Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

I.M.E. Previous Return to Index Next I.M.E.
/   \

Volume 24 (XXIV), 1902-1903, published 1904

Sinking By The Freezing Method At Washington, County Durham.

By Mark Ford.

1. Introduction. — The great interest shown by the members in the operation at Washington, and the novelty of the method, probably adopted for the first time in Great Britain, has induced the writer to give the following detailed description of sinking through alluvial deposits to the stone-head at the Glebe Winning belonging to the Washington Coal Company, Limited.

The company, having acquired the royalties of the Oxclose and Glebe collieries, abandoned forty years ago, decided to sink two shafts, 14 feet and 12 feet in diameter respectively, in a position such as to secure the most economical arrangement of haulage, shaft-bottom and surface-plant in preference to reopening the old shafts.

2. Nature of Ground. — After trial-borings had been made over a certain area, it was found that the shafts would be sunk through drift, consisting of sand and boulder-clay. At the site adopted for the shafts, the following section was proved :—

No.Description of StrataThickness of StrataDepth from Surface
  Ft.In.Ft.In.
1 Soil  1313
2 Yellow sand dry  346359
3 Grey sand: wet  413770
4 Blue clay  01771
5 Grey sand, with a gravel-bed: damp  24795
6 Clay, with boulders: dry  1211924
7 Loamy clay : dry  52976
8 Stiff clay, with boulders : dry  971071
9 Yellow freestone  1301201

3. Method of Sinking. — The thickness of the sand-bed, the treacherous character of the quicksand, and the possibility of damaging the foundations of engines, boilers and other erections in the vicinity of the shafts, led, after careful consideration, to negotiations with Messrs. Gebhardt & Koenig, Nordhausen, Germany, who undertook to freeze two shafts to the stone-head. This method offered almost a certainty of success, a dry shaft to sink, and no water or sand to pump to the surface.

4. Preparatory Work. — The usual headgear and pulley were erected, and a permanent hauling-engine was so placed that both shafts would be served by it. during the sinking (Fig. 5). This engine has two cylinders, each 18 inches in diameter by 38 inches stroke, and is geared as 2 to 1, to two drums, 6 feet in diameter. A locked-coil wire-rope is used for winding.

The first and winding shaft will have a finished diameter of 14 feet. Its diameter to a depth of 24 feet was 24 feet, the sides being secured by ordinary wooden cribs, 6 inches square, placed 3 feet apart, and short backing deals were placed behind the cribs.

At 16 feet from the surface, a scaffold was erected, and on this scaffold, the holes in which the freezing-tubes, 22 in number, had to be placed, were marked off (Figs. 1 and 2, Plate VII.). This was done by drawing a circle on the scaffold having a radius of 10¼ feet, and the circumference of this circle was divided into 22 equal parts, giving the centre of each bore-hole.

Boring-tubes were forced down to form the holes through the sand. These tubes were 6 inches in diameter and 6 feet long, fitted with screwed flush-joints, the lower length having a sharp end. The sand-pump was occasionally put in, and by turning the tubes with the grips, they gradually sank until the gravel was reached; and then screw-jacks were used to force the tubes into the clay.

When the boring-tubes reached the clay, boring was continued by means of a chisel working inside the tubes, making holes 5¼ inches in diameter (Fig. 6). Ordinary bore-rods were employed, a wooden rocking-lever being used to counterbalance the weight of the rods in the hole. On account of the hardness of the boulders, most of which were whin or dark blue Mountain Limestone, of large size, with ice-worn smooth sides, exceptional difficulty was experienced in boring through this clay, progress was extremely slow, and the holes were constantly liable to deflection from the vertical by reason of the impact of the boring-rods upon the edge of these boulders, which no doubt often moved in their bed of soft clay. It was imperative that the tubes should be vertical, in order to secure an ice-wall of sufficient thickness and of uniform frozen condition. The vertical direction of the holes was tested by suspending a plummet from the surface at a point immediately above the centre of the top of the boring-tube. If during its descent the plummet came in contact with the side of the hole a deviation of the cord was seen at the top of the tube. But in no case was the deviation of any of the tubes found to be more than a few inches.

As soon as a hole had attained the intended depth, the freezing-tubes were inserted. These tubes are 4 inches in outside diameter and 16 feet long, the lowest length having a closed end. The joints consist of a sleeve, 6 inches long, screwed inside to receive the screwed ends of the tubes. As the tubes were being placed in the holes they were tested by hydraulic pressure :— 15 atmospheres for the first pipe, 14 atmospheres after a pipe had been added, and so on, reducing the pressure by one atmosphere for every pipe that was added. As soon as the freezing-tubes were inserted, the boring-tubes were removed and used for other holes, so that six sets of boring-tubes were used in putting down 22 holes.

5. Refrigerating-plant. — The entire plant (Fig. 7) was provided by Messrs. Gebhardt & Koenig and brought from Germany. The motive power was steam, and was provided by the colliery-owners from two Lancashire boilers working at a pressure of 75 pounds per square inch. The steam-engine, A (Fig. 4, Plate VII.), had an horizontal cylinder, 18 inches in diameter by 20 inches stroke, fitted with ordinary slide and adjustable expansion-valves, and was run at a speed of 90 revolutions per minute. A flywheel, B, 16 feet in diameter, on the crank-shaft was fitted with a belt to drive shafting, C. On this shafting, two pulleys, D and E, were placed, and by means of belts they drove two flywheels, F and G, which gave motion to the cranks of two horizontal compressors, H and I (Fig. 4, Plate VII.). The compressors are double-acting and fitted with conical valves kept in place by springs.

The refrigerating agent, ammonia, is raised by the compressors to a pressure of 150 pounds per square inch. And for this purpose it is absolutely necessary that the gland in which the piston-rod works shall be efficiently packed, or ammonia will escape the packing consisted of alternate rings of white-metal, gutta-percha and chalked-hemp, with a total length of 15 inches. Provision has also to be made for the continuous injection of oil into the gland, and this was effected by a small pump driven by belting from the main shaft. The oil passes into the cylinder, and, in addition to lubricating, tends to fill up the clearance-space of the cylinders. The ammonia-, under pressure, is delivered into a small receiver, where the oil is separated and periodically drained into a lower receiver, whence it is used again. When the oil is mixed with the ammonia under pressure, it loses part of its heat and on being drained into the lower receiver at a pressure of 15 pounds per inch it has a tendency to freeze, and this is prevented by passing a steam-pipe, ½ inch in diameter, through the oil.

The ammonia leaves the receiver for the condensers, through a pipe, 3 inches in diameter, and thence passes into four tubes, each 1 inch in diameter.

The condensers, J and K (Fig. 4, Plate VII.), are vertical iron cylinders. 10 feet high and 5½ feet in diameter. These condensers contain, in tiers of four rings, 1,600 feet of tubing, 1 inch in diameter, through which the ammonia is circulated. About 4,000 gallons of water per hour circulate through the condensers, and the water is kept in constant motion by means of paddles, ab and cd, driven by belting from the engine flywheel. This water cools the ammonia, reducing it from a gas to a liquid, and the latent heat of liquefaction evolved in the process raises the temperature of this large quantity of water by about 10° Cent. The temperatures of the water on entering and leaving the condensers are recorded in Fig. 8.

When the four pipes emerge from each condenser, they are immediately connected to a pipe, 1 inch in diameter, leading to the refrigerators. The refrigerators, three in number, L, M and are vertical iron cylinders 10 feet high and 7 feet in diameter (Fig. 4, Plate VII.). They are jacketed with 3 inches of peat moss and encased with wooden cleading. They are filled with brine, and contain 2,000 feet of tubing, 1 inch in diameter, through which the ammonia circulates after passing through reducing valves, which has the effect of lowering the pressure from 150 pounds to about 15 pounds per square inch. The ammonia immediately changes its state from a liquid to a gas; and this can only be done by absorption of heat corresponding to the latent heat of vaporization. This heat is taken from the surrounding bath of brine, which is thereby greatly reduced in temperature. Efficient and uniform reduction of the temperature of the brine is obtained by rotating a paddle in each refrigerator, similar to that in the condensers.

The ammonia leaves the refrigerators, passing direct to the suction-side of the compressors, and it keeps constantly passing through the act ions already described.

A duplex pump, O, with rams 6 inches in diameter and steam-cylinders 8 inches in diameter by 6 inches stroke, is used to circulate the brine through the tubes in the bore-holes, and back to the refrigerators. This pump makes 60 strokes per minute, and produces a flow of 144 gallons per minute.

On a scaffold, 8 feet above the bottom of the pit, there were placed two rings of pipes (Fig. 9). One ring was connected to the delivery-end of the duplex pump while the return-pipe was connected to the refrigerators. The return-ring also, had separate connections to all the freezing-tubes; and the inlet-ring, conveying the brine, was fitted with tubes, 1 inch in diameter, branching off to every bore-hole. These small tubes entered, through a gland, into the freezing-tubes in the boreholes, and reached to the bottom. The brine flows down the smaller tube and is discharged through perforations near the bottom of the tube, returning up the outer tube to the return ring, and thence to the refrigerators. The connections from the rings to each hole, were fitted with cocks so that the supply and return side could be closed at will. The pipes, after the freezing commenced, were soon coated with ice ; and, to ascertain that each pipe was receiving its proper supply of brine, a few square inches of ice was cleared every morning, and the rapid formation of ice on the exposed part was proof of satisfactory working. Fig. 8 records, for each day, the average temperatures of the brine as it left the refrigerators and as it returned from the shaft. As a rule, the temperature was increased about 2° Cent.

The brine, which is used to freeze the quicksand, circulates in tubes sunk at intervals in the sand, and has its temperature lowered below that of the freezing-point of water, being robbed of its heat in the refrigerators, previous to circulation by the pump, owing to the vaporization of the ammonia on its way to the suction-side of the compressors.

6. Agents. — The refrigerating agent used was anhydrous ammonia (NH3) and while other agents (carbonic acid, sulphurous acid, etc.), can be used, ammonia is considered to be the most efficient, and certainly the most harmless in case of accidental escape. This substance has a molecular weight of 17, and as a gas had a density in relation to hydrogen of 8.5 and in relation to air of 0.59, and boils at 40° Cent, at atmospheric pressure. It has a latent heat of vaporization of 287 calories, and a vapour-tension of 108 pounds per square inch at a temperature of 16° Cent. Gaseous ammonia can be liquefied at a pressure of 128 pounds per square inch at a temperature of 21° Cent.; and at a pressure of 150 pounds at a temperature of 25° Cent., the pressure required to produce liquefaction rising very rapidly with the temperature. The latent heat of ammonia is very great, consequently its value as a refrigerating agent is proportionately large. It possesses greater heat-absorbing properties than other agents, and it liquefies at a comparatively low pressure. It acts injuriously on copper and brass. It is combustible, and when mixed with twice its volume of air is capable of exploding with great violence. The ammonia was brought from Germany in steel cylinders, 4 feet long by 8 inches in diameter, at a pressure of 300 pounds per square inch.

The brine used consisted of a solution of chloride of magnesium. The salt was dissolved in hot water, the resultant brine consisting at first of 21 per cent, and being gradually raised to 26 per cent, of the salt. The latter solution freezes at a temperature of -34° Cent. It will therefore be seen that it is capable of circulating in tubes at a temperature that would solidify any water in contact with the tubes . A float was used to indicate the height of the. brine in the refrigerators, so that any abnormal leakage would be detected. The quantity of brine was kept constant.

Before commencing the freezing process, the top of the shaft was enclosed, and the exposed pipes were covered with straw-ropes. A hole was bored, and a pipe 18 feet long inserted, in the middle of the shaft, and the height and temperature of the water in the hole was noted as the gradual increase of ice-wall slowly caused the water to rise.

7. Difficulties. — No special difficulties or accidents were experienced. There were a few cases of the packing being blown out of the compressor-glands. A slight shrinkage, owing to the temporary character of the foundations, caused the crank-shaft to heat on several occasions. One of the freezing-tubes split, probably owing to the effect of a shot, the leakage of the brine was seen in the side of the shaft, and the connections to the supply and discharge-rings were immediately closed. The brine was withdrawn, and the pipe thrown out of use.

Owing to a missed-shot, one of the sinkers working in the shaft-bottom struck a gelignite-cartridge with his pick, causing it to explode, and he received injuries that resulted in his death, 4 days later. Eight other workmen were in the shaft-bottom at the time, and all received slight injuries. Two similar accidents, happily, without fatal results, occurred while using the same explosive, at a sinking in Northumberland, three and four days later respectively, so that the accident could not be alleged to be due to special circumstances connected with the freezing system. Probably, the quality or condition of the explosive may have been such that missed-shots were likely to occur.

The large quantity of water used for cooling the ammonia, in the absence of a reservoir, rendered cooling arrangements necessary, and this was accomplished by allowing the water to trickle through perforated boxes.

8. Excavation. — On May 5th, 1902, forty-three days after freezing commenced, the excavation of the frozen ground was commenced. The shaft was sunk 17 feet 10 inches in diameter, and the freezing-tubes extended 16 inches beyond the sides. The comparatively dry sand was found in a hard state near the sides of the shaft, but it readily yielded to the' pick. The 6 feet core in the centre of the shaft was always soft, and in the quicksand the latter was in its natural wet condition. Ordinary cribs and backing-deals were used to secure the sides of the shaft to a depth of 18 feet. In passing through the quicksand, pointed chisels struck by hammers were a valuable aid to the pick, and the working-time occupied in sinking the length of 55 feet through the sand was only 11 days, The wet sand contained 19.6 per cent, of water by weight or 37 per cent, by volume.

On entering the clay, the aspect of affairs altered. Probably owing to the higher conductivity of the clay, the ice-wall was much thicker, and the soft central core was partly frozen, and never more than 2 feet in diameter. The clay was full of stones or boulders, varying in size from a pea to 3 feet in diameter: coal in small pieces, shale, sandstone, Mountain Limestone, red and grey granite, and whin all being represented. Some of the larger limestone-boulders were striated, showing the effect of glacial action. In the clay, recourse was had to blasting, but on account of the brittle condition of the tubes carrying the cold brine, the depth of the shot-holes was restricted to 42 inches in the sump and 30 inches in the canch. A shot was not allowed to be placed within 15 inches of the side of the shaft, and it was sloped at an angle of not less than 20 degrees to the centre of the shaft. The quantity of gelignite was restricted to ¼ pound in each hole. Under these conditions, the comparative inefficiency of the pick, on account of the clay being of a tough leathery nature, and the boulders large and numerous, caused progress to be extremely slow, and the freestone was not reached until June 10th, 1902. In drilling the holes in the clay, brine was used, as water quickly froze and held the drills in the holes. Ordinary wooden cribs, 6 inches square, with backing-deals, were used in securing the dry sand, and for a length of 6 feet in the wet sand iron rings were used to keep the backing-deals in position; but, in neither case, was it necessary to secure the sides, and the remainder of the sinking was finished without supports.

9. Permanent Lining. — As soon as the freestone was reached, water was seen in the bottom of the shaft, and a bed was prepared for a cast-iron ring made in eight segments, 20 inches on the bed, and 2 inches thick. The edge was turned up at the front so as to form a water-ring. Oaken sheathing, 1 inch thick, was placed between the segments, and bolts were passed through the flanges and sheathings.

A solid wall of bricks and cement-mortar was built on the cast-iron crib: the bricks being shaped at the ends so that, although set back 4 inches from the front at the first course, they came gradually into the required size of the pit at a height of 5 feet above the crib. At 18 feet above the crib, the walling was altered to two concentric rings of brickwork, each 9 inches thick, and the intervening cavity, 2 inches wide, was filled with cement. Three stretcher-courses alternated with one header-course. To prevent the cement-mortar from freezing, the mixing water contained 7 per cent. of caustic soda. The soda was dissolved in hot water. The cement-mortar consisted of 1 part of cement to 2½ parts of dry yellow sand taken out of the pit. The sand was not very sharp. The bricks (9 inches by 4½ inches by 3 inches) were obtained from a colliery in the vicinity, made from a seggar or coarse fire-clay, and locally termed "plate-bricks." One side of the brick was curved to suit the circle of the shaft.

10. Extraction of the Tubes. — The removal of the freezing-tubes was commenced, as soon as the walling was completed, above the water-bearing strata. By means of the inner tube, steam was used to thaw the surrounding strata. A pair of hydraulic jacks were used to move the tubes, and they were then drawn out by the sinking-engine. The outside socket-joints increased the labour of removing the tubes, and two weeks expired before the work was finished; and in two cases the bottom length of the tubes was left in the holes, as the screw-thread at the joint had stripped by the force applied. As the tubes were withdrawn, the holes were filled with cement-mortar consisting of 1 part of cement to 3 parts of sand, so as to prevent the sand-feeder from passing through the clay into the freestone.

11. Conclusion. — There can be no doubt as to the reliability and efficiency of sinking by the freezing system through water-bearing strata; and with ordinary care, the possibility of a mishap is very remote. In the present case, the slow progress of the sinking was due to the boulder-clay, and a large amount of time was spent in boring and sinking through it. Opinion varied as to the desirability of freezing the boulder-clay, in the circumstances of the case under discussion; but the contracting firm held that it was absolutely necessary that the boulder-clay should be frozen.

Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print