9th June 1978
Benn Offer Of Mine Closure Veto Likely To Be Rejected
By Paul Routledge
Labour Editor
Mr. Wedgewood Benn, Secretary of State for Energy, has offered the National Union of Mineworkers veto powers over National Coal Board pit closure plans but most of the miners' leaders seem opposed to the idea.
The unprecedented proposal that the industry's most powerful union should be able to decide which collieries stay open was made in private talks between the minister and national officials of the NUM two days ago.
But the plan attracted only one local enthusiast, Mr. Arthur Scargill, left-wing president of the Yorkshire miners, when it was put to the union's national executive yesterday. No final decision was taken but it is likely to be formally rejected.
The idea was put up by Mr. Benn after protests by the union at the threatened closure of Teversal colliery, on the Nottinghamshire — Derbyshire border. The minister said he wanted negotiations with the NUM on procedure followed by the coal
board when it closed pits.
National officials of the NUM involved in the discussions, Mr. Joseph Gormley, the president, Mr. Lawrence Daly, the general secretary, Mr. Michael McGahey, the vice-president, counselled against acceptance of the proposal, and
Mr. Peter Heathfield, the north Derbyshire pitmen's leader and an outspoken advocate of industrial democracy in the coal industry, was also highly critical.
Mr. Heathfield argued that if the union had a veto it would be blamed for pit closures that were properly the responsibility of the coal board.
This is the second time that the question of NUM involvement in deciding on colliery closures has been raised by Mr. Benn, and I understand that the coal board was not consulted about the new powers he proposed to give, which the union appears to
be unwilling to accept.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Benn, Wedgewood | | | |
| Daly, Lawrence | | | |
| Gormley, Joseph | | | |
| Heathfield, Peter | | | |
| McGahey, Michael | | | |
| Routledge, Paul | | | |
| Scargill, Arthur | | | |