Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th December 1942, Page: 151, Column: 2

Uses Of Concrete Underground

With Special Reference to Concrete Props

Extracts from paper presented on 12th December at meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.

By L. C. Maitland, M.I.Min.E.

In view of the present supply position of steel and timber for mining purposes it is necessary to consider every possible substitute. Perhaps the substitute which can be applied to more uses than any other is concrete.

The ingredients normally used in concrete are cement, sand, coarse aggregate and water. Cement is the most expensive ingredient and it should be protected from the weather and kept free from moisture. For preference it should be stocked on boards raised above the ground — bricks can be used to support the boards. Much wastage of cement occurs because the bags have been allowed to get damp ; the cement which is in contact with the wet bag becomes hard and that further inside gets lumpy and particularly wet. The moisture in the air combines with the cement and forms airset lumps and loses some of its value as cement; the concrete made from this is not so strong. Cement should be stored in such a way that it is used in the order in which it arrives.

The term sand is applied to the fine aggregate used in concrete ; it also includes the fine crushings from granite, whinstone and limestone.

Coarse aggregate is the large material used in concrete, and usually forms the greater proportion of the materials used ; it consists of shingle, broken stone (granite, whinstone, limestone, etc.), broken brick, etc.

Water is the cheapest ingredient and yet one of the most important. More concrete is spoiled by water than by any other factor. Speaking generally the smaller the quantity of water used the stronger the concrete, but sufficient water must be used to enable the men to handle the mixture for placing. Less water can be used when the concrete is vibrated. It is important to remember that every drop of water added over and above what is required reduces the strength of the concrete. The great aim should be to use the smallest quantity of water necessary to obtain the workability for the purpose for which the concrete is required. The ideal consistency is such that when the concrete has been well tamped, no excess water appears on the surface. A fairly common water cement ratio is 0.54 ; the water cement ratio is obtained by dividing the weight of the water by the weight of the cement.

The finished product is concrete. If the mixing is performed by hand there should be a clean level surface on which to mix the aggregate, sand and cement; if a concrete surface is not available, get a number of boards and join them close together so that the water and cement will not run away between them, and use this as the mixing platform. Spread the coarse aggregate on the platform, spread the cement over this, and then the sand over the cement.

Where larger quantities of concrete are made, it is usually mixed by machine, when the aggregate, cement and sand are measured into the skip, which lifts it up and drops it into the mixer or drum ; if a no-skip mixer is used the concrete is filled into the drum by hand.

The necessity of reinforcement of concrete props may be stated as follows :—

1. It prevents the props breaking across when treated roughly.

2. It increases the strength of the prop under load, the spiral coil being particularly valuable in this respect, The vertical reinforcement should be attached to the spiral coil, and the whole placed as near to the circumference of the prop as is practicable in construction ; this ensures correct positioning, because it fits the mould, and simplifies the placing of the concrete by the freedom from obstruction in the centre of the prop section. Tests show that with the reinforcement close to the circumference of the prop the concrete is 39 per cent. stronger than with the reinforcement at a depth of 1 inch.

3. It prevents sudden and complete failure of the prop when overloaded. Without reinforcement the prop is dangerous in this respect.

The vertical reinforcement may consist of steel rods or of strands from old wire ropes ; the rods vary in size from ¼-inch diameter to 7/16-inch diameter according to the length and section of the prop ; the rope strands from 3/8-inch diameter to 5/8-inch diameter. The spiral reinforcement is made from 8 to 10 s.w. gauge mild steel wire with l½-inch or 2-inch pitch. The Safety in Mines Research Board specification requires about 8 per cent. of steel by weight for reinforcement in order to give the props reasonable resistance to bending and sudden failure under load.

Concrete Props in Use.

Example 1 : At a group of collieries in the North of England, concrete props have been used for a number of years. More than 28,000 of these props are in use underground in haulage roads, return airways, travelling roads, drifts, back caunches and auxiliary haulage roads — where there is no movement in the strata. Of the 28,000 props installed, approximately 4½ per cent. have failed and about 1.4 per cent. are lost per annum.

One of the seams in which these props are being used was visited a few months ago. The seam is 6 feet thick with a medium hard coarse shale roof, which falls readily and heavily ; a fairly hard seggar floor ; dry, inclination about 1 in 10, a somewhat faulted area, the average depth being 665 feet. The system of working in the district visited is "bord and pillar" and the following observations were made in the last pillar to be extracted before reaching the shaft pillars. Access to the district is through a single track centrally located main airway, the dimensions of which had been 6 feet 6 inches high by 9 feet 6 inches wide, but are now — close to the face — about 4 feet by 5 feet with irregular workings about 120-150 feet wide on either side.

It was observed that where the stress had been heavy and the accommodation of the cap practically all taken up, the cap was acting as a shroud and holding on to the peripheral chipping of the concrete. Where, however, hard contact had been made between the concrete prop and the steel joist, such chipping tended to become sphering ; but in every instance the prop was still functioning.

The props are set with a 6-inch outward splay. In many instances they are now 18 inches — 30 inches into the floor and have been squeezed 24 inches inwards, i.e., 18 inches off the vertical. Usually chipping, occasionally slight flaking, can be observed on the high edge of the leaning props. Another point observed was that no props had failed due to lateral pressure although there was ample evidence of application of side stress.

Example 2 : At another North of England group of collieries concrete props have been used for several years with considerable success. About 8,000 concrete props have been consumed of which about 60 per cent. were made by the Colliery Company and the remainder by Messrs. Samuel Tyzack and Co., Ltd., of Sunderland. These props have been installed in five seams, varying in depth from 200 feet to 540 feet and in thickness from 2 feet to 3 feet 9 inches. In two of the seams the roof is a post stone, and the floor is strong seggar ; in the other three the roof is Blue Metal and the floor in two in seggar and in the third Grey Metal.

Two seams were visited in which concrete props are used, the thickness of the seams being 3 feet 9 inches and 2 feet 5 inches respectively ; the inclination is 1 in 10 ; depth about 600 feet, floor and roof damp but coal dry. The system of working is "stepped longwall."

The main road is being affected, in many places, by the weight being flung on it by the extraction of a seam 2 feet 3 inches thick, about 90 feet below. Generally the concrete props have stood up to this extra weighting well, and where the movement has produced hard contact slight peripheral flaking has resulted. On the whole it appeared that the concrete props, aided by the caps and soles and the degree of floor penetration (due to the floor disruption), had withstood the results of the lower seam extraction in a manner to make it reasonably practical to advocate the continued use of concrete props.

At one of their collieries they have tried concrete props on stilts in roadways close to the face, in unsettled ground. The stilts allow for a settlement of the roof of about six inches ; this is usually taken up within a few days; the prop is then drawn and moved up to the face, a shorter prop being set in its place. A number of wood props have been saved by this experiment. The chief difficulty is the fixing of the stilts, which has to be done carefully, otherwise they are either too tight — breaking the stilts, or too loose — which cancels the object of the stilt. It has been found necessary to get an official to do this job.

Example 3 : At another colliery in the North of England 6,710 concrete props were made at the pit and put into use during the timber shortage of the last war (1914-1918). The props are 6 feet and 7 feet by 5 inches square, the edges being slightly chamfered; they are reinforced with longitudinal steel rods, but have no spiral binding. They were set in well settled ground, and are all apparently as good as when set some 25 years ago, A number which have been removed, during repairs or alterations, have been reset elsewhere.

Example 4 : At several collieries in the Midlands concrete props have been used since the last war in seams 300 to 400 yards deep. At one colliery several hundred have been installed over the last three or four years in settled ground in pillar and stall workings where they have been found much more durable than timber.

Example 5 : Lagging Blocks : This is a very interesting example of the use of concrete blocks in roadways in thick seams varying from 3 feet 10 inches to 7 feet 6 inches on an inclination of 1 in 3.5 at a depth of between 400 and 600 yards.

One of the roadways was lined in 1937, and though in several places the lagging blocks were broken the reinforcement held them in position, and at no point have they had to be replaced. As a matter of fact since this road was lined a conveyor face has been taken along its line in a seam approximately 26 yards above it which proves further that concrete slabs will stand up well to fairly heavy practical pressure.

What Tests Proved.

In the course of experimental work numerous tests were made at King's College, Newcastle, which tended to prove that props made to the Ministry of Mines' suggested specification are about six times as resistant to crushing strain as wood props of the same sectional area.

From tests made it appears that the vertical and spiral reinforcement adds little, if anything, to the load-carrying capacity of the props ; it does, however, add greatly to the prop's resistance to accidental damage due to careless handling and greatly restricts the danger from "bursting" if the prop should collapse under pressure.

The miner's objection to the fact that the concrete props do not "talk" is to some extent discounted by the fact that under undue pressure, but some considerable time before collapses, they "Flake," — usually from the bottom but sometimes from the top, and this "flaking" being almost white requires very little light to be visible on the dark floor.

We can accept concrete props as a useful material in settled ground, and possibly after further experience in roadways in unsettled ground by using stilts. With care in withdrawing they can be re-used many times, and when set in settled ground they will last for many years.

Concrete is roughly intermediate in its compression characteristics between timber and steel. There seems to be little to choose from between the burring of the timber prop top, the sphering of the concrete and the deformation of the steel prop top. In many conditions a good wood sole is a useful cushion saver. Experience indicates that adequate bearing surface should be allowed at the prop head, so that full use may be made of the cross fibre resistance of the lid.

The concrete prop is of course fire-resistant and proof against organic decay.

Once the workmen have become used to concrete props they accept them fairly readily, but it is advisable to commence their use gradually ; generally speaking it takes two men to set them and probably the cost will be higher. They must be handled more carefully than either wood or steel, but if well designed and reinforced they will resist medium rough handling.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Maitland, Lionel Clinton      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print