|
23rd May 1963 Shot-Firing FatalityInquest On Egremont ManThree witnesses - a mine manager, shot firer and a miner - declined to give evidence at the resumed inquest at Whitehaven on Wednesday on 19 year old John Joseph Trodden, of 44 Gillfoot Road, Egremont, who died as a result of injuries sustained in an underground shot-firing accident at the Millom Hematite Ore and Iron Company's Florence Mine, Egremont, on April 19. A jury returned a verdict of accidental death on the deceased who died as a result of shock due to multiple injuries. A pathologist, Dr. Russell Dalachie, said Trodden's multiple injuries included a fractured skull and added that death would be instantaneous. Solicitor's Advice When 28 year-old miner, John Shepherd, of Croft Terrace, Egremont, was called he accepted the advice of his solicitor, Mr. T. Bleasdale, and declined to give evidence. In a statement made by him while in Workington Infirmary after the accident, and read by P.C. Ivan Renwick, of Thornhill, Shepherd said that he and Trodden were drilling 14 holes in preparation for shot-firing when the shot-firer, John W. McGannon, came to see if they were ready for firing. When they said that they were not, McGannon asked them how much dynamite they would need and he left them 28 sticks of dynamite and 14 fuses. They used two sticks in each hole and Shepherd lit all the fuses. As they began to move away Shepherd was just about four feet from the face when a shot fired and threw him to the ground. He was dazed and the lights went out. He remembered crawling about and shouting for "Johnny." "I had only taken three steps when the shot went off. I have no idea how many shots went off altogether. I have no idea what caused the shot to go off so suddenly. It was just an understood thing that we would carry on and do our own firing," the statement added. Heard Shots Mr. McGannon, of 5, Thorny Road, Thornhill, also declined to give evidence on the advice of his solicitor, Mr. F. G. Lamble. His statement, also read by P.C. Renwick, said that he left the dynamite and detonators near where Shepherd and Trodden were drilling. He was returning from shot-firing operations in No. 8 Company and was about 60ft. from where deceased was working when he heard a series of shots fired. He helped the injured Shepherd to a cabin and sent a number of men in search of Trodden. "The place was full of smoke and we could find no trace of him. My dynamite box was empty and had been moved from where I left it." "On no occasion has a miner fired shots on his own, but it is usual for them to assist under the supervision of a shot-firer," the statement added. Miner, Charles McCrink, of Clayton Avenue, Cleator Moor, said Trodden's body was found 15ft from the face. There was enough stone about to fill 10-12 bogies. Manager Declined When the mine manager, Mr. Frank Fairbairn, of Hardheads, Egremont (represented by Mr. J. Jones), declined to give evidence, Mr. Gough said that no statement had been made which could be read to the jury. Copies of the mine regulations were submitted by a clerk, Mr. Thomas W. Braithwaite, of Old Bridge, Egremont. He agreed with the Coroner that one regulation stated that no one other than a shot-firer should fire shots and another ruled that where more than 12 shots had to be fired an electrical system should be used. There were also regulations dealing with the leaving of explosives. "Unusual" "The circumstances and the manner in which the evidence has been given are a little unusual," said the Coroner in his summing up to the jury. Referring to the fact that three witnesses had declined to give evidence, Mr. Gough said they were entitled to do this and it must not be held against them. Mr. Gough went on to say that it would appear there had been a breach of the regulations with regard to shot-firing. "Shepherd was not appointed as a shot-firer and should not have fired shots. McGannon who was duly appointed shot-firer left the materials in such a position, as to enable them to be used by Shepherd and the deceased," said Mr. Gough. "This was a breach of the regulations, as was the manner in which the shots were fired." The Coroner advised the jury that there was no criminal negligence in this case.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||