|
Extracted from "Reports on the Gases and Explosions in Collieries" by Sir Henry T. De La Beche, Dr. Lyon Playfair, and Mr. Warrington Smyth. Report to Parliament published in 1847. Dr. Lyon Playfair To The Chief Commissioner Of Her Majesty's Woods. London Museum of Economic Geology, September 30, 1845. My Lord, According to the instructions contained in Lord Lincoln's letter of the 26th August, 1845, in which Sir Henry De la Beche and myself were directed to proceed to Jarrow, and examine into the nature of the accident which had occurred at that pit on the 25th of August, I immediately visited that place. Sir Henry De la Beche was at that time engaged in important public duties in Ireland, and could not join me, and I therefore availed myself of the services of Mr. Williams, one of the geologists attached to the Geological Survey of Great Britain, and since appointed to investigate the coal resources of India. On my arrival at Jarrow every attention was shown to the wishes of Her Majesty's Government by Mr. Brown, the proprietor, and Mr. Jobling, the chief viewer of the pit, both of whom offered all the requisite facilities for ascertaining the conditions under which the unfortunate accident occurred. The ventilation of the pit had been interrupted by the accident, and so much inflammable gas had in consequence accumulated that it was considered too dangerous to hazard an examination, and we were therefore requested to delay our descent for a few days. During this time I used every endeavour to acquire knowledge of the precise condition of the pit prior to the explosion. Two sets, locally termed "shifts," of colliers are employed in the pit, the first descending at one o'clock a.m., and ascending at nine, at which time the second set go down to keep the works in continual operation. As the explosion took place at 1 p.m., it was easy to ascertain the state of the workings during the time the first set were in the low main, for unfortunately their condition immediately before the explosion could not be determined, there being no survivor save one, and he weakened in intellect by the catastrophe. There are two seams of coal worked in the Jarrow Pit, and it was in the lowest these, termed the Low Main, that the accident occurred. A few deaths from the mixture of irrespirable gases, known by the name of "after-damp," occurred in the upper or Bensham seam, which is, however, twenty fathoms above the former. All the witnesses who had worked in the low main four or five hours before the explosion testified to its safe state when they left work. No obstruction to ventilation had occurred, the air was present in abundant quantity, and neither blowers nor an unusual escape of gas from the pores of the coal had been observed. (See the Evidence attached to this Report.) The deputy overman had gone through all the workings, and found them free from gas and in good order ; and the master wasteman had examined the wastes, and they had shown no unusual signs of foulness, and he had reported to the overman that the pit was in a satisfactory state. The hewers even complained that the brattices, which determine the circulation of air up to the face of the coal, were, if possible, put too well up, causing such a strong current of air as to produce the "swealing" (wasting) of their candles, thus forcing them to burn an unusual number. Most of these witnesses had lost sons or brothers by the explosion, but all of them stated that, as far as the state of the pit was concerned, they knew nothing which could have occasioned the accident, and that they acquitted the master from any imputation of carelessness or blame. They stated objections to the pit, to which I shall afterwards allude, but these did not refer to any immediate or proximate cause of the accident under consideration. Having thus satisfied myself by the testimony of witnesses that the state of the pit four hours prior to the accident was such as not to have led to the apprehension of any danger, the next point of inquiry was as to the geological character of the strata in which the pit is sunk. Unfortunately no records of the strata passed through during the sinking of the pit have been preserved. The shaft was sunk in the year 1801, and the measures have the same geological position as at the Manor Wallsend, the Hebburn, and Wallsend Collieries. The three principal beds worked in the district are the High Main, Bensham, and Low Main seams. The uppermost, or high main, has been worked out, and the Bensham has also been worked to a considerable extent, equal probably to 600 acres, one-sixth of which is in a state of goafs. To render the geological position more intelligible Mr. Williams has run a section from west to east of the three seams alluded to, and has also appended to the plan of the colliery a section of the strata in the vicinity of Jarrow. Having made these preliminary inquiries, we were ready to examine the underground workings. On the 9th of September, or fifteen days after the accident, Mr. Jobling, the viewer, reported to us, that the low main was so far cleared of gas as to render our descent practicable. We first descended, by means of a cage, to the Bensham seam, a depth of 175 fathoms from the surface. Here we found that, with the exception of a few hundred yards in the immediate vicinity of the shaft, the whole of the workings, extending to about 600 acres, were entirely filled with inflammable gas. In the passages in the vicinity of the shaft, and free from inflammable gas, the distinct odour of after-damp was perceptible, and it was here that four men and a boy lost their lives from this cause ; and there is little doubt that, had it not been for the very prompt and manly exertions of Mr. Jobling, the head viewer, the loss of life would have been considerably greater, thirty-six men and boys having been rescued from the seam. From the Bensham seam we descended to the low main, a depth of 120 feet, by means of a loop at the end of a rope, the brattices being so much broken as to prevent the usual mode of descent by a cage. On landing in the low main we found the wreck very considerable, the passage leading to the stone-drift and the bottom of the shaft being entirely filled with broken brattices, parts of waggons, fragments of shale and sand stone, which were blown from the adjacent roof with considerable force. The roof all along the main north headways was much blackened by the explosion, and the large pillars of coal extending from the shaft to the branch up the westway end were coked to about half an inch deep. The force of the explosion must have here reached its maximum, and I cannot conceive such an extraordinary result without supposing that the flame raged in this place with all the force of a blowpipe flame. The large surface of coal thus coked must have yielded a quantity of inflammable gas far from inconsiderable. On turning up to the left towards the west flat the current of fire took the direction of east to west, but, on coming up to the face of the working in the solid coal, it changed and was forced to travel from west to east. This we found to be the case in nearly all the boards in the west flat, Mothergate. The wooden props, several of which are still standing, were burnt on the inside only, and this indication seems to show that the western boards or stalls exploded simultaneously. Along the north headway flanking these boards the current of fire passed from south to north, but, on turning down eastward, opposite the ninth board in the north flat, the currents appeared to have come in several directions from the wastes and other parts, and seem to have converged at this place. At this part a boy was found nearly doubled up, with his face downwards. Both he and his horse must have met instant death from the force of the contending currents. The force of the explosion was by no means the greatest in the western stalls ; on the contrary, it increased in force according to the distance. In the boards flanking the east and west sides of the main north headway, the stoppings, consisting of stone walls six feet thick, were blown down, and along with them a considerable portion of the solid roof; this was also the case in various other parts of the mine for many yards in extent. It is difficult to conceive that these effects were produced by one explosion arising in a single board or stall. Mr. Jobling conceives that the fire arose from the face of the coal in the western district, in which he heard the sound of a blower on two occasions in which he descended the mine subsequent to the explosion. But there were certainly two separate explosions in the pit, as indicated by the manner in which the fire had acted upon the western district, showing that it had attacked it in two opposite directions. Cranstoun, the only survivor in the low main, also gives direct testimony to these two explosions, stating that the second one did not occur until a few minutes after the first. He escaped both the explosions, but his companions were killed by the second whilst attempting to reach the shaft. John Hall, who was working in the Bensham seam at the time of the explosion, states that he heard two separate concussions. Nothing that we saw in our examination supported the opinion that the effects produced were wholly owing to the emission of gas from one blower. Still we agree with Mr. Jobling that the fire originated somewhere in the western district, but unfortunately the foul state of the pit in that quarter prevented us examining it in detail, the gas being in such large quantity as to burn inside our Davy lamps. After the first explosion in the western district, it seems probable that the current of air was reversed, and in consequence of this, aided perhaps by the blowing down of some of the air stoppings, the explosive gas accumulated and produced the second explosion, which was so dreadful in its effects. The force of this was prodigious when it is considered that not only were the stoppings and roof alluded to above blown down, but the strong brattices dividing the shaft from the low main to the Bensham seam were seriously injured. The ventilation of the pit was produced by a jet of water thrown down the east shaft or division during the time we were engaged in our examination, so that we could not judge of its capabilities under the usual system of ventilating by a heated column of air. The current of air produced by the jet of water was not powerful enough to dislodge the fire-damp, the southern boards of the western district, the extreme north, and the whole of the eastern district being so full of explosive gas as to prevent our entrance. We were therefore obliged, after spending several hours in this dangerous atmosphere, to desist from further examination. The state of a pit after an explosion such as that under consideration can scarcely be conceived by those who have not viewed such scenes. The ventilation is arrested, the air-courses and passages stopped with fallen roofs, stones, broken waggons, and brattices, to such an extent that we had frequently to creep over the obstructions on our hands and knees. The props having been blown down, the roof was in a dangerous condition and frequently tumbling, so that we had to pass with much caution lest the vibration should detach the loosened masses. It was impossible in such a state of the pit to make any experiments as to its capabilities of ventilation. The Jarrow Colliery has but one shaft, 14 feet diameter, the area of which is unequally divided into three parts (see Plan), the smaller or southern division being used for pumping water, this and the eastern division both being employed as downcast shafts for air ; the area of both, after making a fair deduction for pumps and brattices, may be about 77 square feet. Supposing that the air descended at the rate of 9 feet per second (a velocity rarely exceeded in mines), 77 x 9 x 60 = 41,580 cubic feet of air per minute would descend these divisions for ventilation. The air is divided at the Bensham seam, part entering there, but the larger portion going to the low main. The air, after having travelled through the western district, enters a long range of passages on the eastern side of the main north headways, and, passing into the stone-drift, ascends a small shaft to the Bensham seam, where it meets part of the air of that seam, and aids in the ventilation of some of its passages ; it afterwards ascends the oval pit to the high-main seam, and then enters the upcast shaft. Mr. Jobling, the head viewer of the pit, had found that 40,000 cubic feet of air entered the low main prior to any operation. The experiment by which this was determined was only an approximative one, and consists in carrying a candle at the same rate as the air-current for one minute, and then measuring the number of yards passed. The person holding the candle judges of the velocity of the current by observing the name, which is carried forwards if he walks slower than the current, and backwards if carried at a faster rate, remaining horizontal when the rate of walking is the same as the velocity of the air. The distance travelled in a minute, multiplied by the area of the air-passages, gives a rough approximation to the quantity of air passing. Supposing, however, that this amount of 40,000 cubic feet per minute did enter the low main, I received the testimony of various intelligent viewers that this quantity was sufficient for all the work performed in so limited a space as the low main at Jarrow. The low main is not reputed to be a very fiery seam, and yet the quantity of gas issuing from it is very considerable. Notwithstanding the constant efforts of the viewer to ventilate by means of a jet of water, the gas in this seam was only very partially removed when we descended, and, in the short time which elapsed between the explosion and our visit, had sufficed to fill 600 acres of the Bensham seam with fire-damp. In some parts of the low main we heard the gas issue from every pore of the coal, the noise being similar to that of a considerable shower of rain. With a coal containing so much inflammable gas, the use of naked candles was far from advisable. In the seam above, the Bensham seam, Davy lamps are generally used ; not so in the low main. There can be little doubt that the Davy would have given such increased safety, supposing the opinion true that the blower suddenly appeared in the western district, as to have given a timely warning to the workers employed in other parts of the pit and enabled them to escape. Another point which cannot be approved of in workings so large as those of the Jarrow pit is that there is only one shaft. In the case under consideration, had the explosion only destroyed by its force those in the immediate vicinity of the place where it is supposed to have originated, still every workman in that seam must have been destroyed from the after-damp and interruption of ventilation caused by the breaking of the dividing brattices in the shaft. As it happened, the explosion was so awful as to destroy every one engaged in the workings, except Cranstoun, whose vicinity to the oval pit kept him alive. The police arrangements of the pit are not complete, but in this, as in the other points mentioned, there is no exclusive blame to be attached to Jarrow, the evils being general in the district in which it is situated. The overman or his deputy inspects the workings previous to the entrance of the men, for the purpose of ascertaining whether they are free from gas and in a safe state. In the performance of this duty he takes a candle or lamp with him, putting out the candle "when he thinks he is coming to a foul place." — (See Evidence of Emmanuel Defty.) — The duty of the overman is a very responsible one, as upon his carefulness or knowledge depend the lives of the workmen employed. The master wasteman has nearly as important duties to perform, having to examine the wastes, the stoppings, and the return passages, and to remedy any defects or obstruction to ventilation which may have occurred by the falling in of the roof. It would be supposed that these men, intrusted with duties so responsible, would be, to a certain extent, educated, and understand somewhat of the principles which they have to apply in practice. Emmanuel Defty, the deputy overman, is asked,— Have you as deputy overman the important duty of looking after the safety of the men, of examining dangerous places, and of reporting as to their safety, and generally, as you state, of "keeping things right"? — Yes, these are the duties of the deputy. Can you write your name? — No, I cannot write. Can you read? — No, I cannot read ; my brother, who was overman and was killed, could do both. In like manner, Robert Fairley, the master wasteman, is asked, — What are your duties as master wasteman? — I have four men under me, who act under my directions, and my duties are to examine the wastes, the passages, and the returns, to see that all is right, or, if any stones have fallen to obstruct the passages, to have them removed. Do these duties require a general knowledge of the principles of ventilation? — Yes, and I used to be considered a first-rate ventilator. Did you ever read any book upon the qualities of air or ventilation? — No, never. Can you read at all? — I can spell the Scriptures, but cannot read easily; hard words soon stop me. Can you write? — I can manage to write my name, but almost nothing else. The men engaged in the pit objected strongly to the swing doors in the passages. These doors are apt to be knocked off their centres by the tubs striking against them, and the ventilation is deranged until they are again put up. The workmen prefer doors watched by trappers, but in this preference they are perhaps guided by the desire to have the junior members of their families employed. The alleged objection to trappers is that they are apt to sleep and leave the doors unattended ; but, as the colliers truly observe, "it is easier to wake a sleeping boy than to do carpenters' work and put right a fallen door." In conclusion of this Report I have to sum up as follows :— 1. That the testimony of those at work in the pit four hours previous to the explosion shows it to have been free from fire-damp and well ventilated. 2. That the indications of the current of fire seem to prove that it originated in the western district, and that this, added to the direct observation of the head viewer, who heard the sound of a blower in that district after the explosion, renders it highly probable that the accident originated in the spot marked A on the plan ; that this first explosion was followed by one of greater force, probably produced by the reversal of the air-current and blowing down of the air-stoppings, by which the pit became more generally fouled ; but that the immediate cause of the accident cannot be ascertained. 3. That, both in the western district, where the fire originated, and in all other parts of the low main, naked candles, instead of Davy lamps, were used. 4. That the existence of only one shaft, and the destruction of its brattices, and consequent interruption of ventilation, would have caused the death of any persons who survived the explosion, which, however, seems to have been of so violent a nature as to have caused immediate death to all; and, therefore, that the hazard of such accidents is much increased in pits where only one shaft is in existence. 5. That the men under the viewer, intrusted with the care and ventilation of the mine, are ignorant and uneducated. I draw the attention of your Lordship to this summary of results, more with a view to a general consideration of the present want of legislative provisions with regard to mines, than with reference to the specific case under examination ; for the uniform testimony of the workmen employed, my own personal examination of this and of other pits in the Durham district, lead me to believe that the usual recognised precautions were adopted and strictly adhered to in this pit, and, therefore, in the present state of the law, I entirely concur in the verdict of the Coroner's jury, on the inquisition held on the bodies of the deceased, "that the explosion was accidental, and was not due to any carelessness on the part of the owner or viewer." But, at the same time, I have to express the conviction that the accident would, in all probability, not have occurred, had Davy lamps been employed instead of candles, the fiery character* of the pit having pointed out their use to be necessary, as well in the low main as in the Bensham seam. My Lord, I have the honour to be Your obedient and faithful servant, Lyon Playfair. To the Chief Commissioner of Her Majesty's Woods.
* This is the sixth explosion which has occurred since the sinking of the pit. At the first explosion, in 1817, six lives were lost ; at the second, in 1820, two ; at the third, in 1826, forty-two ; at the fourth, in 1828, eight ; at the fifth, in 1830, forty-two ; and in the accident now under consideration, forty : making in all 140 deaths in 28 years.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||