The Chairman (Mr. J. L. Hedley) said that the members, on their visit to the mines described in the paper, would be interested in seeing what was being done. He (Mr. Hedley) had seen all the pumping-plant, and he knew how much trouble Mr. Davison had taken over the pumps in times past, and be probably looked upon them almost as his own children. He did not know whether pumps had elsewhere worked for a month under water, but it would be interesting to see what the pump was like, if it was still in existence.
Mr. G. Scoular (Whitehaven) said with respect to Mr. Davison's statement about one of the Hathorn-Davey engines stopping when the load in the pit had been lost, he had had a somewhat similar experience, but the engine, in his case, had not behaved quite so well. The differential gear was, no doubt, a very excellent one, but it was altogether too much to expect that it would act in time to prevent disaster in the event, say, of the pump-rods breaking. He had found it necessary to place buffer-beams in the pit strong enough to arrest the weight of the falling-rods, and be would like to know how Mr. Davison had overcome the difficulty. He would also be glad to know if Mr. Davison had found it necessary to place safety or relief-valves upon his clack-boxes. His (Mr. Scoular's) experience had been that spring-loaded relief-valves were a great protection to the castings. When from any cause, such as the pumps drawing upon air, the ram came down with a shock upon the water, the intense pressure which would thus suddenly accumulate is relieved by the instantaneous action of the spring-loaded relief-valve and a probable splitting up of some of the castings averted. Mr. Davison's cost of pumping was very low, and no doubt much of this economy was due to the efficiency of the feedwater-heaters to which he had referred in his paper. He (Mr. Scoular) would like to know if the exhaust-steam passed through the feedwater-heater on its way from the cylinder to the condenser. With respect to the system of pumping, namely, with large steam-engines encumbering the mouth of the shaft and ponderous pumprods conveying the power to the pumps, he would like to hear what some of their electrical engineering members had to say on the subject. A dynamo placed in some convenient situation on the surface, driven by a comparatively small high-speed steam-engine or other available means, a cable conveying the power to the underground motor-driven pumps would seem, in many respects, to be an improvement. There was, however, the almost always threatening danger of drowning the underground pump, and he feared there would be some difficulty in working an electric pump for a month under water, a feat which Mr. Davison had accomplished with the existing type of pump at the Stank mine.
Mr. Cedric Vaughan (Millom) said, with reference to the gearing or grathing of valves, that it was found at Hodbarrow that when the gearing was set on the seat of the valve it did not last so well as when it was set on the crown. The reason for the change was that when the gearing was on the seat it was found when pumping sand-and-water that the gearing was beaten out of shape in from 24 to 36 hours; they noticed that in valves of the butterfly type, with the gearing on the top, the valves lasted a much longer time, and it occurred to him that the gearing in the double-beat valve might be transferred to the crown. Accordingly that was done, and since the change the same valve would pump sand-and-water for a week, whereas previously it would not pump for over 36 hours without being beaten out of shape. He would like to ask whether Mr. Davison found that occur in his case, and whether the gearing on the seat of the valve was punished in the same way. It was the first time he had heard of gearing on both seat and crown, and he would like to know Mr. Davison's experience as to how long the gearing lasted. Leather was used for the gearing.
Mr. H. Ayton (Newcastle-upon-Tyne) said that in pumping with a Cornish engine at Wallsend colliery there had been two breakdowns, caused by the losing of the load, and in both cases the piston was broken. Since then a controlling engine had been erected, but when the load was lost a second time the piston was again damaged. They did not pump so large a quantity of water at Wallsend collieries as that described by Mr. Davison, although the engines were capable of pumping 4,000 gallons per minute. Husband valves were used with four faces, the object being not to allow the valves to rise too far. The four faces were lifted simultaneously, and a sufficient quantity of water was released to run through all the faces. The bottom part of the valve was lined with white metal, which could be run in and turned down at small cost. Even when pumping sand-and-water the valve acted efficiently, but the pumping-engine did not work so economically as he would like.
Mr. G. S. Corlett (Wigan) said that he had erected electric-driven machinery to deal with volumes of about 1,000 gallons per minute, and he was not aware of anything like 4,000 gallons per minute being dealt with electrically at any one installation in this country. He did not think that anyone had yet constructed electric motors of the size that would be required, and which could be satisfactorily operated under water. It was possible to build electric motors to produce from 10 to 50 horsepower, which would run satisfactorily under water ; but he did not think anyone had attempted to build motors of sufficient size which it would be safe to run under water. He hoped to have the opportunity of looking at the pumping-plant in detail, because he did not think that the question of electricity, as applied to such installations, had been very carefully considered by mining engineers, and he was inclined to think that they would be largely guided by what might be termed their previous experience. They knew what a steam-plant could do, but they did not know what an electrical one could, He did not know of any motors which had been running for any length of time under water, but he was at present running an enclosed and hermetically sealed motor — at full load — which had not been opened for a month. It would be quite feasible to run such a motor under water, as water afforded a ready means of dissipitating the heat.
Mr. J. S. Jeans (London) said that Mr. Davison stated that it had been found desirable that all foundations should be made of wrought iron or steel girders. He would like to know how far iron and steel girders had superseded timber in this district for various purposes, and whether there was any general movement for the superseding of timber in the future.
Mr. J. Davison, replying to the discussion, said that he could scarcely account for Mr. Scoular's Hathorn-Davey engine, which did not protect itself from striking the end of the cylinder. The load had been lost at the No. 10 pit by the valves sticking, and no accident had occurred. They used buffers at the end of the slide bars, made of india-rubber and oak-timber, and in addition they inserted strong catch-logs in the shaft (6 feet deep by 2 feet wide of solid oak) and wings on the pump-rods, which in the case of the engine over-going the stroke, took the weight of the pump-rods, but they had never had a blow from that engine. He could not say the same for the No. 11 pit engine, but the accident was attributable to the gear. When they lost the load suddenly the weight was so great that it was almost impossible to prevent the engine from striking the end of the cylinder.
Berryman feed-water heaters were used, and tended materially to reduce their costs. The discharge-water from the condensers was not used in the boiler, as pit-water was used for condensing, and was not fit for boiler use. Town water was used in the boilers.
With reference to the pump working in water, the plans (Figs. 1 and 2, Plate VIII.) showed the pump and also the pump-rods working below. The water was 90 feet above the bottom of the shaft, and the pumps worked for a month at the rate of 8 strokes per minute, under water, until they came to the conclusion that it was of no use to pump any longer : a diver was then sent down to close the door referred to in his paper.
In Fig. 3 (Plate VIII.) it would be noticed that guttapercha was used in the seating and in the crown as well, as experience with the valve had proved that these were the right positions. The valves supplied by Mr. Davey were geared with strips of leather in the crown of the valve, but this arrangement proved that these were unsatisfactory, and having a large quantity of sand in the water it necessitated their constant renewal. Two strips of guttapercha were then placed in the grooves, and between these split copper pegs were driven into the dove-tail cut in the bottom of the groove. The pins held the guttapercha perfectly tight and it never came out. The bottom of the valve required frequent renewal. In refacing, the valve became too low for the seating and a new bottom part was required. To obviate that loss, he cut grooves, and inserted guttapercha in the same manner as at the top, and valves so fitted had been in use for two years and six months, and were still quite good.
He was unfortunately able to say that they had had serious breakdowns of the Cornish engines, as described by Mr. Ayton, by losing the load at the lift. All the gearing of the No. 2 Cornish pumping-engine had been broken not long ago from the same cause. He had not had any experience of four-faced valves, but with two-faced valves the lift did not exceed 2¼ inches.
At the No. 10 pit, oak-timber foundations were used with a span of 6 feet. There was a brick pillar under the bottom valve, and when the engine was making a forcing lift, these timbers yielded, and the joint gave way at the point x (Fig. 1, Plate VIII.). Of course in condemning the use of timber-beams he only referred to their use in connexion with permanent heavy pumping. In erecting a new pumping-plant he was compelled to use iron girders or steel beams, so as to avoid risk of breakage of joints and pipes.
Mr. H. Ayton sympathized with Mr. Davison in regard to the fractures of the joint indicated. It had been remade on several occasions at the Wallsend collieries. On one occasion, the whole column of pumps had to be raised, so as to allow them to remake that joint. He recommended the use of iron girders made of ship iron of the coarsest obtainable quality, in order that acid mine-water could exert the least possible effect on the girder. The girders used at Wallsend colliery were 5 feet deep and 40 inches wide at the top, and upon them the ramcase was placed, but the greatest difficulty had occurred from the springing of the girders, as Mr. Davison had explained, and the resulting fracture of the H joint.
Mr. J. Davison said that he had considerable experience in pumping sand-and-water. Within three weeks of starting the No. 10 pump and the Hathorn-Davey engine, they came across running-sand, and for a week the engine was pumping sand-and-water.
Mr. Cedric Vaughan asked Mr. Davison whether he had pumped sand-and-water since he used gearing both at the seat and crown of the valve.
Mr. J. Davison said that they had pumped sand-and-water, but not in so great a volume.
Mr. Cedric Vaughan said that the effect of pumping sand-and-water with the gearing on the bottom of the valve was very severe.
Mr. J. Davison said that he used guttapercha and found that the sand became bedded in it, making it almost as hard as iron, and it lasted a very long time.
The Chairman proposed a vote of thanks to Mr. Davison for his valuable paper, and the resolution was cordially adopted.