|
(Unknown)Article from the (Unknown), June 1948 Sherburn Hill Miners were "Accidentally Poisoned"No contraband found in pit or on menEight hours examination of witnesses at the resumed inquest yesterday on the four victims of the Sherburn Hill pit disaster, on 11 June, failed to show how the fire damp became ignited to cause the explosion. The jury found that the men lost their live "Accidentally by carbon-monoxide poisoning as a result of an explosion the cause of which was unknown." Rescue Heroism Among the facts which came to light during the hearing were: Heroic attempts by the under-manager, Mr. W. Kay, the master-shifter, Mr. George Smith, the deputy in charge of the district, Mr. Mark J. McLoughlin, and others to reach the four men at the No.5 coal face in the 4th West district of the Busty seam. The coal face was free from gas less than four hours before the explosion. The flame-testing lamp used by the dead shot-firer (Fred Hodgson) was found in two parts. There was no sign of contraband either on the clothing of the men or in the mine. Liberal stone dusting minimised the effects of the explosion. Duncan Davie, mines inspector, of Durham gave evidence yesterday that lamps provided for the purpose of testing for inflammable gas underground were subject to exhausting tests before beig issued for use in pits. He had no hesitation in saying that it was impossible for the bottom of such a lamp to be blown off either by an explosion inside the lamp or by external explosion. Shown the two parts of the lamp carried by Hodgson, Davie said that from a visual examination, and provided that the lamp was locked and correctly assembled in the lamp cabin before issue he would assume it was safe. The Coroner (Mr. T. V. Devey) said that the two parts would be submitted to the Mines Department testing station at Sheffield for examination. Explosion Still A Mystery Asked by Mr. Sam Watson (Durham area secretary of the N.U.M.) if he had any idea how the explosion was caused, the inspector said that Hodgson`s lamp was found in two parts at the source of ignition. Beyond that it would be entering into supposition. It might be entirely wrong to express an opinion as to what caused the ignition of gas. Mr. Watson: then you don`t know the cause of the ignition? The inspector did not agree that an explosion in the lamp would blow off the bottom of the lamp, or that the explosion was caused by an internal ignition from the lamp. He had known instances of that type of lamp having been unlocked by unscrupulous persons. Mr. Watson: would you say, then, that a lamp that can be opened is safe to be used in a mine? The inspector: Yes if it is as safe as engineers can make it. No Breach Of Rules Further questioned, the inspector said that it would be a breach of regulations if Hodgsons lamp was not examined after issue at the lamp cabin. When Mr. Watson asked witness if he considered it was also a breach for a deputy to relegate any part of his duties to another workman, unless there was some emergency , the Coroner ruled that there was no breach of statutory regulations with regard to examinations for gas The inspector agreed with Mr. J. Crawford (Durham Deputies Association) that a shot-firer was a competent person to examine safety lamps, if authorised to do so, and that such a workman made more test for gas than a deputy at the coal face when shot-firing was in operation. During further questioning of Frederick William Byrne the deputy-overman in charge of the district in the preceding shift, Mr. Watson exclaimed "we are losing hundreds of men every year in the mines and we are entitled at an inquest like this to see that all the evidence appertaining to the safety of miners is brought out," A Mystery The Coroner: the jury and I are not going to sit here and examine the delinquencies of the deputies at Sherburn Hill. Mr. Watson: we are not going to condone breaches of the Act without drawing the attention of responsible people to them in hope that sense will prevail on both sides. The coroner: there are other ways of doing that. We are only concerned with the explosion. The coroner warned the jury not to attempt to arrive at the cause of the explosion unless they were sure of their facts. He was satisfied that a statutory examination had to be made every five hours. The last examination of No. 5 face was made between 3 p.m. and 3.30 p.m. and the next was due before 8.30 p.m. The explosion however, occurred before that time. He was satisfied that there was no breach of regulations in that respect. In the absence of any evidence it would be most unfair to assume that Hodgson unscrewd the lamp. "I do not think that you, or anyone else, will ever get to the bottom of what exactly happened," he added.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 25 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||