|
Volume 35 (XXXV), 1885-1886, published 1886 The President said the paper would be open for discussion at a future meeting, but any gentleman who wished to speak upon it now could do so. Mr. Lawrence said the only thing which struck him as being novel, and whereby a great saving had been effected, was the fact of the pipes being covered with felt and lead He would be very glad if Mr Merivale would give a more detailed description of how the covering was done what thickness of lead put on, and any other particulars as to the covering of the pipes. Of course, it would be out of place for him to enter into any argument as to the logic of taking steam so far into a mine. The mining engineer, as a rule, would not let him do it. He would like to know from Mr. Merivale how he takes away the exhaust steam from the 12-inch engine? He could readily understand what Mr Merivale said about the in-bye pump, but he did not tell them what he did with the steam from the 12-inch pipe a long way in-bye. His (Mr Lawrence’s) experience of turning the steam into the "return" was that it brought down a large quantity of stone, and people would not let him do it. No doubt the crooked ways at Broomhill Colliery would prevent Professor Merivale economically working there with rope; although it seemed to his (Mr. Lawrence’s) mind that a rope could be taken a long way in. This seemed to him a long distance to carry steam for so little work. He would also like to know whether the 12-inch hauling engine had a tail or endless rope; and whether, if the rope went anywhere near the place in-bye for haulage, the pumping could not have been done by the rope, instead of carrying steam in that distance? He was rather surprised to find Forster’s pipes efficient for the long suction, seeing there was a vertical height of, he thought, 14 feet. Could there not have been a less steam pipe than 5 inches carried such a long distance ? They all knew that the larger the pipe the larger the condensation which took place. With regard to the loss of water being caused by priming, he thought if they took into consideration the surface, and the distance the steam was carried, it would be found that the condensation would give that quantity of water without any priming. Professor Herschel said that in the paper the diminution of pressure at the end of the steam pipe was observed, he thought, while the engines were running. He would like to know whether there was any sign of loss of pressure when the engines were not working at that long distance from the boiler? Professor Merivale said that with regard to Mr. Lawrence’s general statement, that it was objectionable to carry steam in-bye to do work which could be more cheaply done by ropes. Mr. Lawrence remarked that he did not say "cheaply;" he left out the word "cheaply." Professor Merivale said, assuming Mr. Lawrence had used the word "cheaply," he would agree with him. He thought it was objectionable to take steam in-bye for many reasons. But this was a special case there was already steam a considerable distance in-bye — put in before their time ; and, having the surplus steam, it was thought it would be cheaper to carry the steam in a still greater distance. When they were pumping originally with horses, the cost was 6½d. per ton, and with the present arrangement it was a little over ½d. a ton. They were well satisfied that if they pumped with ropes, as they were doing on a very large scale in another part of the mine, they would do it more cheaply still ; but, considering the circumstances, he thought they were wise in utilizing the steam. As to the exhaust, he did not think there was any difficulty in killing the exhaust by turning it into the suction pipes, so long as there was sufficient water. At Netherton, there was a larger pumping engine — a pair of cylinders 14 inches diameter, and the exhaust was turned direct into the return when he went there originally, with the result which Mr Lawrence had stated, that it did a great deal of damage. The exhaust was afterwards turned into the suction pipes, and no difficulty was found. The steam from the 12-inch engine was turned into the standage, which does not get unmanageably hot. As to covering the pipes it was only in the shaft, which was rather wet, that felt and lead were used. The felt was wrapped round the pipes, and then there was a covering of sheet lead, about 1/64 th of an inch in thickness, fastened on with copper wire. The hauling engine was a single main rope engine, and there would have had to be a second rope if they had wanted to pump with it. As to Forster’s pipes, in another district they were used as sucking pipes, 186 yards long, 7 inches diameter, with a vertical height of 21 feet. At that distance the pump got a little petted at first. The 5-inch pipe was too big at Broomhill, but it was already there. The 2½-inch pipe even was too large ; but they had thought it best to err on the safe side, as it was an experiment taking steam in so far. As to Professor Herschel’s question relative to the pressure, he said that the pressure stated in the paper was observed when the engines were running. No observations had been made when the engines were standing, although it would be useful to do so. Mr. Lawrence asked Professor Herschel whether he would not expect the pressure would rise to very nearly boiler pressure when the engines were standing? Professor Herschel supposed there would be a little loss. Professor Merivale promised to make the observation. Mr. Lawrence had said that the larger the pipes the greater the condensation. He (Professor Merivale) was not quite sure whether that would really be so or not. There would be a greater surface, but there was a larger body of steam inside. He would ask Professor Herschel whether, with larger pipes, there would be greater condensation ? Professor Herschel said that there would be so; and also an increase of friction on the surface. But the larger area of section would diminish the friction in a greater proportion at the same time. Mr. G. R. Pearson said he had carried steam 1,390 yards, 440 yards in 4-inch and 990 yards in 2-inch wrought iron pipes, with a loss of 5lbs. When the engine was pumping at its ordinary speed the pipes were covered with a non-conducting cement. Mr. Steavenson said that this was one of those excellent papers which he often encouraged young men to write. He would like, if possible, to have the inquiry carried further, and compare the work done with the coal used. Whether the use of steam underground was desirable, or what other power was they could not decide at present The question must in a great measure be ruled by the various circumstances of each case. They had not merely the "three courses" open to them, they had twice that number — steam, water under high pressure, ropes, compressed air, gas, and electricity, and whether there were any more, he would not stop to inquire at present. He must say that, after his experience, he had a very strong prejudice against the use of steam underground, not on account of the loss of condensation, but because of the injury it did to the roads and timbering; it brought everything about their ears. He endeavoured, if possible, to have the engine on the surface, and carry ropes down. The very first book he took off the shelves this morning, the Revue Universelle, for 1884, contained comparisons between the motive powers he had enumerated, and many more. Of electricity he had had no experience. He had no doubt that under some circumstances electricity might be very good, but it incurred a certain amount of danger ; there was the chance of sparks underground, or a man touching a wire not sufficiently protected, and being killed. There was more chance of the machinery going wrong than there was with compressed air, water, or ropes. He was inclined to think that, under all circumstances, the two latter were the best. It would not be a bad idea for the Council to appoint a committee of the Institute to examine a few cases, and ascertain for themselves what would be the best to do under general circumstances, and then let every one please himself as to the plan he adopted. Professor Merivale said he had made the calculation which Mr. Steavenson had suggested, and he would rather not mention the result. He had given in the paper such information as would enable any gentleman interested to make the calculation for himself. If they looked at the matter from a purely theoretical view, taking steam in-bye was very extravagant. But it was the special circumstances at Broomhill which induced them to adopt it there. If he were starting from the surface he would not dream of taking steam in-bye for a distance of 700 or 800 yards. Professor Herschel asked whether the consumption of coal at the boilers was entirely to raise steam for the two engines? Professor Merivale: Yes; 38 tons of rough small coal per pay. Mr. Steavenson : In the Revue Uniserselle the cost per horsepower per day for given distances, is reduced to a very small fraction of a franc. The President said they were very much obliged to Mr. Liddell and Professor Merivale for the paper which they had contributed; and the interest it had created must be gratifying to the writers. Probably, at the next meeting, further remarks would be made by other gentlemen. There was no doubt that steam was a very handy power to use, especially, as often was the case, and as in this instance, when it happened to be ready to hand. They were very much inclined only to lengthen their pipes and use steam as in this case. He knew several instances where steam was taken great distances, and there was found no great difficulty or disadvantage, and there was not much extra cost for the supply, as the first cost of supplying steam was not great. Probably, the use of compressed air was one of the most effective and economical means, and gave the least trouble ; but it required a considerable outlay of capital in the first instance. If there was already a boiler on the surface, and pipes down the pit, it cost very little money to take steam inbye for pumping, if they could get quit of the steam. There were in the paper many facts of interest, and the suggestion made by Mr. Steavenson that it should form the nucleus for further consideration was an excellent one; and probably Mr. Steavenson might bring before the Council the question of forming a committee to consider the best means of transmitting power underground, which might lead to some useful result. When Professor Merivale mentioned that the distance in-bye was greater than had hitherto been tried, he (the President) was not quite sure that he was right. About 1,000 yards was a common distance to take steam in, and one gentleman who had spoken, had taken steam further than Professor Merivale mentioned. As to the question of exhausting into the standage, it would be of interest to know how long the engine was working, and whether the standage did not get very heated. There was a certain loss from blowing steam through the water, if the exhaust pipe were put any depth down. He moved a vote of thanks to the writers of the paper. The vote of thanks was agreed to.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||