13th March 1958
Former Colliery Companies' Tax on Compensation
Inland Revenue Commissioners v. Whitworth Park Coal Co. Ltd. and Others
Before Lord Justice Jenkins, Lord Justice Romer, and Lord Justice Ormerod
Their Lordships dismissed these appeals by three former colliery companies, the Whitworth Park Coal Co. Ltd., the Brancepeth Coal Co. Ltd., and the Ramshaw Coal Co. Ltd., from a decision of Mr. Justice Harman on July 31, 1957 (The Times, August
1), holding in favour of the Crown that payments of interim income received by the companies under the provisions of the Coal Industry Nationalization Act, 1946, and the Coal Industry (No. 2) Act, 1949, fell within case III of Schedule D to the Income
Tax Act, 1918, and were not (as the Special Commissioners had held) chargeable under the provisions of Case VI. Their Lordships held that the interim income was taxable under Case VI and not under Case III, but that this would not affect the actual
result.
Mr. F. N. Bucher, Q.C., and Mr. Peter Rowland appeared for the companies ; Mr. John Pennycuick, Q.C., Mr. E. Blanshard Stamp, and Mr. Alan Orr for the Crown.
Judgement
Lord Justice Jenkins said that in these three cases a reserved judgement had been delivered on March 12, 1958. Immediately after the judgement had been delivered. Mr. Bucher, for the companies, had raised a point which appeared to be a new
point which had not been raised previously in the proceedings. In the circumstances an adjournment was allowed to give the parties an opportunity of investigating further the position arising in view of this new point. The Court now heard argument on
both sides about it. Of the three cases the Court was in effect only concerned with that of the Whitworth Park Coal Company (now an investment company), the case of the other companies clearly being governed by that one. The case concerned the treatment
of interim income payments under the Coal Acts of 1946 and 1949 for the apportionment of the actual income of the company among its members for surtax purposes.
The substantial question was in what year were the interim income payments to be taken into account for the purposes of tax.
Case III Inapplicable
The Court held that case III of Schedule D was inapplicable for the reason that the payer of the annual sums in question was a Minister of the Crown, and the provisions relating to Case III of Schedule D were couched in such terms as to make it
reasonably plain that they had no application where the payer was the Crown. Consequently it was held that the appropriate head of charge was case VI of Schedule D. On various authorities, however, it was held that nevertheless the sums in question must
be treated as income of the year in which they were received and not, as Mr. Bucher contended, on the basis of apportionment from day to day. These payments had in fact been made under deduction of tax, and according to the decision of the Court
that was the wrong procedure. The gross amount should have been paid and the companies should then have paid the appropriate amount of tax on being assessed to it under case VI.
New Point
Mr. Bucher's new point was that the amounts deducted by the Minister supposedly in respect of tax were wholly unwarranted deductions which never ought to have been made at all, and according to the decision of the Court this interim income was to
be considered as income of the year in which it was paid ; these sums deducted for so-called income tax had never been paid, therefore they had not become the income of any year. If this point was acceded to, Mr. Bucher said that there would be a
substantial advantage to the company on the figures. He (his Lordship) was unable to accede to it. It appeared that the point was never taken before the Commissioners, and that before it could be accepted the facts of the case would require a
considerable amount of further investigation. It did not appear to him (his Lordship) to be right to hold this point open for Mr. Bucher in all the circumstances.
Lord Justice Romer and Lord Justice Ormerod agreed.
Accordingly the appeals were dismissed ; leave was given to appeal to the House of Lords.
Solicitors. — Messrs. Tamplin, Joseph & Flux, for Messrs. Heslop & Forster, Darlington ; Solicitor of Inland Revenue.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bucher, F. N. | | | |
| Harman, —, Justice | | | |
| Jenkins, —, Lord Justice | | | |
| Ormerod, —, Lord Justice | | | |
| Orr, Alan | | | |
| Pennycuick, John | | | |
| Romer, —, Lord Justice | | | |
| Rowland, Peter | | | |
| Stamp, E. Blanshard | | | |