheets.
157. Air-pipes ? — Yes.
158. Would there be anything to support the roof, except this four to five-feet pack wall ? — Yes, there were posts put to put the sheets on.
159. Props ? — Yes.
160. As you drew back the pillar of coal, you did not put in a pack wall underneath, but allowed the roof to fall in ? — We put it at the left level side.
161. What width did you build that ? — Four feet.
162. Was that built from the floor to the roof ? — Yes.
163. Between the high side of that pack wall and the lower side of the pack wall in the level above you, what space was there ? — About 4 feet.
164. No, no ? — Well, we pulled the lower side off, and we built with that stone.
165. From the high side of your pack wall to the lower aide on the No. 7 ? — There was lower side walls against the dirt.
166. From the high side of your upper pack wall, what space would there be near the lower side of the pack wall in No. 7, the level above you ? — Oh, I should think about the thickness of the level.
167. How much would that be without packing ? — Do you mean No. 7, low side pack ?
168. Yes ? — About 10 or 11 yards — it varies.
169. Then besides looking for gas — trying with your lamp when you went in the morning — did you ever work with the safety lamp on account of the gas? — No.
170. Were you at your work the day before the explosion ? — Yes.
171. Did you remember a fireman going around in the afternoon ? — He came around about 11 o’clock in the forenoon.
172. Who was that ? — Joseph Wilde.
173. That was the day before ? — Yes.
174. There was another man there — Davies or Moore ? — He was not in our district.
175. Do you remember Davies being in your district the day before the explosion ? — I do not remember in our place.
176. You do not remember Davies the fireman, the day before the explosion ? — No.
177. (Mr. Ellis.) Would you ask what time he came up the day before ? — It was in the afternoon.
178. (Mr. Dickinson.) What was the fireman’s duty ? — To come around and examine the roads.
179. Davies ? — Yes; he never inquired in our shift. He was there in the afternoon.
180. What was Davies name ? — James Davies.
181. You did not see him there in the afternoon before the explosion ? — I was in the morning shift, and could not.
182. (Mr. Atkinson.) There is one other question. Who worked in the level above you ? — William Cattrall Platt.
183. (Coroner.) Is he killed ? — Yes.
184. Is that William Cattrall ? — Yes.
185. (Mr. Atkinson.) Had you any communication with Cattrall ? — No.
186. After he went into his place ? — No.
187. He never went down to you ? — No.
188. And you heard nothing of them ? — No.
(A Juryman.) He was usually called Cattrall Platt, but his name was Cattrall.
(Coroner.) Is that on the day of the explosion ?
189. (Mr. Atkinson.) Yes. That was on the day of the explosion ? — Yes.
190. (Mr. Ellis.) Will you ask him what time he came up the day before the explosion ? — A little after two o’clock.
191. What time did Davies go around ? — I cannot say, sir.
(The Coroner read to witness the evidence he had given, and put the following question with reference to it.)
192. You had no light. How did you know it was Haslam ? — Because he was at the road end — supposed to be there.
The witness added: I never used the safety lamp except for testing the workings.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.