10th March 1980
The Obstacles facing British Mine development
Last week's ruminations in this column about the supply of strategic minerals in the United Kingdom raised by implication the question of how much mining there is in this country. The matter is also interesting because it goes to the heart of a number of
major debates about investment, the environment, and relations between government and industry.
If coal is excluded, a first impression is that British mining is not important overall, though it is more diverse than one might think. For a start, projects tend to be small by the standards of an industry geared to mammoth international investment.
Amax's Hemerdon tungsten and tin deposits near Plymouth might cost about $50m or $60m to develop.
Second, the possibilities are restricted by geology. Some valuable minerals such as manganese or chrome are probably geologically impossible. It is significant that the leading type of mining measured by weight is sand and gravel, followed by limestone
and dolomite. In 1978, the last year for which figures are available, production of these was 107,000 tonnes and 84,000 tonnes respectively.
This is not to say that other minerals do not exist. As the Wheal Jane episode demonstrated, Cornish tin is plentiful and profitable given good management. North Wales has extensive low-grade copper deposits, the Pennines and Lake District have reserves
of fluorspar, uranium, and various metals, while exploration in Scotland for uranium looks promising even if lead and zinc have proved disappointing. Charter is struggling with Cleveland Potash.
But here the difficulties arise. Most of these areas are the few bits of the country not concreted over. As Rio Tinto-Zinc discovered in Wales, and the British Steel Corporation in the east Midlands, the environmental lobby is powerful. Its power is not
just political, but is also built into the whole planning apparatus and includes the considerable cost of applying for and obtaining permission.
Even before a company weaves its way through these obstacles, however, it needs to discover who owns the land and the mineral rights. With gold and coal the beneficiary is clear ; one is the Crown and the other the National Coal Board. But centuries of
obscure rights and privileges have left a legal maze. Different mineral rights on the same land may belong to different people, and in some cases no beneficiary may be found at all.
Assuming that a compliant owner and cooperative local authority are found, the aspiring developer then needs money. On this count he faces two disincentives. By comparison with many other countries, the nearest being Ireland, the tax position can be
unfavourable. Three years ago the Inland Revenue relaxed the rules so that some exploration and planning expenses could be offset against tax.
But the Treasury has refused to introduce depletion allowances on the grounds that levying corporation tax in different ways could set undesirable precedents. Since mines in Britain are likely to be small and fairly short lived, the absence of depletion
allowances can lower the return on investment.
Mining
The likely low return is a frequent complaint. But tax is not the only reason. After so many years of exploitation and intensive exploration most of the best deposits have probably been exhausted. On the whole, prices are not yet sufficiently high to tip
the balance, especially if set against the social costs of damage to the environment. At the moment voters appear to put a higher price on the countryside than on reducing imports or creating jobs.
All these factors mean that institutional investment for mining projects can be hard to find. Mr. Robert Sprinkel's attempt to take personal control of Wheal Jane was largely frustrated by the lack of City money. His optimistic view of the mine's
prospects now seems to be vindicated.
By contrast, private investors showed more enthusiasm. Unfortunately, a mine probably needs more than individuals can find. Here the mining finance houses come in — or rather, the critics say, they do not come in. Other than Cleveland Potash, Wheal
Jane, and Amey Roadstone, the British mining activities of the London finance houses are miniscule.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Sprinkel, Robert | | | |