|
22nd March 1947 "No Ground For Criticism"Professor's Report On Haig PitSince early February, Whitehaven miners have anxiously awaiting the report on conditions at Haig Pit, which Prof. A. M. Bryan, soon to be appointed Chief Inspector of Mines, was asked to submit to the National Coal Board. Prof. Bryan carried out a detailed examination of Haig Pit after the miners had protested to the N.C.B. against allegations contained in Daily Graphic articles. These articles so incensed the miners that the National Union of Mineworkers asked the Coal Board to arrange for an independent investigation which would either confirm or repudiate the allegations. In a long and detailed report of his visit to Haig Pit on February 6, 7, and 8, Prof. Bryan deals with every aspect of conditions at the mine and his conclusions are as follows :— "I find no reasonable ground for complaint or criticism as regards the conditions generally, the method of working, the system of mechanisation, and the work done by the men. "The hazards of inflammable gas and coal dust, either singly or combined, at Haig Pit, are well known, and for some years past a mining engineer with special knowledge of them, and of the mining conditions in the Whitehaven area generally, has been employed almost full time at the colliery to advise the management on the necessary steps and precautions to be taken against these hazards and to see that agreed precautions are carried out. I strongly recommend that this practice be maintained. "I cannot conclude without recording how favourable I was impressed by the high standard of workmanship which prevailed throughout the pit, by the obvious pride of both management and men in the improvements made and the achievements of recent years both underground and on the surface, and by the excellent relationship and degrees of co-operation that appeared to exist between management and workmen." Magnificent Airways The following are extracts from the report :— Ventilation :— Because of the relatively gassy and dry-and-dusty nature of the coal seams, the past history of the mine, the long lengths of trunk airways, and the extent of the workings and wastes at Haig Pit, well maintained airways of large cross-sectional area and a high standard of ventilation are prime essentials. The necessity for these is well appreciated and efficient steps have been taken to meet it by the provision of main airways, which can only be described as magnificent. The mine gives off about 4,000,000 cubic feet of fire-damp daily, a quantity which gives some measure of the fire-damp hazard in the pit. Because of this fire-damp hazard, electricity is not permitted or used on or in proximity to the working faces. Shot-firing on the coal face is prohibited in the Main Bank Seam, but is permitted in the Bannock Seam. A Gas Test I was unable to detect the presence of gas on the reduced flame of the safety lamp, while in no part of the mine did I detect more than 1.75 per cent. in any working place or roadway. I found no evidence of any person in Haig Pit having been affected or overcome by gas in recent years. Travelling Conditions :— Apart from the discomfort due to dust when a group of men are travelling in-bye roadways, the underground travelling conditions are satisfactory. In only one case does the walking distance at present exceed one mile, and then only by a few hundred yards. After walking along most of the travelling roads and seeing many of the workmen doing so at the change of shifts, I saw no evidence of men perspiring profusely, stumbling between the two-way tracks, or overhead obstacles on which men could bump or were bumping their heads, nor any necessity for men doing any of these things when travelling in-bye to the working face. Good Current of Air Methods of Working :— There was a good current of air passing along the working faces, with little or no trace of fire-damp in most cases. There was a considerable amount of coal dust in suspension in the air current, but I did not find the dust anywhere sufficient to prevent my seeing ahead. The temperature throughout was not excessive. Haig Pit cannot be considered in a mining sense as a "hot pit." Indeed, all workmen on the roadways were well clothed and in the working faces the men wore at least singlets and short pants. Shot-Firing Suggestion I would certainly recommend that work on the prevention and suppression of dust in coal-face operations, on the suppression and collection of dust at loading points, and on the consolidation of dust in the floor of travelling roads should be accelerated. In view of the hazards of coal dust and inflammable gas, I also recommend that renewed efforts should be made to devise a method of working which would further reduce or, better still eliminate shot-firing at or near the coal face. Absenteeism In common with other coalfields, the absenteeism among face workers is higher than that of other grades. Roughly, the avoidable absenteeism of coal-face workers and other under-ground workers is 3.6 and 2.5 times, respectively, higher than that of surface workers. Absenteeism, especially among actual face-workers, and loss of output, are particularly high on Mondays. It is only fair to record that the rate of absenteeism for all workers at Haig Pit is not above the average for the district and is probably below that for England as a whole. A small increase in output per man should be obtained from some face-workers. If the "dust-nuisance" at the coal-face could be mitigated somewhat, I feel that the men would respond.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||