|
1st May 1943, Page: 255, Column: 2 Subsidence And Its Bearing On MiningBy Haswell Alder, Arthur Walker and Lister Walker. Extracts from paper presented at the April meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers. General Review. Total extraction of coal over a sufficiently large area is inevitably followed by subsidence of the surface regardless of the depth of working, the method of mining, or the thickness of the seam. The extraction of a 15-seam at a depth of 300 feet by gateway advancing longwall, in which the goaf between gates was completely packed, has resulted in surface subsidence. The amplitude of subsidence ranges between 5 and 70 per cent. of the seam thickness ; it is affected by the method of working, the quality of stowing, and the depth and character of the overburden, and can be reduced greatly by hydraulic stowing, but not completely eliminated. It is universally accepted that the subsiding area is girdled by a tensile belt where deep and wide surface cracks may form surrounding a zone subject to compressive forces in which curbing stones may overlap or the surface soil may be forced up into definite ridges. Uplift has also frequently been noted in the area of the surrounding tensile belt, but this phenomenon is not always seen. The surface immediately in advance of the face moves towards the goaf, and, after the face has passed, moves back again. The ground over the solid coal where the vertical movement is small, usually undergoes considerable horizontal movement towards the goaf, and the lateral movement is small over the goaf where the subsidence rate is higher. Where coal-pillars are extracted systematically by broken workings the movement of the surface is similar to that which occurs with longwall. Draw at the surface is generally positive when the coal is extracted with a definite line of face, whether the system of working be longwall or bord and pillar ; this has been proved in many instances where systematic levels have shown that the subsiding area has extended beyond the area of extraction. There is evidence that where the strata extending right to the surface consist chiefly of strong sandstones the zone of damage is limited to the extracted area. The angle of draw is usually negative where the panel system of mining is operated and the coal-pillars are robbed until the whole area begins to creep as in American and Indian practice. It is significant that the Sub-Committee on (Bituminous) Coal Mining (1926), concluded that surface subsidence from room-and-pillar did not extend beyond the excavated area. The absence of draw in these circumstances can only be attributed to the support offered by the coal stooks which crush but still offer resistance to downward movement. The existence of exceptionally strong sandstones of great thickness which are very common in India may contribute towards the absence of draw. It is generally concluded that dip decidedly increases the draw over dip faces and decreases, but not so definitely, that on rise faces. In apparent contradiction of this, the existence of the upper limit of a fracture arch has been definitely established vertically above an iron-ore bed inclined at 65° to the horizontal. No subsidence was recorded, but it is assumed that had the excavation continued it would have been vertically above the mined area. In addition, cases of chimney caving have been observed in highly-inclined slates, inclined at 60°, where the cave cut diagonally through the bedding vertically upwards. We make no attempt to specify the angle of draw, which varies widely with varying strata ranging from 7° to 60° with a mean of approximately 17° and is considerably influenced by the amount of soft sub-soil. Comparatively little is known about the behaviour of the strata between the coal and the surface. A unique study by H. Sheel of the type of fractures formed over coal-barriers left between royalties has been made in four widely separated areas, at depths ranging from 900 to 1,250 feet with barriers 60 to 70 yards in width. The height to which the water had to rise before it passed over the barriers has been carefully recorded. The seam was between 5 and 6 feet thick and had been totally extracted by bord-and-pillar. The roof varied from post to shale. It has been reasonably assumed that the point of intersection of the induced forward-hading breaks was at the same level as the water when it overflowed the barrier. Breaks would almost certainly be induced over the edges of the barrier, but as there is no evidence as to the position of these the forward hade from the barrier edges to the intersection of the breaks has been plotted, and the angle in each of the four cases studied was remarkably similar, ranging between 16½° and 18½° with a mean of 17½°. The existence of bending forces on each side of the barrier which may be superimposed on each other will result in a complication of the stresses causing fracture, and it is not possible to conclude that the results have a general application, but the observations prove the formation of forward-hading breaks under the conditions described. If it were possible to show that these forward-hading fractures continued up to the surface an understanding of subsidence would be easier, but in one case water under considerable pressure filled an upper seam goaf above the barrier, and as no water made its way into the workings below, it is apparent that the fractures did not extend to the upper seam. Levels taken by D. W. Phillips in a roadway 750 feet above a 210-yard advancing-longwall face in a seam 4½ feet thick at a depth of 2,700 feet showed that the forces induced strata movements at least 70 yards in advance of the face below. The maximum subsidence of the roof of the upper-seam roadway over the centre of the face was only 4 inches and the beds appear to have behaved as sagging beams which had not broken. The most significant feature of these observations was the general elevation of the strata in the vicinity of the roadway 60 yards in advance of the face. The roof only subsided to its original level after the face had travelled a further 120 yards. Considerable differences in both the vertical and lateral movements of subsiding roof-beds have been revealed by investigations made by Fleischer in which plumb-lines were suspended in holes of different depths bored in the roof. In some cases the movement of the plumb-lines was reversed and the variable movements are attributed to pressures of flexure of strong beds in the main roof. Phillips has shown that the rates of convergence in a heading in advance of the face are oscillatory ; these must be produced by a variable pressure-wave in confirmation of the theory propounded by Weber and Spackeler. The differential movements recorded by Fleischer and the variable pressure-wave may be attributed to the same cause, namely, the flexure of strong beds behaving as beams. The effects of subsidence on a shaft were observed in Pennsylvania by F. W. Newhall and L. N. Plein when coal-pillars were extracted from the area below it in a seam 7 feet thick at a depth of 320 feet. The strata consisted chiefly of limestones with strong sandstone beds. It is significant that when the line of extraction moving towards the shaft was still 120 feet away, the top section of the shaft was inclining towards the goaf and that this inclination was gradually accentuated until the line of extraction was within 59 feet of the shaft, after which no further measurements were possible. When the line of pillar extraction had passed 150 yards beyond the shaft, the shaft coping had subsided 2.71 feet, and the shaft was between 5 and 8 inches out of plumb, the inclination being towards the area first mined. The shaft was only slightly damaged, but differential lateral movement had occurred. Damage to the surface is generally greater owing to erratic movements, and the interaction of seams is greater in the vicinity of faults. It is obvious that a fault-plane reduces the strength of the rocks and subsidence tends to follow the planes of weakness. Kampers has suggested that the major surface subsidence caused by underground workings generally ceases after one year but may occupy three years, and that subsequent movement is only small and may be neglected for practical purposes. These observations agree with American records and with our experience. Wide divergence from these general conclusions occurs occasionally, but it is probable that other factors enter into these cases. Investigations have been made in areas far removed from mining operations, and surface subsidence has been observed which in a mining district would certainly have been attributed to mining operations. Some instances of subsidence quoted by colliery companies seem to suggest that it is often erroneously imputed to mining operations. In mining areas it is very difficult to separate subsidence caused by mining from that caused by natural geological phenomena, and there seems to be need for further investigations into the subsidence which may be caused by natural agencies. General Summary. It will be concluded from this very brief review of observed subsidence data that any attempt to explain subsidence must take into consideration a number of factors which may be summarised as follows :— 1. The inherent weakness of strata in tension and to a less extent in shear, and the consequent tendency of strata to arch. 2. The existence of a tensile force not only at the surface but in the main body of the strata. 3. The elevation of the surface and the intermediate strata around the edge of the subsiding area. 4. The existence of oscillatory pressures in advance of the face. 5. The tendency of the surface and the sub-adjacent strata to move towards the excavated area. 6. The formation of either forward or backward-hading breaks in advance of the face. It is unlikely that all the factors described above occur at one and the same time, but it is only possible to explain items 2, 3, 4, and 5 by the existence of forces resulting from flexure, and we agree with the late Professor Briggs that bending plays a much greater part than is often realised. Fractures in the Vicinity of Excavations. The application of theoretical considerations to a study of the formation of fractures is rendered very complex by the heterogeneous nature of coal-mining strata, but the invaluable work by Phillips on the properties of Coal Measure rocks has shown that they behave as elastic materials to a striking degree. These observations, and the regularity with which fractures occur around excavations, have encouraged the elastician to pursue the study of the mechanics of fracture. The relative strengths of Coal Measure rocks when subjected to compressive, tensile, and shear stresses inevitably influence the form of fracture. The compressive strength of shales and sandstones varies between 6,000 and 25,000 lb. per square inch when the pressure is applied at right angles to the stratification, and 3,000 and 6,000 lb. per square inch when the pressure is applied parallel to the stratification ; the compressive strength of coal ranges from 3,000 to 8,000 lb. per square inch. The modulus of rupture obtained in bending tests varies between 1,000 and 6,000 lb. per square inch for shales and sandstones, and 390 and 1,500 lb. per square inch for coal. The shear strength of shales and sandstones when the load is applied at right angles to the lamination varies between 1,000 and 4,500 lb. per square inch, and when the load is applied parallel to the lamination varies between 140 and 1,750 lb. per square inch. Only preliminary work has been done on the behaviour of Coal Measure rocks under tensile stresses, but two sandstones have failed at 560 and 1,340 lb. per square inch. This summary of rock strengths indicates that rocks will tend to fail under tensile or shear stresses rather than compressive stresses. The relative tensile and shear strengths are further reduced by the presence of joints and natural slips. Experiments made on small sandstone and shale beams indicate that the former fail more readily under tension and the latter under shear. When shearing stresses are induced there are always two sets of planes along which stress is at a maximum, but as there are rarely two sets of fractures induced, this is not sufficient to explain fracturing. This can be explained, however, if Mohr's theory of Elastic Failure be accepted. Mohr postulates that plastic strain leading to failure will start when a certain limiting shear stress is attained on any plane which may vary according to the value of the normal stress which acts in combination with it. Briefly, the limiting shear stress will be less if the normal stress on that plane is tensile, and greater if it is compressive. The elastic moduli for shales and sandstones ranges between 1 and 10.106 lb. per square inch, and for coal, 0.3 and 0.6.106 lb. per square inch. Although only preliminary investigations on tensile specimens have been carried out, it would seem that the elastic modulus obtained does not differ greatly from that obtained under compression.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||