Mr. Matthias Dunn had been viewer and inspector for fifty years — inspector since 1850. Explained the connection between Burradon and Seghill, sought to be done away with, lest an explosion in the one colliery should extend to the other, as might have happened upon the late occasion. At the time of the separation, improvements had been forced upon Burradon, after which considered the colliery in a satisfactory state. This was in 1858. Described the courses and subdivision of the air in 1858, being in four splits, and consisting of about 24,000 cubic feet per minute. A very limited quantity of goaf then existed, and little or no pillar working — none where the four and a half acre middle goaf is. Increased powers were instituted for a greater quantity. Described changes of the ventilation, occasioned by the working of pillars causing additional doors, crossings, &c. — increasing the quantity of splits from four to nine — without any aggregate increase of ventilation. Particularised the impropriety of Blackwell's doors being then single, although both a separation door and a working door, with coals coming through, the opening and shutting of which was mast likely to affect the constitution of the air currents throughout the districts. It might influence the current of air even at the eastern side of Maddox's bard, causing the unsteadiness spoken of by some of the miners. [Mr. Dunn stated, that as soon as the pit was sufficiently restored to enable a comparison to be made between the amount of air in the chief passages previous to the explosion, as alleged by Johnson during his examination, and that at present existing, he would make a series of experiments in the principal air-courses.]
Mr. Dunn propounded the following scheme of ventilation :—
That the air from the downcast pit passing along the main north rolleyway should be divided before the narrowest part of that passage is arrived at. By this means the construction in the main airway is not allowed to limit the amount of ventilation it now does.
The first split from the main airway is, under the proposed system, to pass directly up the first bank or incline, which is now used as a return (and is guarded by Blackwell's doors), to the far south headways.
Part of this to be carried round by the face of the whole coal workings, and so towards the extreme eastern point (Maddox's bord).
In its course it will receive other currents from the incline and middle east rolleyway; and, lastly, from the straight up east — suppose 10,000 feet per minute to be passed up through Blackwell's doors from the main airway; 14,000 to the top of the incline and to the middle east mothergate, and so on to south headways to join first split. It is assumed that the whole is 30,000 feet, so that, beyond the first split, there will be disposable 20,000 feet; of this, 10,000 to go to the northwest, as at present, and 10,000 up the main incline.
At the top this current to be divided, viz. :— 2000 to be passed up the straight up fiat, through a regulating door, towards Maddox's bord, whilst the remainder would be turned along the south cross-cuts, and up the middle east mothergate, part going up to the whole coal workings, and there joining the south airway — these two divisions passing north towards Maddox's bard and the north return; 4000 being turned through the middle broken goaves.
The doors straight up to be abolished by stoppings, to enlarge the air crossing over the south cross-cut.
By this arrangement, there would be double airways in and double returns out, the leakages being all natural and safe, but the workings in the middle goaf would be stopped. There would be few splits, however, compared with the present system, and a larger quantity of air would reach the far workings and the most dangerous parts of the pit.
William Morgan did not consider the gas in the face of the middle east workings dangerous, if the air had been working regularly. When he went twenty yards down the north return, considered the air was sufficient to drive the gas away.
Mr. George Elliot, viewer, was down Burradon Pit on the 21st of March. Examined the furnace, and the returns passing over it. There was an excellent furnace, and a strong current of air passing over it. There was no evidence of any foulness in the returns. Next measured the quantity of air that was returning from the workings on to the furnace, and from calculation found it was 42,000 cubic feet per minute. Then measured the fresh air on the inbye side of Blackwell's doors, and the quantity was 32,000 cubic feet per minute. Examined the fall in the north return, but did not discover the least presence of gas. The fall seems to have broken itself over the props. The fall was quite calculated to almost entirely close the return up. Then went down to the middle east mothergate, and through the door or regulator to examine the middle broken. There was evidence of great violence, and indications of fire, on the middle east waggonway on the south side. Concluded there was an explosion of limited extent in or near Maddox's board. The concussion had emptied the gas from the middle goaf, or four and a half acre goaf. That gas came in contact with naked lights, about ten pillars up the high end of the east rolleyway. Attributed the first explosion either to a sudden escape of gas from the coal, or, what is more reasonable, from the fall of stone in the back return contracting the air-course, so that it prevented the gas from being carried off. Was of opinion that 4000 cubic feet were sufficient to keep the faces clean. Noticed the fall behind Maddox's bard was "scummed" or sooty, which satisfied him that it took place before the first explosion. Agreed with Mr. Forster, and looked upon that fall as the cause of the explosion. Considered Burradon Colliery below the average for producing gas.
Joseph Dodds, deputy-overman in the far broken, was employed there on the 2nd of March. That part at times was troubled with gas : sometimes gas and sometimes stythe. It was very fair on the morning of the explosion.
Richard Bradley, rolleyman, William Friar, rolleyman, and John Hetherington, pitman, were also examined.
Mr. J. J. Atkinson, Government Inspector: The furnace is nine feet wide, the temperature of the return air being 66 degrees. Measured the return airway at the top of the staple, and found it five feet ten inches by seven feet, or 40 10/12ths square feet in sectional area. Measured the diameter of the staple, which is also a single return for the entire ventilation, and found it to be six feet nine and a half inches, which gives an area of 36.228 square feet. The barometer stood at 30.39 inches of mercury at the bottom of the downcast shaft. The temperature there was 54 degrees. Measured the air in the main intake. By one set of trials the quantity was 20,428 cubic feet per minute by gunpowder smoke passing 100 feet; by another set of trials, at a distance of fifty feet, it was 24,187 cubic feet per minute. By the anemometer, in the same airway, the first trial showed 20,818 cubic feet per minute; second trial, 21,403; third trial, 22,313 cubic feet per minute; the average being 21,511. Measured the air going to the north workings at a point beyond the stables, by means of gunpowder smoke, the average quantity of air indicated being 9,014 cubic feet per minute; in addition, a small quantity of air passed through the stables, which was taken at 1601 cubic feet per minute; making a total of 10,615 cubic feet per minute going to the north district. In the same airway the anemometer indicated 10,157 cubic feet per minute, which, added to 1601 cubic feet going through the stables, makes a total of 11,758 cubic feet per minute.
William Kirkley gave him the dimensions of the regulating doors in the pit., viz. :— (A) Opening in the regulating door in the straight east rolleyway, above the top of the incline, seven inches by thirty-six inches, equal to 252 inches area. The same opening, since the restoration of the door after the explosion had blown it down, thirteen inches by sixteen inches, equal to 208 inches area. (B) The opening in the regulator in the north return, near the twenty-two feet dyke, twelve inches by nine inches, equal 108 inches area. This regulator had not been renewed after the explosion. (C) Opening in the regulator for the middle broken way air, near crossing of south cross-cuts, about fifteen inches by sixteen inches, equal to 240 inches area. (D) Opening in regulator in return from south cross-cuts, twenty-eight inches by twenty-five inches, equal to 700 square inches. (E) Opening at the high end of the middle broken, seventeen inches by eighteen inches, equal to 306 square inches.
On Wednesday, the 28th of March, again went down, in company with Mr. Dunn and others. Learned that the regulator near the twenty-two feet dyke in the north return had not been restored; but Kirkley had it restored without further loss of time. Returned to the lamp cabin, and measured the air in the main intake at the archway on the inbye side of the lamp cabin. The first three trials indicated 22,409 cubic feet per minute; the next two trials indicated 26,610 cubic feet per minute; the average being 24,509½ cubic feet per minute. These measurements, made by the anemometer, gave an average of 26,587 cubic feet per minute. After this, the air going into the northern district workings was measured in the same place as on the 22nd of March; got an average of 10,446 cubic feet per minute; then went up the first east incline, to the regulating door in the first east way, and found the opening for the scale of air to be equal to 228 inches, and the anemometer indicated 1089 cubic feet per minute passing through it.
While the party were near one of the middle broken doors, two persons were despatched to open the outer door in the rolleyway leading to the far bank broken, at a fixed time, and to allow it to remain open for half an hour, when "Mr. Sinclair and myself returned to the anemometer in the north return, near Maddox's board, to witness the effect produced by the opening of the door. We reached the instrument just in time for opening the door, and I do not think the anemometer made one revolution after we reached it, so quickly had the opening of the door operated to produce that effect. About 800 cubic feet per minute of air should, I calculated, have kept the instrument in motion. On blowing my breath at the place, and observing the direction taken by the condensed vapour, I found a slow current established in the contrary direction to the ordinary current, and the north return was thus converted into an intake airway, on which I remarked to Mr. Sinclair, that any gas at the top of the north goaf would probably soon come up to where we were, near Maddox's hoard. On passing through the wall of the edge of Maddox's bard (twenty-five minutes after opening the door), I tried my lamp, and the gas, which had reached the place, exploded in my lamp. I again exploded the gas in my lamp. Mr. Morgan also exploded his twice or thrice at the same place."
John Thompson had been two years in the pit. Worked in the first east bank. Went in at four in the morning of accident, and thought he had seen the air worse. Noticed it get worse about an hour afterwards.
Such is an abstract of the principal facts and circumstances connected with this explosion. It will be observed that various opinions of its immediate cause are assigned.
1. It is ascribed to a fall in the return which obstructed or entirely stopped the ventilation.
2. To the first east door being open.
3. To a slackness in the ventilation, attributed to Thirlwell's door being open.
4. To the contiguity of foul goaves, and, at the same time, a slackness in the ventilation.
5. To a sudden and unmanageable issue of gas.
This statement having been drawn officially for the Institute, by one of its officers, it will be for the Society itself to deal with the subject as may be decided upon.