Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th March 1965

High Court Of Justice: Queen's Bench Division

A Mine Explosion

Wright v. Imperial Chemical Industries

Before Mr. Justice Edmund Davies

His Lordship, in a judgement reserved from March 3, after a hearing occuping 13 days, assessed liability at 50 per cent. and entered judgement for the plaintiff for agreed damages of £3,750 and costs in this action by Mr. Harold Frank Wright, aged 59, driller, of Melrose Avenue, Billingham-on-Tees, co. Durham, against Imperial Chemical Industries for damages for personal injuries and consequential loss resulting from ignition of a combustible mixture of methane and air in the Anhydrite Mine, Billingham, at about 1.30 a.m. on January 26, 1961. Mr. Wright claimed both in negligence and breach of statutory duty under the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954. The defendants denied negligence or breach of statutory duty and alleged that the ignition was due to his operating a cigarette lighter, a criminal act under the statute of 1954, and contrary to standing orders and regulations. A further allegation by the defendants that the plaintiff was Guilty of contributory negligence in failing to observe or heed the warning of the presence of inflammable gas given by the Davy safety-lamp with which he had been supplied was abandoned during the course of the trial.

Mr. John Stocker and Mr. M. Stuart-Smith appeared for the plaintiff ; Mr. R. H. Forrest, Q.C., and Mr. P. J. Crawford for the defendants.

Judgement

His Lordship said that the violent explosion caused about 500 yards of roadway in the mine to be come enveloped in flame, engulfing Mr. Wright and his colleague, Lake, and causing them substantial injuries. Methane gas had been found to emanate from porous dolomite underlying the anhydrite seam, and, in 1957, Billingham was classified as a safety-lamp mine. Notices were prominently displayed drawing the workmen's attention to the safety precautions prohibiting the possession of smoking materials and taking into the mine various flame producing articles. There was no room for doubt that Mr. Wright fully realized their import.

Anhydrite was won by drilling, charging and blasting by shot-firers, the twin-drill rig involved being operated by compressed air. Once the drilling started there was no need for the driller to remain on the platform, for there was nothing to be done for the next 10 minutes until the drilling was completed. At about 1.15 a.m. on January 26, 1961, Mr. Wright and Lake were warned that blasting was to take place at the end of a cross-cut, and they therefore stopped the two drills, retreated down another cross-cut, and waited until withdrawal of red lamps served to inform them that they were free to return to their working place.

That involved a wait of about 10 minutes, whereupon Mr. Wright offered to go ahead and set the drills to work. The reason for this gesture had been much disputed. The defendants asserted that it was prompted by his desire to enjoy a quiet smoke away from Lake, who was, as Wright knew, a non-smoker and likely to report to the management if Wright was caught smoking. Wright denied this and claimed to have been animated solely by a friendly desire to assist Lake who was asthmatic and having difficulty in breathing on this shift when, so it was claimed, the air was particularly dust-laden.

Before Wright had started the second of the twin-drills Lake arrived, but, so he said, could not tell whether or not Wright was smoking ; finding the conditions intolerable for his asthma, he started going away. When he was about 10 feet away he heard the distinctive noise of the drill biting the face. Immediately there was a "whoosh" and he was engulfed in flame.

The issues of fact and law raised during the 13 days of hearing were many and some were difficult. A detailed analysis of the great body of evidence called would have necessitated a judgement of intolerable length, and his Lordship sought to state his conclusions with as much brevity as was consistent with adequacy. Mr. Forrest had conceded that a prima facie case both of negligence and breach of section 55 (1) of the Mines and Quarries Act, 1954, was established by the fact of the explosion itself — which proved the presence of methane in the combustible range — together with the plaintiff's sworn denial that he caused or contributed to the explosion. The stage of prima facie proof, however, had long been passed, and his Lordship had to consider, on the evidence, as a whole, whether the plaintiff's case was made out.

Irresistible Inference

His Lordship considered and rejected the suggestion that the combustible mixture had been ignited by a broken drill or frictional sparking. The irresistible inference was that the plaintiff set the bottom drill in motion, climbed up to the driller's platform, set the top drill and put it into operation and then, knowing that he had some 10 minutes to spare, and believing that Lake had gone away, took a cigarette and lighter — either from his person or from one of the several possible hiding places on the rig — operated it, and was immediately enveloped in flames, flinging away a lighter to a place where it was found later.

Methane had been emitted at not less than 200 cubic feet a minute and possibly as much as 400. This was vastly greater than had ever been experienced in the mine — as different from known emissions as an ocean wave from a ripple on a pond. The greatest previous emission found was two cubic feet a minute, and the manager would, as he put it, never in his wildest dreams have expected such an emission as occurred on the night of the explosion.

The accident, unhappily, demonstrated that the airflow ventilation across the plaintiff's working face was insufficient. Although his Lordship acquitted the defendants of blame in relation top the ventilation system, the very impossibility of their being able to anticipate or estimate, with anything approaching certainty, what volume of methane might emerge, and under what pressure, seemed to underline and increase the importance of devising such a system of work as would reasonably ensure that men were not permitted within an area possibly contaminated by gas until tests had established that it was, in fact, free from contamination.

What could happen might be unpredictable ; what happened should be capable of being ascertained or, at least, guarded against until its ascertainment was possible. "The more serious the damage which will happen if an accident does occur, the more thorough are the precautions which an employer must take" — per Lord Morton in Paris v. Stepney Borough Council (1951) (A.C. 367, 385).

In his Lordship's judgement the dreadful potentiality of methane, and the known impossibility of prophesying with any accuracy what such operations as drilling and blasting might lead to in the way of gas emissions, would emphasize to the prudent employer the importance of non-admission to the danger area of any workman or of operating any machinery that might cause an incendive spark until testing for gas had taken place.

In this respect the defendants, in his Lordship's judgement, had failed.

The Defendants' Omissions

He had borne in mind the tributes paid to the defendants as excellent employers and was not unmindful of the finding that this particular emission was beyond the bounds of reasonable foreseeability. His Lordship concluded that, to allow the plaintiff and Lake to return to their working place before there had been testing, was a negligent omission directly and casually connected with the accident, and also constituted a breach of section 55 (5) of the Act, which required the manager, whenever "the ventilation is intensified or ceases to be adequate . . . to secure that, until the ventilation is restored, access to that part of the mine is so restricted as to prevent from entering it any person not authorized to do so . . ."

His Lordship had found the application of section 55 (5) by no means the easiest part of this difficult case. It seemed to him incumbent on the mine manager to take proper steps to inform himself of the adequacy of the ventilation whenever there had been a mining operation, such as blasting that might have brought about changed conditions possibly affecting the adequacy of such ventilation. Until he had tested he could not secure whether or not, despite past experience, the ventilation had ceased to be adequate. Pending such tests he could and must, therefore, at least secure that access was restricted in the manner prescribed by section 55 (2). The defendants' negligence and breach of section 55 (5) was a contributory cause of the accident.

The explosion was caused by the act of Wright in operating a cigarette lighter in his working place where there was an inflammable mixture due to an emission of methane elsewhere, which the defendants could not reasonably have foreseen as a possible event. If reasonable foreseeability was the test of liability under section 55 (1) they must be acquitted of a breach of it.

This explosion and the plaintiff's consequential grave injuries were caused by improper acts or omissions of both parties. His Lordship had considered for a time that the plaintiff's conduct must be regarded as so outrageously blameworthy that his compensation ought to have been reduced by some 90 per cent of the agreed damages of £7,500 — but, just as the defendants might rely, to some extent, on their past experience in the working of the mine and the absence of any methane in the general ventilated atmosphere, so might the plaintiff workman. His Lordship had been particularly struck by the evidence of the very last defence witness, a mining surveyor, to the effect that he would not regard it as dangerous for a man standing on the rig to operate a cigarette lighter. The compensation ought not to be reduced by more than 50 per cent.

A stay of execution for 28 days pending consideration of an appeal was granted, but applications for leave to appeal against the award of costs, and of the refusal to grant leave, were refused.

Solicitors. — Messrs. G. Howard & Co. ; Mr. J. W. Ridsdale.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Crawford, P. J.      
Davies, Edmund, Justice      
Forrest, R. H.      
Lake, —      
Ridsdale, J. W.      
Stocker, John      
Stuart-Smith, M.      
Wright, Harold Frank      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Billingham (Anhydrite)  Billingham (Anhydrite)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print