January 1970, Page: 3
MPs urge cash support for 'marginal' pits
A special Government premium to keep "marginally-losing" pits open,
and so provide more jobs in development areas to off-set high unemployment, is
called for by an all-party group of MPs in a detailed report on the coal
industry.
The Select Committee on Nationalised Industries — headed by Labour MP for
Poplar Mr. Ian Mikardo — say there is no logical reason why the Coal
Board should be deprived of this Government aid.
Marginal areas
It is already available to other employers, including coal's competitors to
provide jobs in these unemployment blackspots.
The committee are thinking of a payment — similar to the Regional
Employment Premium already paid to manufacturing industries in development
areas — to keep slightly unprofitable pits working.
This is at present worth up to 30s. a week for each factory employee. Said Mr.
Mikardo: "It would be used only in marginal cases — to decide if a
pit in a development area should remain open."
Impressive
He emphasised that it would not mean keeping unprofitable pits going at the
expense of profitable ones. And the premium should not prevent the closure of
any heavy losers.
The 120-page report of 10 MPs — including mining Members Mr. Richard Kelley,
Don Valley, Yorkshire and Mr. Michael McGuire, Ince, Lancashire —
took 10 months to prepare.
The verdict is that the industry's future depends on producing low-cost coal.
They want low-cost collieries which are reasonably certain to continue in
production to know exactly what their prospects are.
Sound schemes
Praising impressive improvements in productivity, the committee say mineworkers
and their union are entitled to full credit for accepting pit mechanisation.
"Without current Improvements, and further Improvements forecast, the
future of the Industry would be gloomy indeed," the report continues.
The committee questioned Ministry of Power, National Coal Board and National
Union of Mineworkers' chiefs about coal's prospects and challenges. They
describe any removal of Government help for the industry as remote, but point
out that if it did happen it would have serious effects on mining.
Schemes to extend the use of coal — including payments to the electricity
and gas industries — are "generally sound."
They "warmly welcome" the Government's decision to pay for the cost
of deferring any closure of a losing pit, but describe the extent of losses so
far met as "prohibitive".
Demand forecast
"Governments should pay for the cost involved when an industry acts to
further Government policy rather than its own financial interests," says
the report.
The redundancy payments scheme for mineworkers over the age of 55 has
"worked effectively".
The committee note that the Coal Board and former Ministry of Power agreed the
industry's immediate objectives, but not the forecast level of demand for coal
after 1971 — estimated by the NCB to be about 135 million tons for 1975
and by the Ministry about 120 million tons.
Best interests
They call on the Board to estimate the effect on pit productivity and costs of
possible sales forecasts other than 135 million tons a year.
Welcoming the industry's new administrative structure of 17 self-contained
Areas. the report says it has clearly played a part in improving productivity.
The MPs would welcome any steps to simplify coal's "extremely complex
price structure" — described as being based on the average costs of
each coalfield.
They suggest in the long run basing coal prices on the cheapest source of
supply for each part of the country, allowing for transport costs —
whether that cheapest source is the local coalfield or a more distant one.
A long-term contract for coal supplies to power stations is being discussed by
the NCB and the Central Electricity Generating Board. The report notes that
both parties agree that contracts are in their best interests.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Kelley, Richard | | M.P. | |
| McGuire, Michael | | M.P. | |
| Mikardo, Ian | | M.P. | |