1st August 1946
Greenbank Fight
Rolling Pins As Weapons
Trouble between neighbours on Valley View Road, Greenbank, Whitehaven, which it was stated, had lasted three years, reached a climax on July 22nd, when, it was alleged, a fight took place with rolling pins, a handbag, and a tin as weapons.
At Whitehaven Court on Monday, Susanah Wilson, married, and her mother, Mrs. Jane Hutchinson, were charged with assaulting Mrs. Mary Bitcon, and cross-summonses were issued against Mrs. Bitcon by Mrs. Wilson and Mrs. Hutchinson. Mrs. Bitcon was
represented by Mr. W. M. K. Bell and pleaded not guilty, and similar pleas were entered by Mr. T. L. Weguelin on behalf of Mrs. Wilson and Mrs. Hutchinson.
For Mrs. Bitcon it was stated that she had been subject to continuous victimisation by Wilson and Hutchinson. She had been called vile names and damage had been done to her property, all without provocation. On July 22nd Mrs. Bitcon had been talking to
Mr. Wilson about the trouble that was going on when Mrs. Wilson came out and struck Mrs. Bitcon in the chest. When Mrs. Bitcon struck back Mrs. Wilson threatened to "get her." In the afternoon, as Mrs. Bitcon was going into her house, she was
attacked by both the other woman, struck on the head with a rolling pin, dragged about the street, and her hair pulled out. Corroborative evidence was given by Mrs. S. Cartmell, Mrs. J. Oldham, and Miss Catherine Harrison. Complaints had been made to
the Town Hall and all the women had been threatened with eviction.
For Mrs. Wilson and her mother it was stated that they, too, had been insulted several times by Bitcon. They admitted assaulting her in the afternoon in retaliation for what Mrs. Bitcon had done in the morning. Mrs. Bitcon had struck back, but it was
denied that a rolling pin had been used. Mrs. Hutchinson had rushed out of the house at the time when she heard the row and happened to have a rolling pin, which she was washing, in her hand.
The defendants were bound over to keep the peace. For assaulting Mrs. Bitcon, Mrs. Wilson was fined 40s, and 7s 6d costs, while her mother was bound over and ordered to pay 11s 6d costs. Mrs Bitcon was bound over for assaulting Mrs. Wilson and ordered
to pay 4s costs. The case against Mrs. Bitcon for assaulting Mrs. Hutchinson was dismissed.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bell, W. M. K. | | Solicitor | |
| Bitcon, Mary, Mrs. | | | |
| Cartmell, S., Mrs. | | | |
| Harrison, Catherine, Miss | | | |
| Hutchinson, Jane, Mrs. | | | |
| Oldham, J., Mrs. | | | |
| Weguelin, T. L. | | Solicitor | |
| Wilson, Susanah, Mrs. | | | |