Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th May 1943, Page: 278, Column: 1

Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression

By W. Staton, B.Sc.(Hons.), H.M. Inspector of Mines.

From paper read at the April meeting of the Wigan Mining and Technical College Past and Present Mining Students' Association. Continued from No. 23, page 272.

Rock Dust Effects.

And now I would like to deal with rock dust from the point of view of its ill-effects on the human lung.

In discussing this, beyond acknowledging that the degree of injury differs with different dusts, I am not concerned with assigning the blame to any particular constituent of the dust. In addition to the several names for the pulmonary changes caused by dust such as silicosis, anthracosis, asbestosis, haematitosis, etc., which indicate the nature of the dust involved, we have now in connection with coal mines the formally recognised term pneumoconiosis, which simply means dusted lung, and does not specify the nature of the dust. For my purposes if it is dust it is dangerous, and the only concentration of airborne dust with which we ought to be satisfied is the lowest concentration that is attainable in practice.

In general, I shall be speaking of the suppression of dust in hard headings or cross-measure drifts, with occasional references to rippings, but with a little consideration the general principles can be applied to all rock work.

Again we have the four main operations of holing, breaking, loading and transporting, but in this case the cut is usually formed by firing on the solid, and as transporting is the same for both coal and rock, we can confine attention to the three operations, drilling, firing and loading.

Drilling.

Of these three operations the greatest pneumoconiosis risk is probably still attached to drilling.

The usual method of drilling a hole in rock is to cause some form of chisel-edged cutting tool attached to a rod to make repeated impacts at a fixed point on the face of the rock, the tool being rotated slightly after each blow. This inevitably breaks down the rock very finely, and as the hole increases in depth, unless it is at such an angle that the cuttings so made fall out, these cuttings must be removed before a fresh surface can be broken down. When this method of drilling was done by hand, the tool was removed as necessary, water poured into the hole, and the cuttings scraped out as sludge. When, however, it became possible to make the percussive-rotary motions by means of a power-driven machine it became inconvenient constantly to remove the tool, and it was found to be quicker and easier to remove the cuttings by passing some of the compressed air through the hollow rod holding the tool, thus blowing the freshly made cuttings out of the hole, into the general body of the air, and probably straight into the face of the drill operator. In the course of time, enlightened people realised that this state of affairs was intolerable, and other means had to be devised to dispose of the cuttings. The trouble has been overcome by two methods, the first of which is to substitute for the air a stream of water, which performs the same scouring action as the air, but which also wets the cuttings and prevents the dust from becoming airborne ; and the second method is to place a cowl around the drill steel and over the mouth of the hole, attaching it firmly to the inside of the hole, the dusty air and cuttings being withdrawn and disposed of away from the men.

The first method is most often achieved by means of the axial water-fed drilling machine, in which a water tube or needle passes straight from the back end of the machine, through the valve chest and piston to the front end of the machine, where it either penetrates the hollow drill steel to a short depth, or terminates just short of it. The tube at the back end of the machine is then connected to a supply of water under pressure, either from a water main or from a tank in which the pressure is obtained from the compressed air. Water can then pass through the drilling machine and through the drill steel to the front end of the hole.

If water alone in sufficient quantity can be passed to the cutting tool the suppression of dust is very effective. With the axial water-fed machine, however, compressed air may pass to the front of the machine via the clearance between the water tube and piston and along the chuck rotating splines, and if this air passes to the front of the hole with the water then dry dust will be collected in the bubbles and later released into the atmosphere. Efforts are being made to minimise the quantity of air passing with the water, by reducing to a minimum the clearance between tube and piston, by so designing the machine that the piston splines are not uncovered to the compressed air (this is known as the long piston model), and by providing release vents at the front end of the machine for any air that may accumulate there (this is known as the vented model).

The leakage of air into the water stream can be entirely eliminated by the use of an appliance known as the external water feed. With this the water is fed through the side of the drill steel. It simply consists of a water box, with two rubber seals, which fits on to a turned portion of the drill rod next to the collar. The box is connected to the water supply, and the water is fed through a side hole which is bored, at an angle, from the turned portion of the rod to the central axial hole of the rod.

Another method which is being used to prevent the dissemination of fine dust into the air is the employment of a dense, tenacious foam instead of water. This effectively "blankets" the fine dust.

When commencing to drill with a water-fed drilling machine the bit tends to wander at first, and the water may splash considerably. There is a strong temptation to pitch the hole dry, but the quantity of dust made airborne with only a few seconds of dry drilling may be very considerable, and it should be resisted. To help remove temptation the drill manufacturers have almost completed the design of a dual compressed air-water valve, with which it will not be possible to turn on the compressed air to the machine until the water is flowing. To illustrate the necessity for this, I may say that in one instance where a compressed-air driven, rotary-percussive dry drilling machine was operating in a fast end without ventilation, the concentration of airborne dust rose from 40 particles per c.c. to over 50,000 particles per c.c. in less than 3 minutes.

The Dust Trap.

The second method of dealing with the cuttings is most often represented by the dust trap. With this appliance the cowl over the mouth of the hole is connected by means of a length of flexible hose to a canister containing a fabric filter. A negative pressure is caused inside the flexible hose and cowl by means of a small compressed-air operated ejector fixed to the canister; and the air which is passing down the drill steel, the air which is being drawn in around the cowl, the compressed air from the ejector and the cuttings, are induced to pass to the filter, where the cuttings and dust are retained. The filtering unit should be so designed that after the cuttings have been separated from the air they should be so disposed that they may be handled conveniently. It should be possible to remove them without the risk of the fine dust again becoming airborne.

If the suction cowl is properly maintained and applied, if the ejector jet is kept in good condition, and if the fabric filter is kept clean and free from tears, the dust trap is most effective in suppressing drilling dust.

Tirpentwys Colliery Installation.

The filtering medium could take any of the forms already described providing it could be made sufficiently compact and providing it had a satisfactory separating efficiency. Several attempts have been made to evolve a wet filter, but so far the dry fabric filter has been found to be most effective.

In this connection I would like to describe an installation at Tirpentwys Colliery, Monmouthshire, for which the manager, Mr. T. P. S. James, was responsible, where a whole district, consisting of cross-gates and stall roads, was equipped with a 2-inch diameter steel pipe line acting as a suction main. Again, the suction was created by means of a compressed-air operated ejector, of the ordinary boiler feed type. This ejector was placed at the outbye end of the suction line. Immediately preceding the ejector was a short length of 18-inch diameter pipe which served as a grit trap to take out the coarse material from the dust laden air. The dusty (and compressed) air was passed by means of a short length of pipe through a stopping into a dummy road.

The suction main was laid, along the cross-gates, and, by means of a Y-connection, a branch pipe was taken into each stall road, so that the drilling crew boring the ripping holes needed to transport only the drilling machine and a short length of flexible hose with the suction cowl. Normally all the branch pipes were closed by a screwed tapered plug, which could be removed in the stall where it was required to drill for the attachment of the flexible hose and suction cowl.

It was shown that the dust control at the drilling point was effective with a suction main over 1,000 yards long, and when two holes were being bored simultaneously.

In this case I should expect, as indeed it was, that a dummy road with fairly solid pack walls of extensive area would be a very efficient dust separator. The quantity of air being dealt with was small (not more than 200 c.f.m.) so that the air movement would also be small. Firstly there would be appreciable settling of the dust particles inside the chamber; secondly, the air would move only very slowly through the interstices of the packs, where again settlement would be high and, finally, any dust which did escape deposition would be fed only slowly over a large area into a large volume of moving air so that any increase in dust concentration would be very small. In addition the slow movement of air through the packs would ensure that the filtering resistance was low, and that little back pressure would be developed.

A modification of this method was used when driving a crossmeasure drift near the shaft bottom, but in this case the cuttings were conveyed to a roadway, stopped at both ends, between the intake and return airways. This acted as a primary settling chamber, and the dust remaining in suspension was conveyed to the upcast shaft. I was very much impressed by the clean atmosphere resulting at the face of the drift when this method of extracting the drill cuttings was employed, and my interest was particularly excited by the fact that there appeared to be a selective removal of the finer and possibly more harmful particles. With wet drilling it is the larger particles which are more easily suppressed. This point is being pursued further.

It was pointed out in connection with wet drilling that the pitching of the holes may be troublesome, and this is true, perhaps even to a greater extent, in connection with the suction removal of the cuttings. It depends almost entirely upon the drill operator how much dust is made whilst the hole is being drilled to a sufficient depth to allow the suction cowl to be firmly fixed in position. A suction cowl which can be easily and securely fixed to the rock face so that dust suppression is effective from the instant the drill bit touches the rock has not yet been devised, and until it has there cannot be complete confidence in the method.

Rotary Drilling Machines.

Of rather more recent origin as a dust preventive measure when drilling is the power driven rotary rock drill, which employs a special cutting bit tipped with tungsten-carbide alloy, and which by its cutting action, as opposed to the pulverising action of the percussive rotary machine, keeps the production of fine dust to a minimum. A twist steel is used to remove the cuttings. I must emphasise that all rotary drilling machines are not equally effective in preventing the formation of fine dust, and a rock drill has characteristics which differentiate it from a coal drill. It is not yet clear which special characteristics are important in preventing the formation of dust, but it seems probable that the design of the cutting bit, the speed of rotation, and the pressure exerted on the bit are all factors of importance. At the moment it can only be decided whether a particular machine is effective in suppressing dust by actually testing it.

One commendable feature of the rotary rock drill is the fact that, within limits, the production of dust is independent of the human element. Against this, however, should be placed the fact that with the electrically operated machine it is much more necessary to provide some form of ventilation. A compressed-air driven machine is a ventilating source in itself — the volume of ground broken and the quantity of dust produced will be roughly proportional to the volume of compressed air used, so that the concentration of airborne dust will remain more or less constant whilst drilling is being done, but with an electrically operated machine in a working place without ventilation the concentration of airborne dust may progressively increase.

The necessity for ventilating a fast end in which dust is being made cannot be too strongly emphasised. A little consideration will show that the concentration of airborne dust, and the quantity of dust inhaled by a person in the fast end, is inversely proportional to the quantity of clean air with which the dust laden air is mixed. This provides an easy and convenient way of controlling the concentration of harmful dust — it is being treated in just the same way as you would treat a noxious gas. Just as you have hurdles and deflection sheets to ensure dilution of the noxious gas with air so must you ensure mixing of clean air with the air containing harmful dust. This means that in a fast end the intake air must be given sufficient velocity to reach the working face, and it postulates that, near the face at least, the auxiliary ventilation should be of the forcing type.

Before leaving the question of drilling it may be mentioned that if a percussive-rotary machine is being used, and it is not possible to drill wet or remove the cuttings by suction, then a considerable reduction in the quantity of dust made airborne can be effected simply by using a solid spiral or twist steel.

(To be continued).


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
James, T. P. S.    Colliery Manager  
Staton, Walter    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
01 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Jun 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print