Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

15th May 1943, Page: 266, Column: 2

Subsidence And Its Bearing On Mining

By Haswell Alder, Arthur Walker and Lister Walker.

Extracts from paper presented at the April meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers. Concluded from No. 22, page 256.

By mathematical analysis of flexure it can be shown that the deflection, pressure distribution, shearing forces, and bending forces in the stronger roof strata over the sides of the excavation exhibit a wave form, the amplitude of which decreases rapidly as the distance from the excavation increases.

Any strong bed, if not stressed beyond its elastic limits, can be regarded as a beam resting on a foundation of elastic material and accordingly is subjected to upward loading of intensity proportional to its downward displacement, except over the excavation.

The calculation of precise stresses is not possible, as beds of rock are not true monoliths but have inherent lines of weakness along bedding-planes, and the deflection produced by unit pressure varies with increasing distance from the sides of the excavation because of the increasing lateral pressure.

The extent of the elastic foundations is unlimited, but consideration of photoelastic investigations suggests that as the depth increases the stress will tend to be uniformly distributed.

At the edge of the pillar the deflection of the coal sides will be greater for unit load than in the solid.

Hading Breaks.

We do not agree that subsidence occurs by movement of the general body of the strata along forward-hading breaks which continue through to the surface ; we suggest that the explanation is more complex than this. The existence of a fracture starting at the face, the position of maximum stress, and passing into areas of low stress, is not feasible. Many tests have been carried out on beams of Coal Measure strata loaded as a cantilever, and except when the clamping pressure has been excessive, a condition unlikely to obtain underground, the fractures do not extend over the side supports.

A study of fractures induced around excavations built in concrete and to which a uniform vertical load was applied has been made (S.M.R.B. 16th Annual Report). The concrete roof layer under load is similar to theoretical conditions envisaged. Tensile vertical fractures are induced over the centre of the excavation, and on the upper surface of the concrete over the sides of the excavation is the typical arch fracture. Under certain conditions in addition to the arch fracture, shear fractures hading over the side of the excavation have been formed but generally with comparatively weak sides.

It is common knowledge that both backward and forward hading breaks are induced ahead of coal faces and the question arises, what determines the direction of fracture and what in particular causes forward-hading fractures ? When a strong bed lies on a weaker bed of coal or stone the weaker rock will fracture and the zone of fracture will gradually spread over the sides of the excavation until equilibrium is attained, and consequently the maximum abutment pressure will move from the side of the excavation farther into the solid. The maximum abutment-pressure area may be over fractured rock before fractures are induced in the stronger bed, and there may be relative lateral movement of the beds causing additional shear stresses which determine the direction of the induced shear fractures. This matter has been fully discussed by R. Faulkner and D. W. Phillips. We suggest that the spreading of the abutments does not affect the general form of fracture but increases the effective width of the excavation.

When the strata are unsupported over a certain width of excavation (dependent on the nature of the overlying strata) they collapse along the lines of maximum shear stress. As the width of the excavation is increased, more roof material falls and the size of the collapsed arch is increased. In the case of a comparatively narrow excavation the redistribution of stresses restores the state of equilibrium without appreciable subsidence of the upper beds.

Increasing width of the excavation increases the height of the arch until it reaches the surface, which then subsides, but, because of support afforded to the beds above by the fallen strata, there is a stage beyond which the arch of collapsed strata does not extend and above which the beds behave as beams.

That the strata do not fracture along the lines of maximum shear stress right to the surface seems to be the obvious explanation of the fact that coal may be totally extracted below the sea, water-filled seams or water-bearing strata, without water finding its way into the workings.

It seems definite that Coal Measure rocks do not flow, with the exception of wet clays. Maximum length which a bed of rock 9 feet thick can span without fracturing is 100 feet, with a maximum deflection of only 0.2 inch. It would appear that subsidence must be accompanied by fracturing which cannot be continuous, and we suggest that deflection of the beds may be accommodated by slight movement along joints or other planes of weakness, natural or induced, without the occurrence of open fractures.

Control of Subsidence.

The method of working to be adopted will depend on the thickness and nature of the overlying strata and whether lowering of the surface is permissible or not.

Subsidence must be accompanied by a redistribution of load in all the strata overlying the seam right to the surface, and special precautions are necessary when working under seams standing in small pillars or under cavernous strata. Longwall working with intermediate packs involves the least differential movement of the strata, and where great care is necessary under valuable property, water-bearing strata or the sea, this method should be adopted. At considerable depth, bord-and-pillar, if worked systematically, can produce excellent results, as caving, provided the strata conditions are suitable, provides support analagous to packs. Persuing this principle of avoiding large differential movement, care should be taken in working below isolated property to have the face pass right under, with the property in the centre.

Pillars of coal of inadequate size left for the support of isolated property will cause more damage than will be caused by systematic total extraction.

It is not good practice to allow two faces to approach each other under property, as under these conditions surface movements are intensified because the overlying strata tend to bend upwards and delay subsidence until the coal is extracted, when the rate of subsidence rapidly increases.

The destructive effects of differential movements of the subsurface strata are often reduced or obviated by the occurrence of soft clays and sands near the surface, and where such strata exist many seams have been completely extracted without surface damage.

By means of carefully laid-out pillar work it is possible to extract a large proportion of the seam and to control surface subsidence. The gradual squeezing of coal-pillars of suitable size will result in surface settlement without damage, and, incidentally, will tend to reduce draw.

The strip system of working is practised in this country to a limited extent under areas where surface subsidence is not permissible, and it is increasing in popularity. Strips of coal are extracted so as to leave strips of coal of similar or greater width and capable of carrying the weight of the overlying strata. In the national and economic interests the maximum proportion of coal should be extracted, and, unless some system of American power-loading which seems to be ideally suited for partial extraction be adopted, it is essential for economic working that the width of the strip extracted be as large as possible. To eliminate the subsidence of the surface two conditions must be fulfilled: (1) The coal-pillars left must be strong enough to carry the load imposed upon them. (2) There must be sufficient thickness of cover to prevent subsidence of the surface for the width of coal extracted.

The Strength of Coal-pillars.

The load a pillar of coal can carry depends upon the strength of the coal, the relative width of the pillar in relation to the thickness of the seam, and the form of pressure distribution over the pillar.

Consider a cube of coal situated some distance away from any excavation and it will be deduced that the lateral forces will be the same as the vertical pressure. By consideration of the elementary theory of elasticity it can be shown that if the lateral and vertical stresses be the same there will be neither strain nor shear stress. If any known theory of elastic failure be applied to this condition of stress the ultimate strength of the material is infinite. In briquetting processes pressures as high as 45,000 lb. per square inch are applied without the coal completely disintegrating, which appears to support this deduction. Hence the rather startling conclusion that the compressive strength of coal is infinite if complete lateral constraint exists.

The pressure distribution over a coal-pillar before fracture is such that the load at the edge of a pillar is a maximum and decreases towards the centre of the pillar. Coal contains planes of natural weakness and the compressive strength at the edge of a pillar will be small, probably not more than 100 lb. per square inch, and generally the coal sides fracture and the coal tends to move in towards the excavation. The friction of the roof and floor on the fractured coal opposes this lateral movement and sets up lateral forces which will increase towards the centre of the pillar. It is this lateral pressure, built up by the frictional force of the coal on the roof and floor, which enables coal pillars to carry the enormous loads they do. Hence, the pressure on the pillar edge except in very strong coals is small and increases with increasing lateral pressure. The form of the pressure distribution is difficult to determine. If the seam be regarded as a plastic material compressed between two rough parallel surfaces and the friction on the surfaces is constant and equal to the shear strength over the distance the material is compressed, the pressure will increase from zero at the face linearly to the value of the load.

Coal does not rigorously conform to plastic laws as its resistance to compression remains comparatively high, even after fracture along cleat planes. The pressure distribution both in the laboratory and underground has been measured across a shale pack and it was found that the load carried increases rapidly and fairly uniformly from the edge of the pack towards the centre. Fenner has shown mathematically that the pressure over a bed of clay compressed between two strong beds increases in accordance with an exponential law.

Width of Excavation.

It is generally agreed that the safe width of excavation increases with increasing depth, and this general principle appears to have been adopted in practice with success.

All mining engineers know that longwall gates near solid coal are not so liable to break up as gates in the centre of the goaf. A fairly obvious deduction has been confirmed by pack dynamometer records, namely, that the load on the rib-side gate-packs is only a fraction of that on the centre packs. Similarly, gates do not begin to show signs of breaking up behind a face until the pressure on the packs has developed, usually at a considerable distance from the face. The reason for this is simple ; for a certain distance from the solid only the nether beds are disturbed fracturing or separating from the higher beds. The higher beds bridge from a point over the solid to a position in the goaf and any intermediate point is protected by the higher beds. It is suggested that the distance the face has to travel before the weight on the gate is disruptive, or the distance of a gate from the solid side before it suffers maximum damage, is clearly an indication of the safe width of excavation which may be attempted without surface subsidence. Obviously due allowance must be made for time yield, as it is fairly well known that the abutment area does creep forward if the face is standing.

It should be appreciated that the widths will be governed to some extent by local conditions, and deductions made from local data are more reliable than general observations.

With seams in close proximity, care should be taken to leave the strips vertically over each other, as obviously the staggering of strips would increase the effective width of the excavation and decrease the support area.

Care has to be taken when working under seams which may be standing in small pillars. If for particular reasons it is desired not to affect an upper seam or some upper strata, we suggest that the width of the excavations be not more than one-half of the distance between seams or between the seam and the upper strata in question. If an upper seam has been completely extracted, normal strip working may be adopted.

It is inadvisable to extract a panel of coal lying between faults, particularly if their planes are parallel. A remarkable case occurred at the Athens Iron Ore Mine, Michigan, where a rock of solid jasper, 2,000 feet deep, subsided over a depth of ore bed of only 200 feet.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Alder, Haswell      Whos Who Page
Faulkner, R.      
Fenner, —      
Phillips, D. W.      
Walker, Arthur      Whos Who Page
Walker, Lister      Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
01 May 1943  Subsidence And Its Bearing On Mining (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 May 1943  Subsidence And Its Bearing On Mining (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print