|
5th November 1953 Death By GasMine Manager Cleared On Ventilation ChargeAs a sequel to the death to the death of a deputy through the effects of gas at Walkmill Colliery, Moresby on 15th March, the colliery manager Alwyn Hawthornthwaite, of Moresby, was charged at Whitehaven on Thursday, under the Coal Mines Act, with failing to see that adequate ventilation was constantly produced in the Bateman area of the colliery. Represented by Mr. W. M. Bell, he pleaded not guilty. Prosecuting, Mr. G. A. Preston, of London, described the ventilation at the Bateman area, where a 5hp motor pumped air through 22in pipes along the roadway to the headings. Never Came Out On Sunday, 15th March, Deputy Joseph Reay and a rope splicer, Robert Lawson, went into the Bateman area, where Reay switched on the auxiliary fan, which had been stopped for some 17 hours. They then walked up the stone drift to the headings, with Reay testing for gas all the way along. On reaching No. 2 heading Lawson stopped for a rest, and Reay carried on to inspect No. 1 heading. He never came out. After about 30 minutes Lawson began to wonder what had happened and started towards No. 1 heading, but although he saw Reay's lamp shining he was unable to get near him because of gas. He went to get help and Mr. Mason brought Reay's body out of the heading. He had died from asphyxia. Gas From Cavity Mr. Preston continued that gas emanating from a cavity in the roof had caused Reay's death. In consequence mines inspectors visited the mine and 30 hours after the accident an inspector found that although the fan had been running all the time it had not dispersed the gas. Mr. Preston said he was not suggesting the system was inadequate, but because the fan was switched off there was no ventilation at all. On two occasions immediately before this unfortunate occurrence deputies had reported the presence of gas from a "blower" in this area. By switching off the fan the management had cut out adequate ventilation. Robert Lawson, off 77, Moresby Parks, told of what happened that morning. In reply to Mr. Bell, he said he had not heard of gas being present in the Bateman area. It was the first time he had done a weekend job there. He agreed that when the auxiliary fan was off there would still be ventilation from the main shaft. "Blower" Reported Mr. B. Spencer, H.M Inspector of Mines, Whitehaven, said that examination of the colliery general statutory report book showed that a blower of gas was reported in the Bateman No. 1 Heading on March 11th and 12th and 13th; three separate occasions. At the time the fan was stopped the amount of air circulating in the working would be negligible. Questioned by Mr. Bell, he agreed that in the pre-shift reports, which went into greater detail than the general report, the Bateman area was pronounced clear of gas on March 11th, 13th and 14th. In fact, the dead man, Reay, had himself signed on 14th March that there was no gas in Bateman. Mr. Spencer did not agree that a deputy's initials in a working necessarily meant that the area was clear of gas. It meant that he had visited that particular area. Further questioned by Mr. Bell, witness said that, at the time Reay's initials were written on the shovel found near his body, the place he had reached would be clear. He would not admit that the facts proved there was no accumulation of gas in the Bateman district when Reay entered. Mr. Bell: Would you agree that the practice of switching off an auxiliary fan over the weekend was widespread throughout the mining area? — Yes. Witness said that weekend reports over a considerable period had shown that there was no accumulation of gas in the Bateman district while the fan was stopped. No Case Submission Mr. Bell then submitted that his client had no case to answer because, in light of the evidence, the prosecution had not proved that "adequate and constant ventilation" to free the roads from gas had not been provided. The Justices ruled that a prima facie case was established and the case proceeded. The defendant, first witness for the defence, stated that the practice of stopping the auxiliary fan had been operating for two years, though he had been manager of the pit for only eight weeks at the time of the accident. He considered that there was sufficient air circulating through the space between the blades of the fan for adequate ventilation. Witness agreed with Mr. Preston that seven days after the fatality an alteration was made in the ventilation system of the Bateman district. Brave Deed John Mason, of Moresby, the deputy who courageously brought out Reay's body, said he found the dead man lying on his back, with water flowing over his face from the roof. At the time he encountered gas 12 yards from the body, but when he re-visited the scene 1½ hours later he reached the place where Reay had been lying without trouble. The group agent, Mr. J. P. S. Withnall, considered there was sufficient ventilation in the district and there was contravention of the Act. The arrangements made had proved satisfactory for a year. He did not believe there had been an accumulation of gas in the working. Questioned by Mr. Preston, witness admitted he wrote to the Area General Manager after the accident saying that "no effort had been spared to eliminate the use of auxiliary fans in the Group." Water Responsible? Summing up, Mr. Bell held that there was an adequate supply of air in the Bateman district while the fan was stopped, as had been proved by the colliery reports for 12 months previous to the fatal occurrence. "If the main ventilation fan had been off we should have had to plead guilty, but it was not. The flow of water could easily have dislodged matter in the roof, forcing various gases out. If there had been an accumulation of gas over the weekend it would have been encountered by Reay and Lawson before they reached the Bateman district as it was blown out when the fan was started up." After a brief retirement, the Bench announced that the case against Hawthornthwaite was dismissed. Mr. Preston then asked for a statement of the case for dismissal to be made in due course.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||