28th November 1942, Page: 123, Column: 1
Carbon Dioxide In Mine Dusts
New Method of Determination
The fourth report of the General Research Committee of the Monmouthshire and
South Wales Coal Owners' Association describes a new and rapid method for the
determination of carbon dioxide in mine dusts. It is recalled in the Preface
that one of the Mine Regulations stipulates that the analyses of mine dust
samples shall be posted up at the pithead within twenty-one days of the samples
being collected, and the suggestion is that in all probability this Regulation
will be more rigidly enforced in the future. The development of the new method
is explained in the report. The apparatus required for the determination can be
made in any laboratory out of a boiling tube, a stout glass bottle, a few
rubber bungs, a length of rubber tubing and a couple of pieces of bent glass
tubing. An acknowledgment is made to
Mr. Norman T. Simmons, F.C.S.,
F.Inst.F., the Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries chief chemist, who brought
the problem to the notice of the Committee and co-operated with the Committee's
investigator,
Mr. J. Howard Griffiths, M.P.
Regulations Quoted.
Whilst no attempt is made to stress the importance of the carbon dioxide
content of mine dusts, reference is made to the Coal Mines Regulations which
state (M. and Q. Form 128) that a mine dust, sampled according to the
Regulations, shall contain at least a certain percentage of incombustible
matter, depending upon the volatile content of the coal. In the case of
collieries using carbonate stone dusts, this incombustible matter is
represented by the sum of the free moisture in the mine dust, determined at the
residue on ignition at 950°C, and the carbon dioxide, all expressed as
percentages by weight.
The Regulations also state that the carbon dioxide shall be determined in the
following manner :—
"B. (iii) A weighed quantity of the sieved dust shall be treated with
dilute hydrochloric acid in a suitable apparatus, and the weight of carbon
dioxide evolved from the dust shall be either (a) determined directly, or (b)
calculated from the volume of carbon dioxide evolved, or (c) determined by any
other manner approved by the Board of Trade."
There are several methods available for the determination of carbon dioxide
which conform with the above Regulation. The chief of these are :—
(1) Volumetric determination by means of a suitable form of calcimetor ;
(2) Volumetric determination by back titration with a standard alkali solution
;
(3) Gravimetric determination by means of a Schroedter flask ;
(4) Gravimetric determination by drying the gas evolved on boiling the dust
with acid and then passing it through a suitable absorbent contained in a
weighed vessel.
The General Regulations and Orders relating to Safety and Health stipulate that
"samples of dust shall be systematically collected and analysed, and, in
respect of roads used for the transport of coal, and of return airways within
200 yards of the working face, the number of samples collected and analysed
during each calendar month shall not be fewer (except with the consent in
writing of the Inspector) than in the proportion of ten per mile of those roads
and airways."
Any method used must be approved by the Board of Trade.
Description of Apparatus.
In an article by Mr. E. B. Hughes (J.S.C.I., Vol. 61, No. 9, 1942)
mention was made of an apparatus used for the quick determination of carbon
dioxide in baking powders, and the like. "The carbon dioxide is evolved in
an evacuated space of fixed volume, the resulting increase in pressure
measured, and from this, corrected to 0°C, the weight of CO2 is
obtained by direct reading from a graph obtained by treating pure sodium
bicarbonate in a similar way." The Committee realised the possibility of
using this method for the determination of carbon dioxide in mine dusts. After
many trials, the following apparatus was found to be best suited for use with
mine dusts.
The apparatus shown in Figure 1 consisted of a stout glass reaction flask A, of
about 200 ccs. capacity, fitted with a bung carrying an outlet tube B and a
dropping funnel C. The outlet tube was connected, via a drying tube D,
containing calcium chloride or anhydrous silica gel, to a mercury manometer E,
and a three-way tap F, by means of a T-piece. One leg of the three-way tap
opened to atmosphere, and the other was connected to a vacuum pump. The
dimensions as scaled from Figuee 1 should be roughly adhered to, as experience
has shown that they are the most suitable. The apparatus is connected together
by means of good rubber pressure tubing, and the taps and joints should have a
large surface of contact as they have to Withstand a pressure of about 40-45
cms. mercury (approximately 8 lb. per square inch) without leaking.
After a few preliminary tests, the following procedure was adopted. Exactly 0.5
grm. of calcium carbonate was placed in the reaction flask, and 10 ccs. of 1 :
1 hydrochloric acid containing 2 per cent. Perminal were poured into the
dropping funnel. The three-way tap was then turned so as to connect the
apparatus to the vacuum pump. When the desired vacuum was obtained (this was
determined in the preliminary tests to be about 40 cms. mercury) the three-way
tap was closed. The acid was then run into the reaction flask, care being taken
to see that no air leaked in through the tap on the dropping funnel. The
reaction flask was then shaken to ensure complete contact between the reagents.
When the reaction had ceased the manometer was read, and the increase in
pressure due to the addition of 10 ccs. of acid and the evolution of carbon
dioxide was recorded.
It was also noted that the volume occupied by 0.5 grm. of inert solid material
had little or no influence on the reading of the manometer.
A series of determinations was made using known weights of calcium carbonate,
and observing the increases in pressure in the apparatus. The volume of carbon
dioxide liberated in each case was calculated, and working on a basis of 0.5
grm. of substance being used in the reaction flask, the percentage carbon
dioxide was calculated.
It was thought at first that, as the relationship between percentage and volume
of carbon dioxide is linear, and the relation between volume and pressure is a
rectangular parabola, the resultant curve obtained by plotting the increase in
pressure against the percentage carbon dioxide would be a curve somewhat
between a straight line and a rectangular parabola. The graph actually obtained
by plotting the results, which are given in Table, was a straight line.
The accuracy of the apparatus will obviously depend upon the accuracy with
which the scale is made. Experience has shown that, with care, it is possible
to construct a scale reading to within +- 0.2 per cent.
The Report gives a more detailed study of the theory on which the apparatus was
based, the method of calibration, and design of an improved form of apparatus
for general use.
Conclusions.
The results of the work recorded in the Report show that the vacuum apparatus
method is :—
(1) Ideally suited for the determination of carbon dioxide in mine dust.
(2) Accurate within 0.5 per cent., when determining carbon dioxide contents,
and compares very favourably with results obtained by the Calcimeter and
Schroedter flask methods.
(3) More rapid than either of the above-mentioned methods. Determinations can
be carried out in from 5 to 7 minutes.
(4) Simple, requiring no elaborate technique, and can therefore be used with
speed and accuracy even by unskilled attendants.
(5) Due to the reduced pressure, the solubility of the carbon dioxide is so low
that it is not necessary to heat the reaction flask.
The following points should, however, be stressed :—
(1) The apparatus should be calibrated by an experienced chemist, and care
should be taken to ensure that an accurate scale is drawn and correctly fixed
to the manometer.
(2) In the case of a part of the apparatus being replaced by another, then the
apparatus must be re-calibrated. This will take a skilled analyst only about
half-an-hour.
(3) The calcium chloride drying tube will want re-charging from time to time.
After re-charging, re-calibrate the apparatus. This can be obviated if
impregnated silica gel is used in the drying tube. This silica gel is saturated
in an indicator which changes from blue to pink as the gel absorbs the water.
When the gel is all pink, disconnect the tube and dry in the drying oven until
the colour is restored to blue. Re-connect the tube to the apparatus, which
will not require re-calibrating.
(4) In the case of greasy or oily substances, it is advisable to add a solvent
of low vapour pressure such as benzyl benzoate.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Griffiths, J. Howard | | M.P. | |
| Hughes, E. B. | | | |
| Simmons, Norman T. | | Chief Chemist | |