13th February 1981
Mr. Foot Seeks Action on Coal Mine Closures
There was no doubt that to reflate on top of the present level of inflation would result in still higher inflation and unemployment, Mrs. Margaret Thatcher, the Prime Minister, insisted during question time exchanges.
Mr. Michael Meacher (Oldham, West, Lab) had asked : Why does the Prime Minister keep on refusing to reflate on the grounds that it always leads to worse inflation when all previous reflation, except the disastrous Barber one, have not led to a
surge of inflation or higher unemployment ?
What this country desperately needs is not an ever-greater squeeze on credit, leading to ever-increasing unemployment, but an expansion of credit, provided it is channelled into investment, public as well as private, which would reduce unemployment
without bringing inflation.
Mrs. Thatcher (Barnet, Finchley, C) : To reflate on top of the present level of inflation would lead to higher inflation and unemployment. There is no doubt about it.
Mr. David Steel, Leader of the Liberal Party (Roxburgh, Selkirk and Peebles) : Would she reconsider the cost she gave the House last Thursday of unemployment in the light of the article in The Times Business News this morning based on
Treasury figures which suggests that the total direct and indirect cost to the Government of higher unemployment is likely to be £5,000 per worker ?
Mrs. Thatcher : The two things are wholly different. I gave the cost of unemployment benefit coupled with social security benefit. Those figures are accurate.
What he is giving is what the Exchequer would benefit if everyone were in work. (Labour cheers). If everyone were at work producing goods and services that someone else would buy without subsidy there would be no problem.
Mr. Michael Foot, Leader of the Opposition (Ebbw vale, Lab) : Since the Leader of the House (Mr. Pym) has stated in a notable speech that the Government is in a frame of mind to recognize reality and acknowledge mistakes, would she
reconsider the answer she gave me on Tuesday about the coal industry in which she appeared to wash her hands of the whole issue ?
Will she look afresh at the matter, see how serious the situation is and promise that the Government will intervene ?
Mrs. Thatcher : In regard to the speech by the Chancellor of the Duchy I wholly agree with him. There was excellent stuff in it — "The attack on inflation is an attack on unemployment" and "The most enduring safeguard against
unemployment will be the elimination of inflation. We must not abandon the long term strategic approach we believe in."
It is the Government's duty to negotiate with the chairman of the National Coal Board the amount of money for the year. This year it is £834m ; next year it will be £882m. These are considerable sums on top of the price for coal and are sums
which give coal an excellent future.
Mr. Foot : Is she seriously saying she will refuse to call together in this critical situation the tripartite meetings we had on the coal industry which saved it following the experiences of 1974 ?
When we came in we had to call together these tripartite discussions to deal with the matter. That is what she will have to do on this occasion. Will she decide to do it now instead of being forced to do it later ?
Mrs. Thatcher : No. I am not forced to do anything.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Foot, Michael | | | |
| Meacher, Michael | | | |
| Pym, — | | | |
| Steel, David | | | |
| Thatcher, Margaret, Mrs. | | | |