17th January 1978
Mine Likely In Part Of National Park
Regional Report
Ronald Kershaw
Whitby
A public inquiry into an application to develop a potash mine in the Whitby area opens at Whitby on February 7. Whitby Potash, a subsidiary of Consolidated Gold Fields, is appealing against a refusal of planning permission by the North York Moors
National Park Committee. Without having the audacity to preempt the decision of the inspector or the Secretary of State for the Environment, it may be said with some conviction that in the long run the national park committee is "on a hiding to
nothing".
Under the Local Government Act, 1972, the power to determine planning applications within the national park had to be delegated to the national park committee by North Yorkshire County Council. One of the exceptions to the rule is a "straddling
application" where only part of a project obtrudes into the national park. In those circumstances the county council must decide whether to consider planning applications or delegate that authority to the national park committee.
The county council has in the past taken the latter course hence the committee's authority to reject the Whitby Potash application which is a "straddling application." Now there has been a change of policy and the county council will in future
determine such applications.
The county council favours the development of Whitby Potash, so if the appeal fails, the company only need reapply to the council's planning authority and permission will be forthcoming.
Early this month Scarborough Borough Council came out strongly in favour of the Whitby Potash project, with Councillor Peter Jaconelli arguing for the mine. Mr. Jaconelli is also chairman of North Yorkshire County Planning Committee.
Even without support from the local authorities Whitby Potash has a strong case. This is a £75m to £80m venture due to be in operation by 1982, creating 200 new jobs. The local authority will receive an estimated £250,000 in rates each
year and there will be import saving to the national balance of payments of more than £30m a year on potash alone.
The environmentalists protest that the mine, at Egton Moor, and an associated refinery at Stainsacre, on the outskirts of Whitby, will detract from the tourist attraction of the fishing port. They point to the transporting of waste from the mine out to
sea and recall that an "escape" at the existing Cleveland Potash mine at Boulby, near Whitby, allowed sodium chloride to get into a freshwater beck, killing fish and organisms on which they feed.
Mrs. Jean Greenan, a councillor, says the refinery will be the size of a 14-storey office block with a chimney twice as high. She accuses the local authority of being interested in the "quick penny" rather than the Whitby environment.
Councillors, she says, have been mesmerized by the prospect of new local jobs.
At least a dozen organizations jointly or individually are contesting the appeal.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Greenan, Jean, Mrs. | | | |
| Jaconelli, — | | | |
| Kershaw, Ronald | | | |