Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th June 1943, Page: 290, Column: 2

Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression

By W. Staton, B.Sc.(Hons.), H.M. Inspector of Mines.

From paper read at the April meeting of the Wigan Mining and Technical Collage Past and Present Mining Students' Association. Concluded from No. 24, page 279.

Blasting.

In connection with the blasting of rock little can be done to reduce the quantity of dust made airborne, and therefore the measures taken are intended to suppress this dust, to reduce the concentration by dilution with clean air, and to reduce the number of men at risk.

For the present the most effective way of dealing with blasting dust in fast ends and confined spaces is by means of the mist projector or water blast. It is not nearly so effective if there is a moving current of air, and if air movement can be stopped or minimised whilst the shots are being fired this should be done. The aim is then to fill the confined space with a barrier of water particles of the greatest possible depth and concentration, into which the dust particles are projected by the force of the blast, when they become wetted and precipitated from the air. The mist barrier should reach the working face, it should be formed before the shots are fired, and the concentration of water particles should be maintained by leaving the mist projector in operation for some time after the shots have been fired.

There are a number of mist projectors available, some proprietary, but the simplest is a simple T-piece of ½-inch diameter pipe, to the vertical leg of which is attached the water supply, and to one end of the horizontal leg is attached the compressed air supply — possibly these hose connections will be those from the drilling machine. The correct quantities of water and compressed air to give the greatest quantity of the finest mist are found empirically. It will be appreciated that the quantity of mist from a ½-inch diameter pipe will be considerable. Two such mist projectors are better than one.

If the mist projector is turned on for 2 or 3 minutes before the shots are fired, and left on for a further 15 minutes or so, 90 per cent. of the dust particles may be suppressed, but as the concentration immediately after firing may be of the order of 200,000 particles of very fine dust per c.c. of air, we are still left with a concentration dangerously high. Before the men return to the working place this dust must be diluted and dispersed by turning on the auxiliary ventilation or compressed air to its full extent. Care should be taken that there are no men on the return side whilst this is being done. For the present it is very necessary that rock blasting in any working place should be done at that time of the day when there will be the longest interval of time before men return to the place, or when the fewest number of men will be exposed to the blasting dust and fumes.

Dust Sampling.

I would like to discuss briefly the rather vexed question of the sampling of airborne dust. We can prescribe principles of dust suppression, and positive preventive measures in particular cases, but it is very desirable that we should know whether or not the measures being taken are effective, and the only way in which we can obtain this knowledge is by actually measuring the quantity of airborne dust. To obtain an accurate measure of airborne dust underground is extremely difficult, if not impossible.

In the main, for dust sampling underground, there are two types of instrument, the gravimetric and the particle count.

With the gravimetric instrument a measured volume of air is drawn through a filtering medium by means of a manually or power operated pump, or compressed air operated ejector, the filtering medium being either a bed of soluble crystals such as sugar, anthracene, salicylic acid, etc., or a filter paper. Over a period of time a relatively large sample of airborne dust may be collected and afterwards this may be recovered and weighed. From this the average concentration of airborne dust, expressed as Weight of dust per unit volume of air, may be determined. If desired the sample may be examined microscopically and chemically.

The type of filter used depends upon the type of dust to be collected, and the type of examination it is to undergo afterwards, e.g., a soluble dust could not be collected by means of a soluble filter, and the cellulose fibres of a filter paper might interfere with the microscopical and chemical examination of a sample. At present, for most purposes in connection with the suppression of airborne coal dust underground, the filter paper is quite suitable, and the filter thimble, such as I used when working for the Durham and Northumberland Coal Owners' Association, is probably the best. It has a large filtering area compared with its volume, therefore its resistance is low, and the weight of the dust sample is relatively large compared with the weight of paper, so that errors in weighing are minimised. Further, the dust is collected inside the thimble and there is little fear of the sample being lost during transportation.

Efficiencies of dust suppression based on the reduction in weight of airborne dust, and on the reduction of the number of particles of airborne dust, are two very different things. Thus, when we wish to assess the pneumoconiosis risk the sample must be collected in such a way that the particles can be actually counted and sized. I regard the gravimetric instrument as complementary to a particle count instrument, as by means of it much information about the dust can be obtained which could not be obtained otherwise.

Konimeters and Thermal Precipitators.

The two particle count instruments which have been mostly used in this country are the Konimeter and the Thermal Precipitator.

In the former instrument a fixed quantity of air is caused to pass through a small orifice and impinge upon a glass plate which has been treated with a glycerine adhesive in which the dust particles are retained. The spot of dust particles thus obtained is then examined under a microscope. In the case of the instrument with the microscope attached this may be done as soon as the sample has been taken, but otherwise the sample plate must be taken to the surface for examination under a separate microscope.

There are two methods of illuminating the particles, one being by transmitted light, known as light field counting, and the other being by reflected light known as dark field counting. In the first case, which is the method which has been mostly employed in this country, the microscope objective will theoretically resolve detail down to 0.8 micron, and particles rather smaller than this are probably visible as points of light, whereas with the second method of illumination details of the particles are not visible at all, but particles very much smaller than 0.8 micron in size will be represented by visible points of light — just as dust is rendered visible when we look at a stray beam of sunlight. This may not seem very important, but again I emphasise that from a pathological point of view we are really only concerned with the particles below a size of 5.0 micron, and in this size range, depending upon the source of the dust, 90 per cent. or more of the particles may be below a size of 0.8 micron. It will thus be seen that a very small extension in the lower limit of visibility of the particles can effect an appreciable difference in the particle count.

Figures have been given for the overall efficiency of the Konimeter, but a little consideration will show that there cannot be a constant efficiency — it depends upon the proportion of particles in a dust cloud which are below the limit, of visibility of the Konimeter microscope. In the case of a blasting sample where there is a very high proportion of fine particles, the efficiency may be as low as 5 per cent. and with a sample taken when loading rock, and where the proportion of fine particles is less, the efficiency may be as high as 60 per cent.

To enable the particles to be counted the eyepiece of the microscope is fitted with a graticule on which are ruled two diameters forming an angle of 18° between them. The point of intersection of the diameters and the centre of the spot should coincide. The whole of the spot should be within the field of view of the microscope, and this prohibits the use of an objective of greater resolving power, as we should then see only a portion of the dust spot. The whole, of the particles within the two 18° sectors thus formed across the spot are counted, and, as the volume of air sampled is 5.0 c.c.s. and as we are counting only one-tenth of the particles, it will be seen that if we multiply by 2 the number counted we shall obtain the dust concentration in number of particles per c.c. of air. Parallel to one of the diameters of the graticule is ruled another line at such a distance that with the magnification used they are 5 micron apart. If then the sample has been taken to assess the pneumoconiosis risk we may omit from the particle count all those particles which by estimation are too large to go within the two lines. This is the only size estimation that can be made.

Two other drawbacks of the konimeter are that the sample is a snap one, and a large number of samples must be taken before an idea of the average conditions can be obtained, and that the quantity of air sampled is fixed irrespective of the concentration of dust in the air.

It may seem that I am concerned only with criticising the konimeter, but that would be far from the truth. It has done much valuable work in the past, and is capable of much more in the future. We just cannot ignore its extreme simplicity and portability. I have been concerned to show that particle counts by the konimeter should be treated with caution, but where it is used as a comparator, i.e., where samples are compared one with another or against a standard sample, for routine testing work, I regard the instrument as being unequalled at the present time. If counting must be done, then in concentrations of dust within its range it is quite as accurate as some instruments which do not possess its simplicity and portability, and which fallaciously claim greater accuracy.

If the most accurate determination of the particle numbers, size and shape is required then I believe the Thermal Precipitator to be by far the best instrument. With this instrument the dusty air is drawn, by means of an aspirator, past a wire heated electrically from a 2-volt accumulator, the dust particles being precipitated by thermal action upon two thin, circular cover glasses, which are placed one on each side of the wire. The rate of aspiration is controlled by means of a calibrated jet. The time of sampling may be controlled, according to the concentration of dust present in the air, to give any desired density of sample.

Afterwards the two cover glasses are mounted on a glass microscope slide, the two dust strips being on the underside of the cover glasses and placed parallel to the shorter side of the slide.

They are then examined by transmitted light under a microscope which will allow all the particles between the sizes of 6.0 micron and 0.2 micron to be sized by estimation, and particles smaller than 0.2 micron to be seen. It will thus be seen that with this instrument the range of the visible particles has been extended considerably.

By taking a series of strips across the sample and counting all the particles within these strips the total number of particles deposited may be estimated. If this number is divided by the quantity of air sampled the concentration of dust in particles per unit volume of air may be found.

In conclusion, of necessity, the various aspects of dust suppression have been touched upon only lightly, but the essential points have been given, and it is my hope that I have made a little clearer the underlying principles. If this paper helps in any way to stimulate a more vigorous prosecution of dust suppressive measures I shall be very well satisfied.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Staton, Walter    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
01 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Jun 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print