Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

1st May 1943, Page: 253, Column: 1

Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression

By W. Staton, B.Sc.(Hons.), H.M. Inspector of Mines.

From paper read at the April meeting of the Wigan Mining and Technical College Past and Present Mining Students' Association.

The dust problem is not peculiar to the mining industry. The adverse effects of dust include the possibility of explosion and lung injury, also the acute personal discomfort that it may cause, and the increased accident risk due to reduced visibility. The elimination of these troubles is part of the same general problem, but for the purpose of discussion it is convenient to differentiate between rock dust, which is of importance from the point of view of lung injury, and coal dust, on which greater emphasis is placed from the explosive aspect, although it is by no means free from suspicion as a causative factor in lung disease.

Two Main Aims.

To take the latter first and to consider how coal dust is formed and the measures that are, or should be, taken to deal with it, it is necessary to make the first generalisation ; namely, that in winning coal the four primary operations are holing, breaking, loading and transporting.

The two main aims when considering dust suppression are (1) to prevent the formation of dust by keeping the coal as large as possible, and (2) to prevent any dust that is made from becoming airborne — "keep it big and keep it down." To take the first of these points to its limit it is obvious that if the coal seam was not broken down at all there would be no dust problem, and of the second point it may be said that once dust has become airborne it is exceedingly difficult to deal with it.

Holing.

We will now see how these two principles of dust suppression may be applied to the coal winning operations. To take holing first, and to consider a machine cut face, to ask for the coal to be kept large may seem a contradiction of terms, but, speaking relatively, much can be done in this respect. It has been shown that sharp cutter picks, by reason of their cutting action as opposed to grinding, produce less fine coal and dust than blunt picks. Efforts have been made to produce a cutter pick with a very hard tungsten-carbide alloy tip, and if those efforts are successful the picks should retain their sharpness for a very much longer time, and should be beneficial in decreasing the production of dust. In the meantime the frequent changing of picks is desirable.

In addition, the mechanical gummer by collecting the kirvings as they are swept out of the cut by the chain, and depositing them in a tidy pile alongside the cut, prevents them from being re-ground, and substantially reduces the production of dust. In order to comply with the second principle of avoiding dispersal of the dust the kirvings should be removed with as little disturbance as possible; all automatic gummers are not equally effective in this respect, although they probably make far less airborne dust than the hurried shovelling of the man behind the machine.

If we take a face 100 yards long, and a cut 4 feet 6 inches deep, then the weight of kirvings may be 20 tons, and with careless cutting 900 lb. or more of this may pass a 240-mesh sieve, all potential airborne dust. With frequent changing of picks and by using an automatic gummer, this quantity may be reduced to one-half quite easily, but it is still a lot of dust.

Much more could probably be done to reduce the quantity of dust by careful attention to the setting of the picks, and by finding the most effective pick lines and speed of chain and haulage of the cutting machine for any particular conditions. Energy must be expended in breaking up coal into dust, and the cutting machine which will give a certain length, width and depth of cut with the least expenditure of energy is likely to produce the least dust.

In order further to reduce dispersal of the fine dust during cutting, and subsequent handling of the kirvings, attention in this country is now being directed towards the practice of thoroughly wetting the kirvings as they are made, by means of water sprays attached to the jib, a method which has been used in the United States of America for a number of years. To be really successful I feel that a large quantity of water must be used, and this will probably necessitate the provision of a water main along the face.

Personally, I should like to see the whole of the kirvings extracted as they are made, and conveyed pneumatically to a convenient settling and loading point.

Drilling.

Before passing on to the operation of breaking down the cut coal, I should, perhaps, make some reference to the drilling of the coal. The quantity of dust produced by this operation, however, is so small, relative to the whole, that, as yet, it has received little attention. There is no doubt, however, that the rotary drilling machine, including the hand drilling machine, produces much less airborne dust than the percussive machine, particularly if the latter is a blowing model.

Coal Breaking.

With regard to the breaking down of the cut coal the main point is to keep the coal as large as is consistent with convenience of handling. Fortunately, there are other aspects of mining which make it desirable to keep the coal large, and whilst this obtains the dust aspect is not likely to be neglected.

If the coal is broken down by means of explosives then by careful attention to the positioning of the holes, to the correct choice of explosive, to good stemming and to the clearing of the holing, the explosives used should be kept to a minimum. Any excess of explosive simply produces shattered coal and dust. From many points of view it is desirable to eliminate, or reduce to a minimum, the use of explosives, and it is particularly desirable from the dust point of view. In this connection the various coal-getters such as the Cardox, Hydrox and Gullick coalburster, which develop their pressure over a much longer period of time than an explosive, and thus rend the coal instead of shattering it, are commendable.

Another useful tool in this respect is the pneumatic pick, which may eliminate both coal cutting and blasting, or it may eliminate or reduce blasting only, the pieces of coal too large to handle being further broken down by means of the pick. In any case it reduces the production of small coal, and the more it does this the more effective it is as a dust preventive measure. This fact is generally conceded, but with a very dusty seam the quantity of dust made airborne by the exhaust of this tool may be considerable, and as yet no efforts have been made to overcome this trouble.

Perhaps this is a convenient point at which to refer to the water infusion of the coal in situ which is now being practised in South Wales, extensively in the anthracite area, but also in the steam coal area. With this method, also, it is claimed that there is a substantial reduction of the quantity of explosives normally required, but the method is much more important than that. It is the first real effort in this country to suppress the dust at its source.

It is an attempt to reproduce artificially the natural conditions that obtained when the seams were being worked near the outcrop, where the coal was saturated with surface water, and where, it is well known, the production of dust was very much less than it is in some of the present deeper and drier mines. Briefly, holes are bored into the coal face at a distance apart and to a depth determined to be best by experiment, and then water under pressure is injected into them. This water percolates to a predetermined depth along all the dust bearing coal slips and breaks, binding the dust particles together and to the sides of the slips. When this method is adopted the reduction in the quantity of airborne dust is astonishing — on the anthracite and steam coal faces at least. It has not yet been proved that the method is equally effective with bituminous coal, but it could not fail to have beneficial results.

Loading and Transporting.

As regards loading and transporting the coal after it has been won in a form convenient for handling, the greater part of the inevitable dust has by now been made, and we are thus concerned with preventing any further breakage of the coal, and with preventing that dust which is already present from becoming airborne.

The cohesion of dust particles with each other and with larger pieces of coal is quite marked, and the cohesive effect may be increased by wetting the particles. The action to be taken therefore becomes quite clear. It is to increase the cohesive effect by watering the broken coal, both before handling and subsequently during transportation, and to avoid as far as possible the breaking of the cohesion such as occurs when the broken coal is subjected to shock and free fall through a moving air-current.

In this country little attention has been given to the watering of shot coal, although abroad the practice has been adopted extensively. If this is not done then only by making the transference of the coal to the tub or conveyor as smoothly as possible can we effect any reduction in the quantity of airborne dust. In this respect one of the new power loaders which gently eases the shot coal on to the bottom belt of a conveyor is very effective in keeping down the quantity of airborne dust. Some attempts have been made, perhaps not always with the idea of reducing the quantity of airborne dust, to lessen the quantity of fine coal thrown through the air by using forks, and in South Wales the curling box (a hand-filled scoop) instead of shovels.

Before a loaded tub commences its journey outbye the exposed coal should be thoroughly watered and, during its journey, shock should be minimised by careful attention to the track. Low haulage speeds, of course, by reducing the relative movement between the coal and the air, reduce the quantity of dust blown from the tops of the tubs.

At conveyor transfer points and loading points the shock to the coal and the free fall should be reduced to a minimum by employing low belt speeds and carefully designed chutes. These points should as far as possible be isolated from the ventilating current by means of cowlings — a brattice covered box frame placed over the transfer point can effect a really surprising reduction in the quantity of dust raised into the air at that point, and an effective cowling over a loading point may be almost as good as a dust extractor.

It should be obvious that we have, as yet, touched only the fringe of dust suppression, and I cannot escape the feeling that many of the means of dust suppression have been merely incidental to some other purpose — for example, I don't suppose for one moment that the automatic gummer, excellent as it is in preventing the formation of dust, was designed with that as its sole, or even main objective. These methods should not, however, be disparaged on that account — they merely point the moral that good engineering and dust prevention are usually synonymous — but I do feel that when dust suppression is accorded individual attention immense strides will be made very quickly.

Air Cleaning.

So far we have been concerned only with preventing the formation of dust, and keeping out of the air that which has been made, but it is inevitable that throughout the whole series of mining operations some dust will become airborne, and then it must be, or should be, taken out of the air again, for it is this dust which assumes a pathological significance and is mainly responsible for the road dust problem.

Here we enter the field of air cleaning, a process which, in some form or other, has its application in almost every branch of industry, and increasingly so in the domestic sphere. The subject has been studied intensively. It is now almost an exact science, and there is a vast amount of knowledge available if We are ready to use it.

To separate the dust from the air the particles are obstructed mechanically, as with the dry filter, where the air is passed through very fine interstices in which the dust is retained ; or they are allowed to settle out of the air by gravitational force ; or they are wetted and caused to impinge on a wetted surface where they adhere, as in the scrubber; or advantage is taken of their momentum and inertia to cause them to move towards a fixed surface, where again they adhere and, because of the low skin air velocity, are not again made airborne, as in the impingement, centrifugal and vortex separators ; or they are subjected to an additional force which causes them to move towards a fixed surface, as in the electrostatic precipitator. A dust separating plant may combine more than one of the foregoing principles, and the possibility of other methods in the future is not excluded.

All air cleaning plants are not equally efficient nor equally suited for any particular duty, and the selection of a separator requires the consideration of many factors, such as (1) the quantity of air to be cleaned, (2) the concentration of dust in the air, (3) the degree of separation required, (4) the permissible pressure drop across the separator, (5) the space available for installing the separator and (6) the explosion risk.

The electrostatic precipitator, in which the dusty air is drawn between two electrodes, one of which is earthed and the other charged to a high potential, the dust being driven towards the earthed electrode, has been used, I believe, in the gold mines of the Witwatersrand, but it has not yet found any place in the coal mines of this country. All the other forms of dust separator have been used underground at some time or other. The mine itself, of course, is a very effective dust separator — I am often surprised at the very small percentage of dust made airborne which leaves the mine via the upcast shaft — but, intriguing as the idea may be, it is not usual to work inside a dust separator.

(To be continued).


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Staton, Walter    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
01 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 May 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Jun 1943  Some Aspects Of Mine Dust Suppression (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print