|
23rd January 1946 Nationalization Of Coal MinesColliery Owners And The BillLetter To MinisterThe colliery owners views on "various important aspects" of the proposals contained in the Government's Coal Industry Nationalization Bill are outlined in a letter yesterday from Mr. Robert Foot, chairman of the Mining Association of Great Britain, to Mr. Emanuel Shinwell, Minister of Fuel and Power. Matters which the Mining Association regarded as closed, the letter states, were the principle of nationalization of the industry, and the fact of arbitration, the composition of the tribunal, and the terms of reference. The letter then refers to matters of principle in regard to which the association feel themselves free to take such action as may seem to them appropriate. On the scope of the Bill, Mr. Foot writes :— The proposal in the King's Speech was to submit to Parliament plans for the nationalization of the industry. The Bill as it stands goes far beyond that point. In our view activities and businesses not part of the coal industry proper (that is the industry of mining coal) should be taken by compulsion only where they are so closely connected with the coal mining operations that it is impracticable to separate them. Examples of separate activities which can be acquired by compulsion under the Bill are :— Coke ovens, gas works, patent or manufactured fuel plants ; tar distilleries and chemical works ; brickworks, pipe works, and other similar organizations. Their compulsory acquisition not only goes far beyond the stated intention to nationalize the coal industry but also has the effect of spreading the principle of public ownership far into other realms of commercial activity. Method Of Compensation The amount of compensation (the letter continues) will be ascertained as a sum in cash, but the Bill does not propose that cash will be paid. Payment is to be in stock and, what is worse, for many holders the stock will of be restricted marketability, a fact which itself will seriously detract from its value. For these reasons the Bill fails to ensure that the compensation will be fair. We would strongly urge that all compensation should be paid in cash. We view with the gravest concern the proposals in the Bill :—(i) That the payments are to be made in Government stock ; (ii) that the nature and the amount of the stock and the interest to be paid on it are to be settled by the Treasury at the time of issue without any right of appeal, however unfair any decision might appear to be ; (iii) that in all cases in which a company is a colliery concern and does not go into liquidation the stock can be and presumably will be made non-negotiable in the hands of its owners for an indefinite period (except for certain limited purposes). Because of the Government's policy in regard to the fixing of the vesting date and the method of valuation, the properties to be compulsorily acquired cannot be paid for at the time of transfer. Indeed, in the best technical opinion, a period of not less than four years must elapse before the ultimate valuation of the mining assets can be completed. Companies' Liabilities During the whole period between the vesting date and the date of eventual liquidation colliery companies will be liable for debenture and other interest ; have to maintain offices and staff (even if only on a skeleton basis) ; and have to keep the colliery owners association (both national and district) in effective operation until all questions of compensation are settled. All those charges will have to be met before the shareholders receive any payment at all ; and in this connexion it is relevant to point out that the number of shareholders affected is not less than 150,000. The Government have in fact reorganized the difficult position in which colliery companies would otherwise be placed, by admitting the principle of an interim payment on revenue account ; but on any fair assessment of the needs of the case a money payment equivalent to only 50 per cent. of former profits, and continuing only for two years, is utterly inadequate. Further, at the end of two years from the vesting date money payments cease altogether. The letter presses for insertion in the Bill of the usual statutory clauses for the protection of the staff, not only of the individual colliery undertakings but also of the collective organizations of the industry. The Bill did not provide, as it unquestionably should, following the normal practice on the purchase of an undertaking, that the purchaser, on stepping into the shoes of the seller, should assume all the obligations and liabilities relating to the property he had acquired. Certain liabilities were taken over but many were not.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||