9th January 1943, Page: 164, Column: 1
Ventilation And Deep Mining Limit
At the April meeting of the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining Society of South
Africa Mr. R. A. H. Flugge-de Smidt read a paper on "Ventilation
— is it a Limiting Factor in Deep Level Mining on the Witwatersrand
?" In attempting to answer the question contained in the title, he assumed
that they were about to open up an entirely new deep level proposition on the
Central Rand, and that the character of the shafts and the general layout would
be dictated solely by the requirements of ventilation regardless, for the time
being, of any economic limitations in the winning of gold.
Some Known Factors.
The author pointed out that there are certain known factors, such as the
geothermic gradient and the effect of adiabatic compression, while the
temperature and humidity of the air entering a mine can be controlled. The
limit of human comfort as defined by temperature and humidity and velocity of
air can be fairly reasonably assessed.
Recent research work has resulted in what he believes to be a fairly accurate
determination of the virgin rock temperature at a depth of 7,700 feet on the
Central Rand. The Observed temperature was 100.6°F., giving a geothermic
gradient of 4.62°F. per 1,000 feet, or a reciprocal gradient of 1°F.
per 216 feet.
The rise in temperature of air descending a shaft due to adiabatic compression
has been given in text books, both English and German, as 5.5°F. per 1,000
feet or 1°C. per 100 m., but he prefers the more accurate figure of
5.26°F. per 1,000 feet.
The temperature and humidity of air entering a mine can be controlled to almost
any extent. For his purpose the author assumed that the air supplied to the
mine would be kept at the point of delivery, i.e., at the entrance to the
shaft, at a constant temperature of 40°F. saturated.
In order to obtain a proper cooling effect in any saturated or nearly saturated
atmosphere round about 85°F air movement is absolutely necessary, but with
a wet-bulb of 85°F. and a very much higher dry-bulb, say, 120°F. air
velocity is not so necessary; a high air velocity can have a parching effect on
the human body.
For the purposes of discussion it was assumed that the downcast shafts,
vertical and sub-vertical and all the approaches to the stopes could be kept
absolutely dry.
Surface Refrigeration.
Giving his conclusions Mr. Flugge-de Smidt said the one outstanding
feature of the discussion that cannot be too strongly emphasised is the fact
that very great benefits are to be obtained by keeping the downcast shafts and
intake airways dry.
On the Central Rand dry air conditions without surface refrigeration will
probably allow of mining down to 9,000 ft. or a little more, but under wet
conditions 8,000 ft. would most likely be the limit.
On the Far East Rand it would be imperative to resort to dry shafts and airways
to mine much beyond 6,000 ft. in depth.
On the Central Rand surface refrigeration would, from a purely ventilation
point of view, allow of mining to a depth of 12,000 ft. and more. For other
districts this limit would be governed by the geothermic gradient.
Whether an atmosphere of 85°F. wet-bulb and 120°F. dry-bulb is better
than an atmosphere of 85°F. at or near saturation is a matter that is open
to controversy, but it is certain that the only way in which to keep the
wet-bulb down as low as possible is to maintain the dry bulb as near as
possible to rock temperature. The wet-bulb temperature will always remain the
limiting factor.
Heat Exchange.
In the course of his remarks seconding the vote of thanks to the author
Professor C. W. Riccard Jeppe said that on the Witwatersrand, the wet
Kata-thermometer is commonly used as a measure of the cooling capacity of the
air on the human body at work under conditions of high temperatures. The bases
of wet Katathermometer charts and tables are: (1) The wet-bulb temperature
(which is the true measure of the heat in air), and (2) the air velocity.
Experiments have shown that the influence of dry-bulb temperatures on wet
Katathermometer readings is very small: so that the wet Katathermometer leading
that is the cooling capacity of the air, at, say, 130/85°F. is
approximately the same as at 85°F. saturated (at the sama air velocity).
On first principles, of course, since it is the wet-bulb temperature which
represents the heat in air, the heat transfer from air at 130°/85°F. or
at 85°/85°F. to a body, say, at a temperature or 97.0°F., must
balance out very closely.
Giving some actual figures, Professor Jeppe pointed out that the
proportions of heat exchange remain approximately the same, whatever estimates
may be made of exposed body area, air velocity, etc. ; in other words,
theoretically, and taking only the stated factors into consideration, the
amount of perspiration required under hot, dry conditions is very much greater
than under hot, moist conditions.
The problem, however, he proceeded to say, is not nearly as simple as it
appears at first sight; there are a number of other factors which may possibly
influence the position and have to be taken into account, such as :—
(1) The heat radiation from a body covered with perspiration is much greater
than that from a dry body.
(2) The heat transfer from a hot body is much greater to saturated air than to
dry air.
(3) Perspiration has a high specific heat, and the loss of perspiration in
large quantities has a considerable cooling effect on the body, outside the
evaporation factor.
(4) The "aridity " of the air, or its capacity for taking up
moisture, may affect the position.
(5) The human body, as has often been pointed out, differs greatly in a number
of ways from the ventilated wet Kata-thermometer. There are a number of
intricate physiological reactions which play their part in the adjustment of
the body heat to surrounding conditions. Thus, although the same basic cooling
capacity is available in saturated air as in dry air of the same wet-bulb
temperature (at the same air velocity), yet this cooling capacity may function
with different degrees of efficiency under dry air as opposed to moist air
conditions. Thus it is possible that although hot, moist air conditions only
theoretically require, say, half the amount of perspiration as hot, dry air
conditions, yet in actual fact, the human body, acting in its mysterious way,
may find itself forced to provide an equal or even a much greater quantity of
perspiration under the moist air conditions than under the dry air conditions.
There is clearly still great scope for further investigation of these and other
influencing factors.
Need for Definite information.
Mr. J. P. Rees also contributed to the discussion, and regarding the
need for definite Information, he said :
"With regard to observations and the heat problem, so little has been done
systematically and so little has been published that almost the whole field is
open. We do not know how the geothermal gradient varies from one part of the
Witwatersrand to another, and we do not know what local variations there are.
The Hot and Deep Mines' Temperature Committee established in Great Britain that
if a sufficient volume of air passed down a shaft it was virtually insulated
from the heat contained in the earth's strata during the working life of the
mine. This has certainly not been systematically checked for the much deeper
and generally wetter shafts of the Witwatersrand. When we leave the shaft
system we have no systematic guide as to the effect of heat from the rock on
the temperature of the air. Undoubtedly observations have been made and a body
of experience exists which is of great value, but there is no definite
information. The same applies to the stopes. We know that we can cool the air
artificially but we cannot forecast accurately the results in the working
places. We know that we could insulate the airways to some extent, but we have
no accurate figures for the effect of this. We know that the passage of huge
volumes of air through the working places can, theoretically, carry us to any
depths at present contemplated, but we do not know what can be expected from
such volumes of air as can be circulated through the available shaft system. We
know that in this battle time is on our side and that the greater length of
time that airways and working places are left open the cooler they will become
so long as ventilation is maintained, but we know little more. We know that the
heat problem presents different aspects in a flat mine and a steep mine, but we
do not know in which it is easier to solve. I have no doubt we have decided
opinions on all these points, though not perhaps decisive opinions."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jeppe, C. W. Riccard, Prof. | | | |
| Rees, J. P. | | | |
| Smidt, R. A. H. Flugge-de | | | |