16th November 1951
Colliery Explosion Inquiry Ended
Union Criticism Of Management
The inquiry into the explosion at Easington colliery, County Durham, on May 29, when 83 men lost their lives, was concluded at Easington yesterday after final addresses by Mr. R. Williams, M.P., legal adviser to the National Union of Mineworkers,
and by Mr. W. L. Miron, on behalf of the National Coal Board.
Mr. Williams said there was a conflict of evidence on the cause of the explosion, but he submitted that facts on which inferences had been based made it clear that it was due to gas from the long wall face being ignited by sparks from blunt picks
on a coal-cutting machine drilling into pyrites. He contended that the management knew, or should have known if they were carrying out their duties diligently, that there was an emission of sparks.
He thought that coal dust was a significant factor and that the attempt to suggest that it was purely a firedamp explosion could be disregarded. Gas had previously been found on the third south face, pyrites were known to be in the seam from top to
bottom, the ventilator was defective, the system of roof control was "quite unsuitable," and there was a dust hazard present. In his submission, there were many important points closely related to the explosion in which the management failed in
their duties.
"Disquieting features"
Mr. Miron said that "a number of disquieting features" from the point of view of the National Coal Board had been revealed at the inquiry, and it was for the board to take to heart, and urgently apply, some of the lessons learned. The
potential danger of sparking was open to argument, but, having regard to the absence of reports of gas in the area, the circumstances of a combination could not be assumed to exist. Pyrites in the seam were only encountered sporadically and were not in
any vein or similar formation. He would not suggest what part gas and coal dust played in the explosion, but the weight of evidence suggested that firedamp was the cause.
Evidence of stone-dusting was one of the most serious features of the inquiry. The management had done all they could in the way of dusting, although it was clear that there has been a failure to take samples from every working road in the mine. Measures
to be given immediate consideration by the board were that experiments in water infusion schemes must continue and more controlled wet-cutting be introduced. There would be an insistence that picks and cutting machines should be sharp, and the method of
caving, as against strip-packing, for roof control would have to be considered.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Miron, W. L. | | N.C.B. | |
| Williams, R. | | M.P. | |
 |
 |
|
Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
Pub. Date | Article (Newspaper) |
| 29 May 1951 | Pit Explosion Traps 78, One Man Rescued, Eight Bodies Found in Easington Disaster, Bishop At Pit-Head (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 29 May 1951 | Editorial, Pit Disaster (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 30 May 1951 | Miners Trapped After Pit Explosion, 14 Bodies Found : Over 60 Men Missing (The Times) |
| 30 May 1951 | 63 Are Still Missing in Pit, Lord Hyndley and Mr. Shinwell at Easington Pit-head, 'Won't Give Up Hope' (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 30 May 1951 | Relations Keep Night-long Vigil at Pit Head (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 30 May 1951 | Miner Listed as Missing Was Safe Home in Bed (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 30 May 1951 | Trapped Men Listed (Sunderland Echo) |
| 30 May 1951 | Editorial, Easington Pit Disaster (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 31 May 1951 | No Hope For 60 Miners, Lord Hyndley's Statement (The Times) |
| 31 May 1951 | 400 Yards from coal face, No Hope for 58 Missing Men : 23 Bodies Found at Easington, ‘Working Tirelessly' (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 31 May 1951 | Disaster Fund Opened (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 31 May 1951 | Stricken Village is told there is no hope for miners, Women Break Down as News is Given (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 31 May 1951 | Two Were Safe (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 01 Jun 1951 | Distress Fund For Miners, Broadcast To-Day By Mr. Shinwell (The Times) |
| 02 Jun 1951 | Easington Pit Inquiry Ordered, Mr. Shinwell's Appeal For Fund (The Times) |
| 02 Jun 1951 | Mr. Atlee Sends Message (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 02 Jun 1951 | Silent Village Lays Pit Disaster Victims To Rest (Sunderland Echo and Shipping Gazette) |
| 17 Jul 1951 | Easington Camp Boys Show Their Thanks (Northern Daily Mail) |
| 31 Oct 1951 | Easington Colliery Explosion, Miners' Evidence At Inquiry (The Times) |
| 01 Nov 1951 | Easington Colliery Explosion, Inquiry Told Of Rescue Workers' Deaths (The Times) |
| 02 Nov 1951 | Colliery Explosion Inquiry, Evidence Of Sparking from Machinery (The Times) |
| 03 Nov 1951 | Stone Dusting at Easington, Evidence At Inquiry Into Explosion (The Times) |
| 06 Nov 1951 | Shot Firing In Coal Face, Evidence At Easington Inquiry (The Times) |
| 07 Nov 1951 | Miner's Evidence Of Gas In Pit, Easington Inquiry (The Times) |
| 16 Nov 1951 | Colliery Explosion Inquiry Ended, Union Criticism Of Management (The Times) |
| 09 Apr 1952 | Easington Colliery Memorial (The Times) |
| 23 May 1952 | Pit Fund Appeal (Sunderland Daily Echo & Shipping Gazette) |
| 15 Aug 1952 | Easington Memorial Plans Agreed (Northern Daily Mail) |
| 20 Sep 1952 | Cause Of Mine Disaster, Firedamp Ignition, Inspector On "Bad Practices" (The Times) |
| 20 Nov 1952 | Grave By A Coal Mine (Northern Daily Mail) |
| 20 Nov 1952 | Appeal For Easington Pit Memorial Fund (Northern Daily Mail) |
| 14 May 1954 | Easington Memorial Nearing Completion, To Be Dedicated On Pit Disaster Anniversary (Northern Daily Mail) |
| 29 May 1954 | Tablets Unveiled To Memory Of 83 Killed In Pit Disaster (Sunderland Daily Echo & Shipping Gazette) |
 | Main page for Easington |
 | Accident/Disaster Page |
 | Text of the official report into the incident |
 | Memorial images gallery |