|
Volume 38 (XXXVIII), 1909-1910, published 1910 The Chairman (Mr. J. B. Atkinson) said that Mr. Elwen's paper was a practical one, and was upon a subject which was of very great interest to everyone at the present time. The Royal Commission on Mines had the subject in hand, but they were, in a way, waiting until they got a report from the coal-owners' committee, who were conducting experiments. In the meantime, Mr. Elwen seemed, to a certain extent, to have solved the problem at his particular colliery. The pit was a shallow one, being only about 400 feet, and the difficulties were not, of course, so great as in a pit 1,800 to 2,400 feet deep. Mr. A. L. Steavenson (Durham) said that Mr. Elwen's method of dealing with dust was an excellent one, and was moreover both scientific and satisfactory. There were other methods of dealing with dust by the use of chloride of sodium and chloride of calcium, for example, which were both strongly recommended. In a paper which he (Mr. Steavenson) was reading recently, it was mentioned that experiments were made in Lancashire where they had 3 inches of dry dust on the road. He thought that any manager who had 3 inches of dry dust on the road should be sentenced to hard labour. Another system, Mr. Harle's, which had already been described in the Transactions,01 aimed at the prevention of the accumulation of dust by spraying water on each tub as it passed out of the in-bye landing, thus preventing any dust from rising as the sets travelled out. A set of fifty or sixty tubs travelling out at 14 or 15 miles an hour caused dust to rise, and this dust was deposited on the timber of the roof and sides. Of the many systems in use, he could not say whether one was better than the other; but he thought that a combination of at least two of them would be very useful, and would, at all events, minimize, if not do away entirely with, the risk of coal-dust explosions. With respect to the sprayer, the other day he (Mr. Steavenson) supplied to one of his managers one which was not unlike that shown by Mr. Elwen. His (Mr. Steavenson's) sprayer, however, had a copper ball fitting into a cup, and, with a strong pressure, the water was forced through and thrown off as spray in a fine mist. He was sure that everyone was always on the alert to prevent explosions, and the more attention that they paid to coal-dust the fewer explosions there would be. Prof. Henry Louis (Armstrong College, Newcastle-upon-Tyne) asked whether the effect of the sprayers was to make the ground sopping wet. He noticed that the writer stated that the effect on the roof and sides has caused no inconvenience, but nothing was said about the floor, which was rather an important point. He should like to know whether the author had experienced any inconvenience with the floors of the roadways, and whether they might take it that in a colliery, less fortunate than Brandon, where there were soft and swelling shales in the bottom, the wetting would be sufficient to cause trouble under such circumstances. He (Prof. Louis) would also like a few particulars as to the crucial statement that "the coal-dust had undergone an advantageous change.'' Did the writer mean that the coal-dust was so sopping wet that it would not rise at all, or that it was sufficiently moist not to be liable to ignite or explode under a different set of conditions Unfortunately, they did not really know the essential point, which was to determine just how damp the dust should be to render it innocuous. Prof. P. Phillips Bedson (Armstrong College, Newcastle-upon-Tyne) said that in a paper already communicated to the Institute by Mr. Henry Widdas and himself,02 it was demonstrated that the coal-dust must be wet so wet that it would not rise in a cloud,03 in order to prevent its inflammation. The dangerous point was reached when it began to rise in a cloud. The Chairman said that he would like to know whether Mr. Elwen had found that the saturation of the air produced any effect on the working capacity of the men. He did not know that it would in a shallow mine like Brandon ; but, in a very deep mine, if the air was fully saturated, he thought that it would lead to considerable diminution in the capacity of the men for work. Mr. Mark Ford (Washington Colliery) said that it would be an advantage if Mr. Elwen would give them the number of sprayers necessary to keep, say, 300 feet of roadway in a damp condition. The velocity of the current also had a very great effect; his (Mr. Ford's) experience was that in a current of 180 feet per minute the spray did not carry more than 12 to 15 yards. Mr. T. Campbell Futers (Whitley Bay) said that it might be an advantage to add also the pressure of water necessary. One could conceive that there might be a colliery where such sprayers would be useful, but where it was impossible to get a sufficient head of water, unless a pump, something like that used by Mr. Harle, were adopted. Mr. Steavenson asked whether Mr. Elwen had any fixed time for clearing the roads, or how many inches of coal-dust was allowed to accumulate. The Chairman said that possibly Mr. Elwen recommended the use of sprayers in conjunction with regular cleaning, and possibly cleaning would be found easier on account of the dust being moistened. Mr. T. L. Elwen, replying, said that the spraying had had no effect on the floor, although it had become very wet indeed. He could quite imagine, if one had a very big pressure and a soft bottom, that trouble would ensue, and this would have to he met in another way. With regard to the coal-dust having undergone an "advantageous change," he meant that the dust was in a damper condition on the top. By blowing it on the sides there was not the same readiness for it to come up in a cloud as there had been before spraying was introduced. Respecting the effect, if any, on the working capacity of the men, he had had no complaints on that score, and he was not aware of any deleterious effect either on their health or their working capacity. If Table I. were consulted, it would be found that at the face of the workings before spraying, where the normal temperature was 60° the humidity was 93 per cent., and that after spraying the humidity was 100 per cent., so that there was not a great change. If the temperature had been high, it would have made a difference. He agreed with Mr. Ford in his remarks respecting a very still current. He had only tried the sprayers on the main roads, and would not attempt to put them in the face or a short distance out-bye where there was a low current of air, as the water would simply drop down and wet the floor. The number of sprayers required was dependent on the velocity of the current of air, and had to be ascertained by experiment. The sprayers were made to suit varying pressures, and they could be made to suit a low pressure. It had been found that formerly, when the sides and top were wetted, if it was a frosty night at the surface the roads were dry next day; whereas now, after a road had been wetted one night, it remained very much longer in that condition than before, on account of the air not having such a drying capacity. The Chairman proposed a vote of thanks to Mr. Elwen for his paper, which was cordially adopted.
01 "Automatic Sprayer for Preventing Accumulations of Dust in Mines," by R. Harle, Trans. Inst. M. E., 1899, vol. xviii., pages 113 and 484. 02 "Experiments Illustrative of the Inflammability of Mixtures of Coal-dust and Air," by P. Phillips Bedson, D.Sc., and Henry Widdas, B.Sc., Trans. Inst. M. E., 1906, vol. xxxii., page 529; and 1907, vol. xxxiv., page 91. 03 Ibid., 1907, vol. xxxiv., page 93.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||