The Chairman (Mr. J. B. Atkinson) said that they were much obliged to Mr. Cummings for his very clear account of tackling a somewhat difficult problem. Although the method of sinking was German, and tubbing from that country was used, the work had been done by purely British labour. At a meeting held in that room a short while ago, there seemed to be a disposition on the part of some of the members to think that British mining engineers ought to be able to do everything themselves. For his own part, however, he did not see why one should not go to any country for assistance if one had not a better way of doing the work. He noticed that Mr. Cummings had given them the cost, a thing which was very often omitted from papers. This was important, as in many cases it was the factor which decided what method was to be selected. The cost in the present instance seemed to be comparatively small, and it would apparently not have paid to have adopted either freezing or the method that was used at Newbiggin.
Prof. Henry Louis (Armstrong College, Newcastle-upon-Tyne) said that he would like to congratulate Mr. Cummings upon being the first person in this country to adopt the method of sinking described in his paper. He quite agreed with Mr. Atkinson that one ought not to stick to the old-fashioned insular system of thinking that one could do everything and anything better than anybody else; and when other people who had had bigger difficulties to fight, had worked out new methods, he thought that it only showed common sense to take advantage of their experience. The present method was first devised by Mr. J. Riemer, of Dusseldorf, who drew his (Prof. Louis') attention to it some 4 or 5 years ago, when he, at the same time, submitted some of the results of his work. Ever since that time, he (Prof. Louis) had been continually advocating and urging the Riemer method as being the best for getting down through running ground where the difficulties were not exceptionally great. He should imagine that there would be difficulties in using it in the case of a very deep layer of quicksands; but for ordinary conditions of running ground, especially near the surface, he thought with Mr. Cummings that there was no better method. Moreover, Mr. Cummings had broken fresh ground in the method he had used for securing the bottom of his tubbing while grouting. The German method was to cut strips of sheet-iron to a template of the side of the shaft, to bolt these up temporarily against the bottom flange, and then grout against this temporary bottom under considerable pressure, pumping the grouting in instead of just pouring it in. He thought that that method of cutting an iron plate, bolting it up against the bottom flange, and forcing the grouting in, would probably be preferable where considerable difficulties were met with, although undoubtedly more expensive, and perhaps more cumbersome, than the method used in the present case.
Mr. Cummings replying, said that the idea was first got from an article in a text-book by Prof. Louis. The method was there described, and, although they had practically decided to pile the shaft, the idea was abandoned, and the method used adopted instead. An endeavour had been made to get the tubbing in England, but this was found to he impossible, and it had to be obtained from Germany. If it could have been got in England, it was possible that it might have been purchased cheaper; having to go to Germany, they had to pay a higher price for it.
He had been asked whether any trouble was caused by the metal washers in the joints breaking while the bolts were being tightened up. Although the paper stated that "metal" washers were used, he ought to have said that they were made of cast-steel. They were quite able to stand the pressure, and no trouble whatever had been experienced from that cause. So far as he knew, not one of them had been broken.
The Chairman proposed a hearty vote of thanks to Mr. Cummings, which was unanimously adopted.