|
14th November 1942, Page: 113, Column: 1 Colliery Officials' ExaminationsIn his presidential address delivered at the October meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers, Lt.-Col. H. B. B. Daniell, M.C., M.A., dealt with the question of suitable papers for reading and discussion. His suggestions included papers on emergency roof supports ; the practice of mine ventilation ; problems connected with miners' ailments and injuries ; fire-fighting and the use of water underground in the course of operations ; also the question whether coal cutters, inbye pumps, conveyors or other inbye plant of small power could be run without long cable or pipe lines. The president devoted the second part of his address to matters related to mining examinations. He said that no less unhealthy than the loss of entry of boys to the mines is the lack of successful competitors for the managerial side. It is not due to any lack of candidates, but that the candidates do not satisfy the examiners. Having studied the questions set for a good many years he thinks the real fault lies in the regulations governing the examinations, and the very abstruse state into which the Mines Act and amending regulations have now drifted. Extracts from this section of the president's address are appended. "A statutory examination should concern itself primarily with matters of safety and health. It should also, of course, ensure that the candidate should have sufficient knowledge, education and practical experience to enable him to apply his knowledge. It seems that the syllabus of the second class certificate contains all that is required to comply with these conditions. The present syllabus for first and second class certificates, when first read, seems simple and easy, and one which all intelligent candidates should easily master. If the examination was strictly confined to its main intentions, more candidates would pass. The aim of the examiner should be to find out if the candidate really knows the ABC of the job, such as things which he has under observation in the daily course of his work. If he knows the ABC, as he grows older he will teach himself the DEF, and if lucky and very wise may ultimately attain to the WXYZ. It is fairly easy to set questions on all the subjects in the syllabus so as to be fair to candidates from all districts, except the subject 'Winning and Working.' This is the living subject in the whole examination, and quite rightly has the highest marks allotted to it. Text books and education authorities can do little to teach it. It can only be learnt in the mine by practical experience. Main principles can be laid down about it in books, but the practical pitman is always going one better in his own underground conditions and many of his successes are never recorded. It is impossible to set fair questions on this most important subject for all districts in one examination paper owing to the great variation in underground conditions in the different coalfields. If the present examination system for other subjects is adhered to, the examination on 'Winning and Working' should be decentralised to the districts and organised by local examiners in each district, who could set fairer questions within the practical knowledge of themselves and the candidates, and in the mining language which they both understand. Colliery managers, and still more under-managers, mostly stay in the districts where they are trained, in spite of a small but brisk export trade in these commodities from Scotland. If a man is a good pitman and master of his trade underground in one district, he will soon master the conditions in another district. Indeed in the same seam in the same mine conditions often alter, and new seams with different conditions may be opened out. "There is undoubtedly a shortage of suitable men to fill colliery managers posts. Many excellent under-managers are debarred from further promotion owing to the impossibility, owing to middle age or other causes, of their satisfying the examiners for their first class tickets. Not only is this unfair on the men themselves, but they are a loss to the industry. This might be got over by the institution of a special class of service first class certificates. The regulations governing these might be as follows : (1) Age not below 30 years. (2) At least three years' actual service as under-manager. (3) Application to be made by an owner or agent to fill a definite managerial post, and application in the first place to be granted only to fill that post. (4) After four years' service in that post the service certificate may become an ordinary first class certificate of competency. (5) Applications to be judged by a local panel of mining engineers, who will satisfy themselves as to the applicant's fitness for the post on the same lines as if they were appointing a manager, but without a written or oral examination. They would also satisfy themselves that the owner or agent was not putting forward the application in order to obtain a manager at "sweated" wages. "It has been advocated that colliery engineers should have to sit for an examination and obtain a certificate. This would have the effect of legalising the present practice of the manager in delegating much of his responsibility under this head to the engineer. It would also enable the present syllabus for the manager's certificate examination relating to mechanical and electrical engineering to be made easier, if not abolished. It is hard to understand why a similar course was not taken as regards surveying in the 1911 Coal Mines Act. It has further been suggested that overmen, enginewrights and head electricians should also pass statutory examinations, and this has much to be said for it, as their duties carry considerable responsibility. "If, as seems probable, a new certificate is instituted for colliery engineers, in addition to the two present certificates for colliery managers and surveyors, it seems logical that both surveying and engineering should be removed from the syllabus for colliery managers' and under-managers' certificates. The certified surveyors, as now, will have a statutory responsibility, and the engineers will join them. It might be objected that small mines could not afford all three, but this difficulty could be met by the work being carried out by firms of certified consultants in the case of engineering and surveying. In this connection, it would be necessary to have two grades of engineer's certificate on the same lines as the colliery managers' and under-managers' certificates, and all mines would have to permanently employ a second-grade man qualified to enforce the Coal Mines Act."
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||